Sturgeon criticised as hypocritical over Peggie praise

Former first minister Nicola Sturgeon signing copies of her memoir Frankly at SNP conference yesterday. <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Former first minister Nicola Sturgeon signing copies of her memoir Frankly at SNP conference yesterday. (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A co-editor of a gender-critical book has called Nicola Sturgeon “a phoney of the highest order” after she praised the “bravery” of Sandie Peggie, the nurse who is suing NHS Fife over its trans policy.

Susan Dalgety, a writer and former Labour politician, accused the former first minister of hypocrisy because she was one of the driving forces behind legislation that allowed transgender people to share former single-sex spaces.

Ms Dalgety said Ms Sturgeon had lauded the courage of Ms Peggie and Maria Kelly, an engineer, even though it was the gender self-identification policies promoted by the former SNP leader that led to their tribunal cases being heard.

Ms Peggie is suing NHS Fife for discrimination after she was forced to share a changing room with a trans woman doctor Dr Beth Upton.


Read More:


Ms Kelly’s discrimination claim, opened in Edinburgh this month against the aerospace company Leonardo UK, relates to using mixed-sex work lavatories alongside trans women staff.

Ms Dalgety said the “apogee” of Ms Sturgeon’s duplicity came last week in The Usher Hall in Edinburgh during an interview to promote her memoir Frankly.

“The former first minister, who is at the fag end of her UK tour to promote her memoir, described women such as nurse Sandie Peggie and engineer Maria Kelly, who are currently suing their employers for discrimination on the basis of their sex, as ‘brave’,” Ms Dalgety wrote in The Scotsman at the weekend.

"Apparently with a straight face, she [Sturgeon] said: ‘I think any woman or any person who feels that their human rights have been compromised and come forward to challenge that, whether they are ultimately found to be vindicated or not, is a brave thing to do, and particularly when that involves sharing intimate details’.

“In a masterclass of hypocrisy, shot through with cruelty, Sturgeon tried to rewrite history.”


Read More:

Sturgeon shrugs off 'rip off' over SNP book signing

Sturgeon: 'Unthinkable' for care Promise not to be delivered


Ms Dalgety and Dr Lucy Hunter Blackburn, a former senior civil servant, edited The Women Who Wouldn’t Wheesht, a 2024 book of essays written by influential people, including JK Rowling, which puts forward the case for the rights of women and gender-critical feminism. The book, published by Constable, entered the bestseller lists in 2024. The proceeds, after costs, are donated to women’s charities around the world.

Ms Peggie, an A&E nurse, is suing NHS Fife and Dr Upton after she was suspended for objecting to the transgender medic’s use of the female changing room at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, claiming it amounted to unlawful harassment under the Equality Act. She was previously cleared of gross misconduct at a disciplinary tribunal.

The health board argues that while Ms Peggie is entitled to her belief that Ms Upton is male, the way she confronted her colleague was unreasonable in a workplace setting and it was therefore reasonable that she was suspended and investigated. The tribunal panel is due to deliberate on the case from October 14 for four days.

At the Usher Hall event, Ms Sturgeon acknowledged the toxic debate over the conflict between trans rights and women’s rights could have been better handled. She has faced criticism from Ms Rowling, who first expressed concerns about gender self-ID in 2019.

She told the audience: “In the last few years, I would have made my own life a lot easier if I’d just said, ‘Yep, JK Rowling and co are right, and I got it all wrong’, but I didn’t come in to politics to chuck vulnerable groups under the bus.”

The Dundee Tribunal Hearing Centre in July heard that Ms Peggie had describing Dr Upton as a "weirdo" and referred to the medic as "it".

At the hearing, Ms Peggie admitted some remarks made about Dr Upton in a WhatsApp chat were derogatory and demeaning, but added they were only made between a small group of friends. She denied waging a "vindictive campaign" against Dr Upton.

Documents presented in evidence to the tribunal also show Ms Peggie also making racist comments in an online group chat mocking the victims of the Pakistan floods in 2022, which killed over 1,700.

Between June and October 2022, monsoon floods devastated Pakistan, submerging one third of the South Asian nation, leaving millions homeless and injuring nearly 13,000. The official death toll was 1,739.

She said the “distasteful" posts were sent as an attempt at “dark humour” has strongly denied accusations of racism.

Trans people are one of Scotland's most minority communities.

In 2022 Scotland’s Census found that 19,970 people were trans, or had a trans history, accounting for 0.44% of people living in Scotland aged 16 and over.

The SNP has been approached for comment.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos