Scottish independence is the one subject that unites the SNP. It has also been responsible for decades of rammies. Next week, in Aberdeen, First Minister John Swinney will hope to settle the matter once and for all — or at least for the next seven months.
There is no doubt that passion will run high during Saturday’s debate on “Winning independence”, but for some activists, this is about more than the constitution. It is about the very soul of the party.
One told The Herald on Sunday it would be the biggest row at conference since 2012, when members narrowly voted to overturn the SNP’s decades-long ban on Nato membership.
Read more
- Nationalists are now out in front in all four home nations… what comes next?
- Former MP in bid to oust Alex Kerr as SNP national secretary
- SNP member who challenged Swinney bids to be party president as candidates revealed
The First Minister and SNP depute leader Keith Brown have tabled a motion arguing that next year’s Holyrood election should be fought on a “clear platform of national independence” and that the party should aim to replicate its 2011 majority, when it won 69 seats leading to the 2014 referendum.
They say winning at least 65 seats would be the “only uncontested way to deliver a new vote on Scotland’s future”.
If passed in its entirety, the motion would commit the party to making independence the central issue of the 2026 election.
It states: “Conference recognises that how Scotland becomes independent matters. That process must be agreed, democratic, constitutional and legal so that our nation gains recognition both at home and abroad. That process must also seek to maximise participation as part of ensuring popular consent.”
Mr Brown told The Herald on Sunday: “Whether it is Labour, the Tories or the prospect of Nigel Farage becoming Prime Minister, it is crystal clear that Westminster is not serving the people of Scotland.
"Scotland deserves the right to decide our own future and we know that a majority for the SNP is what leads to a referendum.
"By winning an SNP majority at next year’s election, Scotland will be telling the world that no-one, least of all Westminster politicians, can stand in the way of the sovereign people of Scotland exercising their right to choose a better future.”
The most significant challenge is Amendment A, which would scrap key parts of the leadership motion and replace them with a more hardline strategy. It has been backed by more than 40 branches.
It says that Scotland "must extricate itself from the United Kingdom as soon as possible, and it requires a strong SNP government to do this."
If backed it would reinstate the Nicola Sturgeon-era policy that consideration should be given to treating the election as a de facto referendum.
That means if the SNP, or the SNP plus other pro-independence parties, win a majority of the popular vote in 2026, that should be treated as a mandate to negotiate independence directly — not just to demand another referendum.
To achieve that, it would then commit the party to prioritising a majority of the popular vote on the regional list among independence-supporting parties.
It also calls for practical preparations, including a target date, a provisional government to oversee the necessary steps, and an “Independence Delivery Unit”.
The approach has historical echoes. In 1918, Sinn Féin won 73 of 101 Irish seats at the UK general election, treated the result as a mandate for independence, and issued a unilateral declaration of an Irish Republic.
That precedent ultimately led to the creation of the Irish Free State, though only after years of violent conflict.
Amendment B, tabled by the West Fife and Coastal Villages branch, keeps the leadership’s 2011 majority ambition but adds a crucial qualifier: a true mandate must involve more than 50% of Scots voting for pro-independence parties or candidates on the regional list.
This would tie the push to indyref2 to the share of votes, not just the seats won by the SNP.
Amendment C, tabled by the Dunbar & Haddington branches along with former MP Alyn Smith and Paul McLennan MSP, would simply add a line stating that Scotland’s independence process must also enable the country to become a full member of the European Union.
Mr Smith said it was important to have EU membership “explicit in black and white in the independence proposition.”
He added: “It is clear slam dunk polling that EU membership is not just the right thing to do but also smart politics to win over soft No voters. Independence is not going it alone, it is joining a global A team when the UK is going backwards and inwards in every sense.”
Meanwhile, Amendment D, from the Glasgow Kelvin branch, focuses on uniting the fractured Yes movement. It calls for a strategy to convince independence supporters who do not currently vote SNP, by offering “credible, objective and impartial” answers to their questions.
It commits the party’s ruling National Executive Committee to “operate with respect and trust across political boundaries as we work with others to establish a structure which will involve other political parties and groups sympathetic to Scotland’s future as an independent nation.”
The party would also be expected to “articulate where possible a common prospectus for independence which can help form the basis to establish a cross-party and non-party campaign before the next Holyrood elections.”
Members will also have the option to remit the motion back to the conference agenda committee, effectively sending it away to be rewritten, or to take the nuclear option of a direct negative, which would kill the leadership’s proposal altogether.
Former SNP policy convener Toni Giugliano said leaving the leadership’s motion unamended “risks tying the party’s hands”.
He warned: “This is not 2011 when securing an SNP majority was enough to guarantee a referendum. The sad reality is that no matter whether Scotland returns an SNP majority or a pro-independence majority, the democracy-deniers in Westminster will continue to oppose our right to choose.
“I urge the party to look beyond process. Two years ago the SNP voted to re-establish a well-resourced Yes campaign yet it is nowhere to be seen. The only way to make independence irrefutable is to grow support for Yes to well beyond 50% and make the demand unstoppable. We can only achieve that through a civic, grassroots, national Yes campaign. I urge the party to prioritise that now.”
One insider suggested it would be an easy win for the leadership: “My sense is that it is now settled. The leadership motion will get amended by helpful amendments, and the ‘howl of frustration’ amendment has its place and then is significantly defeated.”
Aileen McHarg, Professor of Public Law and Human Rights, Durham University, told The Herald on Sunday Mr Swinney's latest plan was "probably made more in hope than in expectation."
"In other words, I saw it more as an attempt to create political difficulties for Labour in the run up to the Holyrood election rather than in any serious expectation that the UK Government would accede to his request.
"That said, if the SNP were to win an outright majority in 2026, there would be serious questions to be asked about why the 2011 precedent should not hold. Opponents would no doubt fall back on the 'once in a generation' claim, but that’s extremely vague and becomes progressively weaker over time."
Ultimately, Prof McHarg said, “barring some unforeseeable bit of political luck that enables a deal to be done, the best route to indyref2 is to build irresistible public support for independence”.
"Indyref 2 is likely to be much more like the 1997 devolution referendum than the 2014 referendum – i.e., an event which confirms a settled public will rather than an extended process of will formation."
Share