Exclusive

How philanthropic 'permission to fail' can change lives for the better

3
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Dr Trish Turner and Dr Ewan Kirk both describe themselves as problem solvers.

Turner’s career as an award-winning academic saw her explore some of the most complex issues in early child development, while Kirk’s doctorate in General Relativity led to him becoming a successful tech entrepreneur and investment manager.

But it’s one thing to see yourself as a problem solver, and another to try to back it up while spending considerable sums of your own money.

That is exactly what the Turner Kirk Trust is for.

Their scientific backgrounds have helped the couple to develop an approach that makes them more than willing to critically examine prevailing orthodoxies, and this principle lies behind much of the work that their organisation supports.

As philanthropists they have found themselves “pushing against the received wisdom”, particularly when the things we think we know for sure might, in actual fact, be entirely wrong and, in the worst cases, deeply harmful.

According to Kirk, people in positions like theirs have a duty to speak out:

“When philanthropy gets in the way and actively causes a problem, I think that's the time at which it's beholden on people who believe, with evidence, that they're doing the wrong thing to say loudly: ‘This is not the right thing.’”

But he is also keen to point out that this doesn’t mean trying to take over from state-level institutions, nor are they seeking to fund projects, no matter how worthy, on an indefinite basis. Long-term viability and sustainability, supported by official organisations where necessary, are key.

This is clear with their most recent investment – a new Centre for Spatial Reasoning at the University of Glasgow, which has been established in the hope of boosting the numeracy skills of children in Scotland, especially those from deprived backgrounds and underrepresented groups. The project follows a successful pilot, and is being supported for three more years, but after that point, if the state values the work that has been done, it will have to step in and take over.

Kirk says that even the Gates Foundation, which has paid out tens of billions of pounds since its inception, “cannot replace the state”. Instead, he argues that the role of organisations like the Turner Kirk Trust is to catalyse activity that can lead to better results for people in need, and there are specific aspects of their approach which, they believe, allow them to achieve that goal.

One example of this is seen in Malawi, where the Trust supported SolarAid to install lighting in an off-grid village. This didn’t just directly help those living there, but also enabled the test of a commercial model that could help communities across the continent.

A woman reads underneath a solar light installed in a village in Malawi.(Image: Sofia Ollvid)

A central part of their philosophy is to facilitate, and fund, risk-taking, especially in areas where public bodies might not have the confidence to back the early, experimental stages of a new project.

“If you do something and give some money and it doesn't have an impact,” Kirk says, “you've done a bad thing. That's the received wisdom. Certainly when we started this everyone was talking about impact measurement and all of that kind of thing, which is important, and obviously you don't want to waste money, but it does push back against doing things are high risk, and that's something that we didn't really like.”

Turner adds: “I think, perhaps because we're from different disciplines, we also take a kind of interdisciplinary, or multi-disciplinary, approach to problems.

“We try and look for things where if you take a different perspective from the one currently being taken, you might end up with a different outcome. I work primarily in Africa with maternal and infant health, and what you find there is a lot of money goes into medical clinics. So if you've got a problem like high infant and maternal death in child birth, for example, then a lot of the funding that goes into that is to fund clinics or medical equipment because that's what you think would be the solution to that particular problem.


READ MORE


“But in some places that's not the problem - the problem is a question of geography, or it's a question of logistics. So for instance in the Eastern Cape in South Africa, they have very high infant mortality at childbirth and one of the problems is that the geography of the Eastern Cape is like a series of large mole hills. The huts are dispersed and there's no central village. So if a woman goes into premature labour, it's not that there isn't a clinic, it's that she can't get there.

“She has to walk and it may take her three hours, at which point things have probably become critical.

“Nepal has the same sort of problem. It's a different geography, but their problem is that the rivers run north to south because of the rising of the Himalayas, while the country itself goes east to west.

“So a lot of the connections between villages are east to west and if you're a woman who gets into difficulties then, again, you can't get to your clinic. It's not that there isn't a clinic, it's that you can't access it.

“If you don't look at things from different perspectives you don't necessarily solve the problem on the ground.”

Dr Turner and Dr Kirk during a recent visit to a Glasgow primary school(Image: Turner Kirk Centre)

This is especially true, and critical, with respect to another of the projects they have backed, the charity Hope and Homes. This international organisation aims to do something that challenges a number of orthodoxies and assumptions: shutting down orphanages.

“We know from research that the outcomes of children in institutions are very poor across physical, cognitive, social and emotional development,” Turner explains. “But one of the things that was very significant is actually that space is being driven by philanthropy.

“So in certain countries there's been a huge increase in the number of orphanages and the increase is actually to meet the needs of the donors. There are so many foreign donors who want to contribute to orphanages.

“In Uganda for instance, they've gone from a thousand orphanages in the early 90s to 50,000 now.

“Similarly in Cambodia, it's being driven by the desire for people to go on orphanage volunteering placements or holidays or gap years. The need to have space for those people has driven the increase in the number of orphanages. You can plot the number of orphanages against the rise in tourism and they almost map exactly.

“So they're businesses. They're not solving the problem of the children. They're looking at it from the perspective of the donors and the participants.

“Participants who do 'voluntourism' report that it makes a transformational change to their lives. They feel like they've had a very good experience and they've really, really helped the children. But it isn't transformational for the child - it's very detrimental from the child's perspective.”

These sorts of challenges are reflected in much of the work supported by the Turner Kirk Trust, and bring with them the very real risk of spending money for minimal, if any, impact. Both of them also recognise that they’re whole approach may be wrong, but believe that by backing risky projects predicated on alternative views of big problems, they can use the wealth they have accrued to make lives a little bit better for others.

“I think our mantra – permission to fail – underpins the approach that we have,” says Trish. “So we don't see failure as a problem. We see it as a kind of springboard to do something better, something different.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos