Waste firm Biffa has insisted Green MSP Lorna Slater gave it “unambiguous and emphatic” assurance that Scotland’s botched deposit return scheme would go ahead.
The company is seeking £166 million in compensation over the collapse of the recycling programme.
Biffa was appointed official logistics provider for Scotland’s DRS in July 2022 under a 10-year contract with Circularity Scotland, the non-profit body set up to administer the scheme.
Read More:
- Biffa begins £166m court fight with Scottish Government over collapsed deposit scheme
- Biffa given go ahead to sue Scottish Government over deposit return scheme collapse
- Boss of Scotland's scrapped deposit return scheme leading new venture
The firm claims it invested £51.4m preparing for the launch, including on vehicles, equipment, infrastructure and a depot in Motherwell. It also began recruiting staff. Biffa expected to make £114.8m in profits over the decade.
The company argues that both those costs and its anticipated profits were lost when the scheme was delayed and ultimately collapsed, and that Scottish ministers are liable for the loss.
Scotland’s DRS fell through in 2023 after the Scottish Government moved to delay the scheme for two and a half years following a dispute with the UK Government.
At the time, Ms Slater, then circular economy minister, blamed the Conservatives after ministers in Whitehall said an exemption to the UK Internal Market Act would only be granted if major changes were made.
These included removing glass from the scheme, introducing standardised labelling, and applying a uniform deposit charge across the UK.
Ms Slater said uncertainty around the UK Government’s conditions meant the scheme could not go ahead as planned.
However, Circularity Scotland maintained that the scheme could have complied with the UK Government’s requirements and launched this year.
Despite that, Ms Slater announced in June 2023 that the DRS would be delayed until “at least October 2025” — before a further postponement pushed any potential start date to 2027.
Circularity Scotland fell into administration weeks later, leaving debts of more than £86m, including £8m owed to the Scottish National Investment Bank. Its contract with Biffa was terminated.
Biffa is claiming negligence and breach of duty of care.
Speaking in the Court of Session in Edinburgh on Tuesday, Biffa chief executive Michael Topham said a letter sent in May 2022 by Ms Slater offered assurances that the scheme would proceed.
He said: “It was so unambiguous and emphatic. It provided me with certainty there was no doubt it was going ahead.
“I read it as a very unequivocal reassurance about their commitment to the scheme.”
He added that the letter “applied pressure somewhat on us to conclude the contract and move ahead”.
The Scottish Government’s lawyers have previously said Biffa took a “commercial risk” in choosing to spend money on the scheme.
At the court on Tuesday, Mr Topham said he had not been told of the UK Government’s position on internal market rules, which could have affected the scheme’s progress.
He said that had he known, he would have made signing the contract conditional on having an exemption in place.
Mr Topham was questioned by Gerry Moynihan KC on behalf of the Scottish Government.
He asked about the significance of Ms Slater’s letter, noting that Biffa had taken out insurance with a premium of more than £3m.
Mr Topham said the insurance was taken out due to concerns about possible delays.
Mr Moynihan also questioned him on why the letter was not mentioned in board meeting notes the following day. Mr Topham said he had told the board about it verbally.
The Court of Session hearing is expected to last eight days and will later hear evidence from Ms Slater and Lord Alister Jack, who was Scottish secretary when the scheme was shelved.
Following a freedom of information request, the Scottish Government revealed in January it had already spent £168,000 on legal fees related to the case.
Scottish Conservative MSP Maurice Golden said: “The Deposit Return Scheme was a costly shambles that summed up the SNP’s coalition of chaos with the Scottish Greens.
“Lorna Slater was repeatedly warned of potential problems but stubbornly pushed ahead, insisting the scheme would go ahead no matter what. Biffa says her assurances persuaded them to invest millions and lose millions more in prospective revenue.
“Many small businesses lost money and Circularity Scotland went bust while the SNP/Greens were asleep at the wheel.
“If the courts agree that Ms Slater breached the assurances she gave and caused Biffa’s losses, Scottish taxpayers face a huge compensation bill for SNP/Green incompetence.”
Scottish Liberal Democrat climate emergency spokesperson Liam McArthur said:
“If this legal bid succeeds, tens of millions of taxpayers’ money will have to be handed over for nothing in exchange.
“Deposit return schemes have operated successfully around the world. There was no good reason for Scotland to be any different.
“In the end, however, DRS was just the latest victim of those who enjoy indulging in constitutional spats. Businesses were caught in the middle, strung along, incurring costs and left to navigate the uncertainty. Now it is the public who could be left to pay the price.”
Scottish Labour's net zero spokesperson Sarah Boyack said: “Lorna Slater is no longer a minister or even a Scottish Greens co-leader, yet Scots are still having to pay the price for her complete incompetence in government.
"The Scottish Government’s appalling mismanagement of the Deposit Return Scheme has already cost taxpayers millions, with the public purse now exposed to even greater risk due to a potential compensation payout to the tune of £166 million.
"Ministers should have heeded warnings about the scheme and taken all steps available to ensure that public money would not be wasted."
Share