The Scottish Government’s new paper, A Fresh Start with independence sets out why the SNP administration believes Scotland should leave the UK, and “what an independent Scotland could look like”.
Here are five key takeaways:
Lender of last resort
Much of the document is devoted to a blueprint for new fiscal and monetary institutions, including a Scottish Central Bank, a Debt Management Office, and a transition from sterling to a Scottish currency.
Ministers say these institutions would give Scotland the tools to manage its economy independently.
The Scottish Central Bank would eventually act as lender of last resort — providing emergency liquidity during financial crises — once a Scottish currency is introduced. Until then, John Swinney told reporters, the Bank of England would hold that role.
Though in the Q&A published alongside the new paper, the Scottish Government suggests there would be limited demand for such interventions, arguing that most large banks operating in Scotland are part of UK or international groups whose main activities are based outside Scotland.
With ring-fencing and stronger capital requirements for retail banks, ministers say “such support should not involve any significant cost to Scottish taxpayers.”
The deficit and debt
The Scottish Government says Scotland “would not inherit any of the UK’s debt stock, as the UK Government set out during the referendum campaign in 2014.” It adds that Scotland would seek to negotiate a fair contribution to servicing costs “in a spirit of co-operation and responsibility,” but would not be directly accountable to UK markets for historic UK debt.
Ministers say they will not present an estimate of the starting fiscal position of an independent Scotland, citing “uncertainty over the outlook for the global, UK, and Scottish economies, and future fiscal and economic policy decisions.”
However, they reference the current notional position within the UK:
“The latest estimates of the tax revenue raised in Scotland and the cost of public services provided for Scotland show a notional deficit for Scotland larger than the UK as a whole (–11.6% of GDP in Scotland compared with –5.1% for the UK in 2024–25).”
They argue these figures reflect the UK’s economic model rather than what an independent Scotland would run. They say they would aim for “sustainable public finances with clear fiscal rules and targets in line with international practice,” guided by the EU’s new fiscal framework, which allows for gradual deficit and debt reduction alongside investment and reform.
EU membership and energy at the heart of economic strategy
The paper repeatedly frames EU membership as the main lever for growth, restoring freedom of movement, improving trade, and increasing investment. Mr Swinney described independence and EU membership as a “golden combination.”
The government argues Brexit has cost households billions and that rejoining the single market would boost productivity, though this assumes smooth accession negotiations, business adaptation to new border arrangements, and EU approval.
It also presents energy wealth and productivity growth as key levers for closing the gap with small European economies. Ministers describe Scotland as “energy-rich” and say independence would allow more of this wealth to benefit households directly, for example through lower bills. They also highlight productivity growth — twice that of the UK since 2007 — as evidence of “catch-up potential.”
“More countries in Scotland, like Denmark and Ireland, are wealthier than the UK. They are fairer, they have higher levels of investment, and they are more productive,” Mr Swinney said.
Social policy: welfare, NHS and migration
The paper argues independence would allow more co-ordinated action across social policy, particularly to tackle poverty and support the NHS. Ministers say they could “do more to end child poverty” by controlling all welfare powers, tax, and immigration.
They also say independence would allow them to use the “full range of levers” to strengthen health and social care — including migration powers to staff services, full control of social security, and drugs policy.
On migration, the government says it would design a “humane, well-managed” visa system tailored to Scotland’s needs, including addressing rural depopulation and skills shortages. This would include a Live in Scotland route — a new visa allowing people to live and work in Scotland with their families without employer sponsorship, if they meet criteria set out in Scottish immigration rules.
Culture, the constitution and the monarchy
The paper argues independence would boost Scotland’s cultural profile and creative economy, allowing it to “take our place on the world stage” and rejoin schemes like Erasmus+ and Creative Europe.
It also commits to a written constitution, developed after independence, which would set out Scotland’s key institutions, values, rights, and citizenship arrangements.
On the monarchy, the paper states that Scotland would initially remain a constitutional monarchy, with the King as head of state. In the longer term, it would be for “the people of Scotland to decide” on the head of state, though no mechanism is outlined for how that decision would be made.
Share