Douglas Ross calls John Swinney ‘delusional’ over education

John Swinney speaking at the committee today. <i>(Image: Scottish Parliament)</i>
John Swinney speaking at the committee today. (Image: Scottish Parliament)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A tense exchange between Scottish Conservative MSP Douglas Ross and First Minister John Swinney erupted at Holyrood’s Conveners Committee, after Mr Ross accused the SNP leader of being “delusional” over his government’s record on education.

Mr Ross challenged the First Minister — who previously served as Education Secretary — to name the SNP Government’s “biggest failure” in education since taking office.

During his time as education secretary, Mr Swinney faced fierce criticism over the 2020 exam-results scandal, when thousands of pupils – particularly from poorer areas – had their grades downgraded by a government-approved algorithm.

Speaking at the committee today, Mr Swinney declined to single out any failure, saying he wanted to address the question in a “different fashion.”

However, Mr Ross interjected, urging him to “just try” to identify one area where the government had fallen short.


READ MORE:


In response, Mr Swinney said: “I think we’ve got to look at the record of the government as a whole and amongst the many things the government has delivered has been the more than doubling of early learning and childcare provision in Scotland for three and four year olds.”

He added there had been “significant increases” in positive destinations for school leavers and “record numeracy levels” in primary schools.

When pressed on whether the SNP had failed on education, Mr Swinney replied: “No, we’ve not failed on education because, for the reasons I’ve just recounted."

Despite being asked several times to name a single failure, the First Minister refused, instead defending his government’s overall record: “I’m simply explaining to the public which I do openly, honestly and transparently that the government has focused on education policy to improve outcomes.”

Mr Ross hit back, saying: “I think people will be baffled by, quite frankly, that delusional answer from Scotland’s First Minister.”

Mr Swinney responded: “With the greatest of respects, Mr Ross, I don’t really think that is a particularly appropriate characterisation for a member of parliament to be throwing around this committee.”

But Mr Ross stood by his comment, saying: “Well I’ll repeat it because I think it is. It is delusional for a First Minister to think there’s not been a single failing in education.”

Mr Swinney replied: “Oh, here we go again.”

Since the interaction, Mr Ross has said the First Minister "must be living on a different planet" as he said the SNP have taken a "wrecking ball" to education.

He added: “As a former education secretary, the First Minister must know his party have failed Scotland’s pupils, teachers and parents for over 18 years, but he shamelessly cannot bring himself to admit that.

“Nicola Sturgeon’s pledge to eliminate the poverty-related attainment gap is in tatters, violence is soaring in our schools, teachers do not have the resources to do their job and pupils have fewer subjects to choose from.

“If that is not a litany of failures to choose from, then I would hate to see what a successful education system would look like to John Swinney.”

Scottish Labour also criticised the First Minister for not pointing out any failures around education since the SNP took office, describing the omission as "insulting".

Scottish Labour Education spokesperson Pam Duncan-Glancy said “John Swinney’s bizarre claim that the SNP has never made any mistakes in education shows how arrogant and out of touch this SNP government is. 

“John Swinney can’t seem to remember his government’s record on education so here’s a reminder – they broke their promise to close the attainment gap, let our schools fall down the international league tables, let violence run riot in classrooms, cut ASN to the bone, attempted to downgrade the exam results of working class pupils, hollowed out colleges and pushed Universities to crisis point.

“It is insulting for John Swinney to pretend this record of failure is as good as it gets – but Scottish Labour will end SNP complacency and build an education system that works for every young Scot.”

The SNP has been contacted for comment.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos