Updated

Scotland’s Jewish community ‘terrified’ after synagogue attack

Pro-Palestine protesters take over Edinburgh Waverley <i>(Image: NQ)</i>
Pro-Palestine protesters take over Edinburgh Waverley (Image: NQ)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Scotland’s Jewish community is “really terrified” following the Manchester terror attack and a wave of pro-Palestine demonstrations that saw “slogans of just absolute Jew hate being shouted".

Scottish Tory MSP Jackson Carlaw, who represents Eastwood in East Renfrewshire, home to a significant proportion of the country’s Jewish population, said there was an “unprecedented level of alarm and fear” among his constituents.


READ MORE:


Large crowds carrying Palestinian flags and signs gathered at train stations across the country, including Glasgow Central and Edinburgh Waverley, where they attempted to stop passengers boarding trains.

They were protesting Israel’s interception of the Global Sumud Flotilla, which was carrying aid for Gaza. A number of activists on board vessels were detained, including four Scots.

The demonstrations came just hours after Jihad Al-Shamie drove into a group of people outside Heaton Park Hebrew Congregation Synagogue before stabbing a man.

Two men were killed in the terror attack: Martin Daulby, 53, and Melvin Cravitz, 66. Three others remain in hospital with serious injuries. Al-Shamie was shot dead by police seven minutes after officers were alerted.

At Waverley, rail travellers faced significant disruption and passengers had to be escorted onto platforms by police.

A central London demonstration saw activists clash with police outside Downing Street, leading to 40 arrests.

Mr Carlaw told the BBC’s Good Morning Scotland: “The Jewish community is a small community in Scotland and a relatively small community across the whole of the United Kingdom,” Mr Carlaw said. “They felt safe and secure in this country for decades, but I am afraid at the moment, they are really, really terrified.

“Events internationally involving the Government of Israel should not be conflated with the Jewish people living in this country. It is an entirely different thing, but the focus of attention is directly on them now, and they feel afraid to go about their daily lives, and that is just unacceptable."

He said there had been an increase in direct and indirect antisemitism in his constituency.

“If you start wandering around seeing graffiti saying death to all Jews. When you walk out of Edinburgh Waverley station, on the walls opposite on Market Street, you will see incitements to kill Jews. This is unacceptable, and no wonder people are scared and intimidated.”

Mr Carlaw added there were “others who I think have been complicit in not moderating their rhetoric and not understanding that there are those who will hijack any issue, because latently and deeply within them, there is an antisemitism which has always been there, but which we, the majority, have got to stand disgusted by and confront”.

Protesters at Edinburgh Waverley(Image: NQ)

John Swinney made a private visit to the Edinburgh Hebrew Congregation on Thursday night, where the Scottish Government said he was able to "reiterate his solidarity with Scotland’s Jewish community."

The First Minister also received a briefing from the UK Government Security Minister, and Scotland’s Justice Secretary has had further conversations with the Chief Constable of Police Scotland to "ensure every necessary step is being taken in Scotland to provide reassurance to Jewish communities."

Mr Swinney said: “The horror of the violence inflicted upon the Jewish Community with the Heaton Park attack is utterly unimaginable. I cannot stress enough my sympathy with those families and their friends who have lost their loved ones, and my solidarity with the Jewish community in Scotland and across the whole of the United Kingdom.

“I know just what a distressing time this is for our Jewish communities, with fears and worry over the consequences of Heaton Park playing on their mind. I can assure our Jewish community that we will do everything necessary to ensure their continued safety, and additional security and policing is in place around synagogues and Jewish community venues.

“When society is faced with unimaginable horror, we must take solace in the things that unite us. We must stand firm against those that seek to divide us. Now more than ever, division and all form of hatred – especially evil antisemitism – must be rejected and I urge communities across Scotland to stand firm against those that seek to divide our country."

Scottish Secretary Douglas Alexander met with the congregation at the community at Giffnock Synagogue on Friday morning.

“With a heavy heart, I listened to their horror at yesterday’s attack," he said. "I felt deeply the fear that the community in Scotland expressed around rising anti-Semitism and the way in which yesterday’s attack confirmed those deep anxieties. 

“My father was a Church of Scotland Minister and as a child I would walk with him into our church each Sunday.  In 2025, it is a source of deep shame that some Scots have to walk to their place of worship in fear each week and are forced to put in place security measures at holy places and even at schools. 

“Terrorism always seeks to divide but as communities in both in Manchester and East Renfrewshire have shown us, they will not succeed.”

The terrorist attack in Manchester came on Yom Kippur, the holiest day of the Jewish calendar, when many do not look at their phones or TV until after prayers finish at 7.30pm.

Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood told Sky News she was “very disappointed" by the protests that took place last night.

“I think that behaviour is fundamentally un-British. I think it is dishonourable," she said. "I would have wanted those individuals to just take a step back.

“The issues that are driving those protests have been going on now for some time; they do not look like they are going to come to an end any day soon.

“They could have stepped back and just given a community that has suffered deep loss just a day or two to process what has happened and to carry on with the grieving process.”

The Met has written to protest group Defend Our Juries, which plans to hold a march on Saturday, asking that it does not go ahead following the Crumpsall attack.

A letter from the force shared by Defend Our Juries raised concerns about the amount of police resources the protest would divert at a time when “visible reassurance and protective security” is needed in communities across London.

But the protest group, which has led demonstrations against the terrorist ban on Palestine Action, said it planned to go ahead.

Police grapple with a protesters who tried to stop passengers getting a train(Image: NQ)

Around 1,500 people, “including priests, vicars, pensioners and healthcare workers”, are expected to get involved.

The Met Police said it will call in support from other forces in the country if necessary, to ensure officers can arrest all those breaking the law in support of Palestine Action, a proscribed terrorist group.

The previous two events have seen a total of 1,422 people arrested, the majority for supporting a proscribed organisation.

A Defend Our Juries spokesman said: “Our thoughts are with everyone who has lost loved ones in the horrific attack on Heaton Park Synagogue and we stand in solidarity with the Jewish community across the UK.

“Many Jewish supporters of Defend Our Juries have warned that postponing tomorrow’s action would risk conflating the actions of the state of Israel with Jewish people around the world, as Netanyahu seeks to do, who bear no responsibility for Israel’s crimes, which could fuel antisemitic hatred and prejudice.

“It couldn’t be clearer that tomorrow’s action, which is in Trafalgar Square and not near any synagogue, is about defying the Government’s absurdly authoritarian proscription of Palestine Action and the Government’s complicity in the genocide being committed by the Israeli Government."

Meanwhile, the UK’s Chief Rabbi has described the murders of Mr Daulby and Mr Cravitz as “the tragic result of Jew hatred”.

Sir Ephraim Mirvis said: “It was the day we hoped we would never see, but which deep down, we knew would come.

“For so long we have witnessed an unrelenting wave of Jew hatred on our streets, on campuses, on social media and elsewhere — this is the tragic result.

“This is not only an assault on the Jewish community, but an attack on the very foundations of humanity and the values of compassion, dignity and respect which we all share.

“May the victims' memories be for a blessing and may the injured be granted a swift recovery.

“I pray that this tragedy strengthens our collective resolve to confront antisemitism, in all its guises, once and for all.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos