What is to be gained by binning BBC Scotland's Mornings?

Not 'po-faced' or 'middle-class', but Radio Scotland show in desperate need of reset
Not 'po-faced' or 'middle-class', but Radio Scotland show in desperate need of reset
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Radio Scotland faces a programme shake-up set to impact Good Morning Scotland and its Mornings phone-in show. On the latter, Barry Didcock applauds the good and laments the tired in a three-hour slot screaming out for fresh ideas.


“Your calls, your stories” is the line used to trail Mornings, the three hour phone-in show which follows BBC Radio Scotland’s Good Morning Scotland (GMS) on weekdays. On the basis of Monday’s programme, that feels more like a statement of hope than a correct précis of what is to follow.

There were some calls, admittedly, but of actual stories there were few and it would be more exact to describe Mornings as a text-in rather than a phone-in, that being the preferred method of communication. 

If you’re unfamiliar with Mornings, the programme has a three-strong presenter roster composed of Connie McLaughlin, Stephen Jardine and Kaye Adams. They take it in turns to host and are all experienced, capable and highly likeable broadcasters. In the chair, filling the air and battling the odd technical gremlin on Monday was McLaughlin, also a noted sports journalist. 

Why does any of this matter and why was I listening? Because along with GMS, Mornings is reportedly heading for the bin in which are placed radio programmes deemed no longer fit for purpose. If we can mix metaphors for a moment, there’s a new broom in town – her name is Victoria Easton Riley – and she may soon be swinging the grim reaper’s axe. Or whatever is the weapon of choice for a newly-appointed Head of Audio and Events at BBC Scotland’s Pacific Quay headquarters these days. 


Read more:


The announcement of Easton Riley’s appointment came on May 27, a couple of weeks after Howard Simpson was unveiled as BBC Scotland’s new Head of News and Current Affairs. Perhaps it’s a case of two new brooms, then. Less rubbish and in half the time. 

Speaking about her new gig, Easton Riley said: “It’s an incredible opportunity to help shape the future of audio in Scotland and work with teams who share my passion for creating bold, distinctive content for audiences across the country”. To that go-getting statement of intent The Times found a BBC insider to add (sotto voce, presumably): “Victoria is on a mission to ditch all the po-faced, middle-class stuff and attract a new audience.”   

For the record, Eaton Riley was previously employed by Hamburg-based media behemoth Bauer Media as its Director of Content for Scotland and Northern Ireland. Bauer Media owns and operates dozens of UK commercial radio stations, from Absolute Radio and Jazz FM to Kiss and Kerrang! 

How then does this apply to Mornings, if indeed it is threatened with the axe? Is it already bold and distinctive enough to survive a quality audit and remain on air? If not, does it also fall into the category of that po-faced and middle-class stuff desperately in need of a new audience? 

The vague, almost comically bland title reflects the show’s baggy nature – a yawning three-hour stretch of what would otherwise be dead air into which is poured anything and everything you (or rather the producers) can think of. 

And so we kicked off with an hour-long discussion of the tribulations of the Scotland men’s football team. It was the kind of thing you would overhear in the pub – a place, remember, where bores outnumber true raconteurs by about ten to one – and it fairly soon descended into talk of holding midfielders, whatever they are, and a discussion of whether Scotland would be better served with a 4-3-2-1 or a 4-1-4-1 formation. Given that we have just won two games on the bounce and are closer to qualifying for a World Cup than in decades, you’d have thought a 5-4-3-2-1-Blast Off! formation would be the one to discuss. But apparently not. 

That was followed by an interview with former Great British Bake Off contestant Flora Shedden, who talked about her new cookery book, and she was followed in turn by something called The Court Of Karen. This had nothing to do with squash and everything to do with sons-in-law. Or is it son-in-laws? Anyway, there was a question from a listener about the breed, and judge Karen Mackenzie dug into the whys and wherefores of this ‘humdrum conundrum’ alongside comedian Dave Chawner, who had been drafted in as a sort of opposing counsel and to provide some jokes. If he did, I missed them. The judgement was announced later in the programme and introduced with some cheesy music and the sound of a gavel striking wood. Any listeners who had nodded off would have woken with a fright at this point and spilled their tea, but hey-ho. 


Read more:


We also heard from jet-setting travel correspondent Simon Calder, a man for whom the words ‘climate emergency’ seem not to apply. He phoned in his bit from Liverpool Street Station in London, having just arrived there from Prague, and was en route to Lebanon via Moldova. Or something. Anyway, he’d been trying out the new exit and entry drill for non-EU citizens (that’s us, folks) but later had time to provide advice for a couple of listeners who had called in. From them came questions about queues, refund procedures, more queues, how Irish is Irish where getting an EU passport is concerned, how to get to Nashville from Scotland (which should be a song title if it isn’t already) and what to do as a psoriasis sufferer if you are required to provide fingerprints. 

So, bold and distinctive Mornings is not. But neither is it overtly middle-class, at least not in the tin-eared, plummy-voiced, London-centric way BBC Radio Four is. And it isn’t po-faced, either. Odd was the over-riding flavour of the Court of Karen segment – it has internet cult hit written all over it, if not for entirely the right reasons. Elsewhere, in a section devoted to the ongoing renovation work in Glasgow’s George Square, SNP councillor Graham Campbell made a brave attempt to raise the issue of Glasgow’s legacy of slavery as represented in some of the square’s statuary. 

McLaughlin didn’t bite, more is the pity. Maybe late morning isn’t the right place for that kind of stuff – the kind of divisive, culture war topics which get thumbs texting and set the phone lines blazing, and which may just capture the interest of that new audience. 

As for Mornings itself, it does feel ripe for fresh ideas and approaches. But I’d say that’s best done by keeping what’s good about the show and using commissioning money to replace what isn’t. Spend cash on tightening up, filling out, adding to, enhancing. Make the show a series of interesting sprints rather than just a handful of middle distance slogs stitched together with bland pop tunes from the BBC Radio Two playlist. Whether that will happen is anyone’s guess. 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos