The Scottish Government has confirmed a nationwide review of maternity services will go ahead, as First Minister John Swinney insisted Scotland’s maternity care remains safe despite a series of critical reports and recent public concern.
Speaking to journalists during a huddle at Holyrood on Thursday, Mr Swinney said ministers had accepted there was “unease” about maternity services and that ongoing inspections by Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) would feed into the new review.
“What we recognise is there is unease about maternity services where we have the Healthcare Improvement Scotland investigations that are being undertaken, a number of those are underway just now,” he said, "The maternity taskforce will look at the findings of those points and take forward the necessary action in terms of a national review and that’s the judgement the government has come to.”
READ MORE:
- Neil Gray 'open' to national review of Scotland’s maternity care
- The Scottish mums driving 100s of miles for maternity services
- How can Scotland make maternity care safer amid concerns?
- 'Wigtownshire maternity crisis shows need for political action'
- NHS Dumfries & Galloway accused of ignoring maternity safety concerns
Pressed by The Herald on whether new or reinstated maternity units were needed to improve care, the First Minister replied: “We’ve got a very strong network of maternity services around the country and maternity services are safe in Scotland.”
When it was pointed out that several units have been downgraded or closed across Scotland, Mr Swinney accused The Herald of “jumbling up a few things", saying such changes were made on clinical grounds.
He added: “There are clinical assessments made about the sophistication of services that are required, given the number of cases that individual units are dealing with.
“A government that didn’t take seriously that clinical advice would not be a government serving the people properly."
Mr Swinney said the government must ensure “the strength and quality” of maternity provision through the HIS inspection process and pointed to national data indicating the system “is safe”.
“I say that not to dismiss concerns but to give reassurance that services are strong and they are safe,” he said.
“We have to be constantly challenging ourselves about whether or not we can do those services better — and we do that.”
The First Minister said HIS recommendations across NHS Tayside had been “largely implemented”, though he acknowledged NHS Lothian had “not done them all”, stressing there “has to be an intensity of focus” on delivering outstanding improvements.
During First Minister’s Questions, Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar welcomed what he called a “change of heart” from Mr Swinney after ministers agreed to the national review less than 24 hours after SNP MSPs had voted against Labour’s motion for such an inquiry.
“I’m glad he went home and thought again,” Mr Sarwar said.
On Wednesday, Health Secretary Neil Gray told Parliament that a national probe would proceed only if recommended by the Maternity and Neonatal Taskforce.
However, on Thursday, Public Health Minister Jenni Minto confirmed in a letter to MSPs that the taskforce will now decide "the scope" of the review.
Labour’s deputy leader Dame Jackie Baillie said the move was overdue but welcome.
“It is right that SNP ministers have finally listened to the families and the experts and agreed to carry out this important work,” she said.
“Too many women and babies have been let down when it matters most, and their experiences must be at the heart of this review.”
The U-turn follows harrowing testimony from bereaved parents at Holyrood on Wednesday.
Julie Keegan, an intensive-care nurse whose three-day-old baby died after failings at NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, said a lack of accountability meant “nobody ever faces consequences”.
“These people are letting our babies die – and they’re going to work the next day,” she told PA News Agency.
Lori Quate, whose wife and unborn daughter died in 2020, added:
“They can look at it, accept that that’s what’s done, and nothing changes, nothing happens – but you get to walk home with somebody less in your family. It’s not acceptable.”
Mr Gray revealed last week that he “nearly lost” his wife due to inaccurate medical assessments.
An HIS report into the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh, one of the UK’s busiest maternity units, recently found “serious concerns” about patient safety, including staff shortages, medication errors and a “suboptimal skill mix”.
Mr Swinney said the forthcoming national review would take account of those investigations to “ensure the highest standards of care for mothers and babies across Scotland”.
Minister for Public Health and Women’s Health Jenni Minto also confirmed the national review which she said would be shaped by HIS inspections of "every maternity unit" and clinical expertise.
The Minister said: “A national review of maternity services will take place. The new Scottish Maternity and Neonatal Taskforce, chaired by the Minister for Public Health and Women’s Health, will set out how a review can be undertaken and will define its scope. This will be shaped by clinical expertise and by the findings of Healthcare Improvement Scotland’s inspections of every maternity unit, which are already well underway.”
Share