For years, the college sector has called out a warning, and although the message it is sending now is much the same, the situation is starkly different.
In January 2024, the college sector was crippled by a prolonged dispute over pay for lecturers and support staff. Although the negotiations at the time were over a specific pay award, they were happening against a backdrop of a decade of dispute and years of dismissing funding from the Scottish Government.
As a result of consistent real-terms cuts in public funding, individual colleges have been finding ways to make savings on an almost annual basis. For years, cuts came mostly from the periphery, but more recently, a growing number of institutions have been making cuts closer to the heart of what colleges are all about: delivering on the education and skills expectations set for them by the Scottish Government and their community stakeholders.
This month, however, new warnings have been issued that these types of cuts could quickly become the norm rather than the exception. In rapid succession, two sweeping reports outlined the financial situation for colleges in terms that have been described as “stark”, “grim”, and “bleak” in equal measure.
The reports, one by the Scottish Funding Council (SFC), the organisation responsible for distributing and overseeing the money that the Scottish Government provides to the sector, and financial watchdog Audit Scotland, were meant to assess colleges’ financial sustainability.
The answer is that the sector is “not sustainable”, and the reports are explicit that multiple colleges face imminent deficits.
Audit Scotland’s report grabbed headlines most recently, highlighting a 20% deduction in real-terms funding for the college sector over the past four years as a primary reason for the sector’s dire straits. Other details in the report are much more telling, however.
And for college insiders, they are much more troubling.
As Gavin Donoghue, CEO of umbrella group Colleges Scotland, put it, it would not be unfair to say that colleges have become victims of their own success, with staff, students and employers repeatedly proving their ability to adapt and deliver despite shrinking support and uneven footing.
But without a significant change in the Scottish Government’s approach, that will not be possible for much longer, he warned.
Like the proverbial shepherd boy, the college sector is again crying wolf by asking for more money. The difference between reality and the fable, however, is that the wolf is and has always been real, and some of the sheep are already missing legs and bleeding out.
Colleges ‘victims of success’
The fact that government funding for colleges has declined in real terms is not news. Every year, a report highlights this fact, and if nothing else, the numbers in each budget settlement tell their own story.
However, within Audit Scotland’s most recent report, there is a figure that many will have read without fully understanding: over the past decade, the collective balance in colleges’ arms-length foundations (ALFs) had reduced from £99 million to £8 million.
ALFs are charitable bodies established in 2014, when incorporated colleges were reclassified as public institutions. They allow colleges to hold cash reserves for future use.
Mr Donoghue explained that the original intent for this money has blurred.
“My understanding is that they should be used for longer-term projects that would benefit the education of college students and help staff, but actually, colleges have had to use that money in order to pay for voluntary severance and make the books balance.”
Read more
- Why Scotland's college sector is fighting for its life
- Colleges have seen funding cut by 20 per cent in five years - watchdog
- Colleges risk insolvency as universities are forced to restructure
- An uncertain future: Universities and college finance troubles go deep
A key point of pride within the college sector is the ability to adapt, but Audit Scotland’s report suggests that changes will begin to impact core delivery:
“Without changes to baseline funding, colleges will have to deliver even less to remain sustainable at a time when demands from students and employers are not being met.
“As college funding is also dependent on credit delivery, there is a risk that colleges prioritise courses that are less expensive to deliver over those that meet local need.”
Mr Donoghue accepted that this is the reality colleges now face.
“Colleges have been victims of their own success by managing the chronic underfunding they’ve had for a number of years and methodically managing this reduction in resources by making sure they keep getting to balanced budgets every year.
“So to the outside world, maybe it looks like they can manage with ever-reducing budgets.
“But we have got to the point now where colleges are as lean and as efficient as they possibly can be. There is no fat left to cut; there’s only body parts left to cut."
In the context of colleges, this is, of course, not just a metaphor. It means decisions that will affect students and staff acutely.
Mr Donoghue added: “To make a balanced budget, college leaders know that they will have to face decisions that will either harm the education of their students or close campuses.”
The brutal reality, he added, is that in a stark financial climate, these closures and “unpalatable decisions” will likely fall most heavily on the more deprived communities that rely on colleges as anchor institutions.
Money, money, money
In response to the recent financial reports, Colleges Scotland and EIS-FELA, the union representing college lecturers, have renewed their calls for an urgent increase in funding from the Scottish Government. As was made clear by the SFC during a meeting of the Scottish Parliament’s Education, Children and Young People Committee this week, a substantial increase in sustained funding is only one part of the required solution: the college sector will also need a systems overhaul.
When asked about the concerns raised by Mr Donoghue and the union, the Scottish Government referred to comments made by Higher and Further Education Minister Ben Macpherson this week in response to an urgent question from Conservative MSP Stephen Kerr.
Mr Kerr asked what the government would do in response to the “reported crisis in the college sector”, and the result was a fiery exchange between Mr Macpherson and multiple MSPs. Mr Macpherson pointed to “austerity policies of successive UK Governments” and an increasingly expensive public sector bill affected by inflation and rising national insurance costs.
The response was met with hostility from across the aisle, and more questions about how the Scottish Government squares the “appreciation and admiration” for colleges that Mr Macpherson described with the real-terms decline in funding.
The exchange eventually wound to a close when Independent MSP John Mason interjected with the question that regularly hovers over debates of this type: if the answer is more money, where is it going to come from?
Share