Unspun 🗳️

Can FM's £10,000 indy promise work or could it backfire?

First Minister John Swinney has published a new independence paper promising greater prosperity for households under independence. <i>(Image: Graphic: Derek McArthur)</i>
First Minister John Swinney has published a new independence paper promising greater prosperity for households under independence. (Image: Graphic: Derek McArthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter.


It's absolutely no co-incidence that John Swinney is unveiling a new paper on independence three days before the SNP conference gets underway in Aberdeen.

The First Minister's speech today at the National Portrait Gallery in Edinburgh has much to do with placating restless party activists.

Members are dissatisfied with his independence plan set down in a motion to conference that a mandate for indyref2 would require the SNP to win a majority of seats at the Holyrood elections in May.

Mr Swinney is facing a tough debate on Saturday with 40 branches supporting a more hardline "de facto referendum" proposal and I'm not convinced his intervention today is going to make the forthcoming discussion any less fiery.


Read More:


But could his plan to win a majority next May actually work? And could a claim in the Scottish Government's new paper that Scots households would be £10,000 a year better off under independence help persuade voters to back his party come the 2026 poll?

On the first question, pollster Mark Diffley tells Unspun the ambition is "tantalisingly close" for Mr Swinney with a wide range of issues at play: how the SNP perform, whether Reform's support continues to grow and whether Labour can mount a successful challenge to the SNP in the Central Belt constituencies - as it did at the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election in June.

The SNP is currently polling around 35% or so, down from the 48% it got in the 2021 election but well ahead of its nearest rival Scottish Labour, he points out.

But, Mr Diffley adds, with the rise of Reform, the non SNP vote is split between more parties giving the SNP an advantage in the constituency part of the ballot. Sixty two of the 64 seats the SNP won in 2021 were in constituencies.

In this new political landscape winning 35% of constituency votes could help bring the party close to achieving a majority of Holyrood seats again, he explains, but also end in a result some way off from the goal.

"What the modelling shows at the moment is that the SNP would still hold the vast number of the constituencies it won in 2021," he says.

"It looks like they would be up at 60 to 62 seats at this point with 65 being the magic number by which a party gets a majority.

"They are and they aren't that far away from getting to 65.

"It's tantalisingly close but there's not much more to eke out of those constituencies. Getting those additional three to five seats the SNP need for a majority by winning more constituencies or regional list seats when their support is down will be difficult.

"The only time it was done was in 2011 when the SNP were polling around 50%."

So would a new push on independence with a focus of creating greater household prosperity help achieve the SNP's ambitions?

Again Mr Diffley believes it's a complicated situation.

He notes the difference between support for independence at 50% and support for the SNP at 35% and that part of Mr Swinney's strategy is to close that 15% gap by persuading independence supporters who have switched to Labour or the Greens to come back to his party.

The problem, he notes, is that this 15% of soft independence supporters are extremely difficult to shift.

Get Scotland's top politics newsletter straight to your inbox.

They don't see a second independence referendum as a priority with their main priorities instead being the delivery of improved public services, particularly the NHS, and tackling the cost of living crisis.

And they may not be persuaded by Mr Swinney's argument that independence will lead to greater prosperity and improved living standards.

The danger for the SNP, Mr Diffley explains, is that with a new focus on independence, the SNP could actually risk putting off the very people it needs to win over to help it achieve a majority.

He says: "The messaging around independence, how front and centre it is, is very hard for the SNP.

"How do you keep your base happy while trying to get voters back who have gone elsewhere in the last few years? It is not easy but it is something they need to get right if they have any hope of winning a majority next year."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos