Trust in Scottish Government hits lowest level since devolution began

All the latest news about the Scottish Parliament <i>(Image: Jane Barlow)</i>
All the latest news about the Scottish Parliament (Image: Jane Barlow)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Public trust in the Scottish Government has dropped to its lowest level since devolution, according to a landmark survey charting 25 years of changing attitudes.

Just 47% of Scots now say they trust Holyrood to act in the country’s best interests — down from 61% in 2019 and 81% when the Scottish Parliament reconvened in 1999.

The Scottish Social Attitudes survey also found satisfaction with the NHS has slumped to 22%, matching levels elsewhere in Britain and marking the lowest since records began.

ScotCen said this follows a 2023 finding in which 69% of people felt the standard of the health service had declined.

In 2024, just over two in five adults in Scotland (41%) said they were living comfortably or doing all right financially, while around one in four (24%) reported they were really struggling.

Although these figures represent marginal improvements from 2023, they remain significantly less positive than before the Covid-19 pandemic.

Scottish Conservative Deputy Leader Rachael Hamilton said: “It is no surprise that trust in John Swinney’s government is at an all-time low after nearly two decades of abject SNP failure in every major policy area.

“Struggling Scots can see that this Nationalist government does not listen to their concerns and instead focuses on fringe issues and obsessing over independence.

“The SNP has imposed the highest taxes in the UK while decimating frontline services. They have continually failed to meet their promises on everything from NHS waiting times to teacher numbers and housebuilding.

“This is a damning verdict on a government that has ignored the public and neglected its basic responsibilities.”

Scottish Labour Deputy Leader Jackie Baillie said: “This damning survey shows this tired SNP government has lost the trust of the Scottish people and compromised the founding principles of our NHS.

“It is no wonder people are losing faith in this SNP government when nearly one in six Scots are stuck on an NHS waiting list and basic services are becoming increasingly impossible to access.

“This SNP government is out of ideas and out of steam — but next year Scotland can choose a new direction and a better future with Scottish Labour.”

Every year between 1,200 and 1,500 people across Scotland are interviewed by ScotCen for the Scottish Social Attitudes survey.

The sit-down interviews typically include a range of questions on different topics. Questions are funded by a range of governmental and third-sector bodies, including the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC), the Scottish Government, NHS Health Scotland, the Equality and Human Rights Commission, and charitable and grant-awarding bodies such as the Nuffield Foundation and Leverhulme Trust.

The results of last year’s survey mark the 25th year of devolution.

Other findings shared ahead of the publication of today’s report include the fact that most people in Scotland continue to identify as Scottish.

However, the 74% saying in 2024 that it was at least one of their identities is down from 84% in 1999.

Support for independence stood at 47% last year, up from just 27% when devolution began.

Paul Bradshaw, Director of the Scottish Centre for Social Research, said: “The Scottish Social Attitudes survey provides a unique and incredibly valuable time series for monitoring trends and understanding public attitudes, to help support and develop effective policies and identify government priorities.

“These latest results show a clear decline in trust in the Scottish Government, alongside continued concern about public services and the economy. While Scots remain strongly attached to their Scottish identity, our data suggest that confidence in political institutions is under pressure — a finding that will be important for policymakers and the public alike.”

Responding to the survey, Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes said: “I am pleased to see this survey’s recognition of a long-term increase in support for Scotland becoming an independent country. The fresh start of independence is crucial if we are to raise living standards, grow the economy, and shape a fairer, more prosperous future.

“The data suggests that trust in the Scottish Government is on a level with governments elsewhere but we are determined to do more.    

“Much of this data was collected up to two years ago. Since then the Scottish Government has made considerable progress to deliver on the people of Scotland’s priorities – including abolishing peak rail fares, confirming plans to deliver winter heating support for pensioners and taking action to improve our NHS, including investing record funding of £21.7 billion for health and social care this year.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos