The Scottish loch that's blooming again - success at last

Seawilding volunteers at Loch Craignish prepare seagrass for translocation <i>(Image: Seawilding)</i>
Seawilding volunteers at Loch Craignish prepare seagrass for translocation (Image: Seawilding)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The challenge of growing a huge underwater garden in a chilly Scottish loch was always going to either sink or swim: from the harvesting of 100,000 seeds from beneath the surface, to wading knee deep into the water to plant them.

For around a decade efforts by groups across the UK to revive dwindling seagrass habitats focused on the tricky task of gathering seed, encouraging it to sprout in land-based tanks, then replanting shoots, only to see their efforts often end with disappointment.

At Loch Craignish, between Oban and the Crinan Canal and overlooking the Sound of Jura, volunteers strived for four years with the fiddly process, with little to show for the fruits of their labours.

Now, however, the group has uncovered a solution with remarkable results that are set to transform how seagrass meadows are restored around the country.

Seagrass provides a vital habitat for marine biodiversity (Image: Seawilding)

Using an innovative technique that translocates seagrass shoots from existing meadows to new sites rather than harvesting their seeds, the project has achieved an impressive increase in seabed coverage - from 10% to 70% in just 15 months.

The method has also seen a 97% survival rate at the new sites and, even better, is believed to benefit existing meadows.

In a process that will be familiar to many land-based gardeners, the act of ‘pruning’ from existing plants is thought to encourage further growth and is boosting the health of the ‘donor’ meadows.


Read more:


The success at the Loch Craignish project is being seen as a major breakthrough in seagrass (Zostera marina) restoration.

It’s led to the group behind the project, Seawilding,  Scotland’s first community-based marine habitat restoration charity, investigating potential new locations at west coast sites where the process can be repeated.

Volunteers at Loch Craignish are helping restore seagrass meadows (Image: Seawilding)

Seagrass is the ocean’s only flowering plant, and provides a vital habitat for marine biodiversity as well as being an important carbon sink.

In Victorian times, Loch Craignish’s lush seagrass meadows provided bountiful spawning grounds for white fish such as cod and herring and helped the area becoming famed for its huge oysters and scallops.

However, a combination of bottom trawling, dredging and pollution devastated the once vast meadows of seagrass that covered the loch floor.

And although it has around ten relatively healthy seagrass meadows left, they are said to be small, fragmented and isolated.

A new method is helping to grow new seagrass meadows at Loch Craignish (Image: Seawilding)

The loss of seagrass there and at other sites around the country has been noticeable since the 1990s and has been partly blamed for a collapse in west coast white fish stocks: seagrass meadows are said to harbour up to 40 times more marine life than areas without it.

The new method of planting at Loch Craignish is being seen as a “significant leap forward in technical success” potentially heralding a shift in how similar projects around the country operate.

From having dealt with years of less than impressive results, the community effort is now being held up as one of the most successful establishments of seagrass habitat in the UK to date.


Read more:


The new approach was tested two years ago when tens of thousands of adult shoots were carefully taken from existing seagrass ‘donor’ meadows within the loch.

Teams of volunteers were tasked with carefully processing rhizomes, getting them ready for transplanting into the restoration area by securing them to tiny steel anchors to help stabilise them on to the floor of the loch.

Seagrass being prepared for translocation at Loch Craignish (Image: Seawilding)

Despite an early setback, this year’s success has taken the group’s leaders by surprise after seasons of disappointment.

“We have been working at Loch Craignish for around four years and there have been a lot of challenges along the way as with all projects like this,” says Will Goudy, Seawilding’s Seagrass Lead.

“We started with seed planting, but the methods were not really working and initial trails were not what we hoped for.

Seagrass plants being prepared for translocation at Loch Craignish (Image: Seawilding)

“We persevered and tried to find out why things were failing.

“We realised that the bags we were placing the seeds in were hindering germination.

New efforts to restore seagrass meadows at Loch Craignish have proved successful (Image: Seawilding)

“We tried other seed regeneration methods but it was hard to unpick exactly what was happening.

“We were scratching our heads when a couple of team members visited a Canadian restoration project and saw how they were digging up seagrass shoots for transplant.”

Intrigued, the group decided to try a similar method in 2023. In a UK first, they took around four inches of seagrass shoot with roots attached and simply replanted in a quarter of an acre restoration zone.

But, as many gardeners will know, plants can have a habit of hating one corner of the garden and thriving in another.

“It didn’t work to start with,” he adds, “but it seems we were planting in an area of the seabed where the sea conditions were not quite right.

“Last year we tried another area where we thought the conditions might be better and it took off.”

Muddy seabed sediments lacking in oxygen are thought to have added to the high failure rate during the first attempt.

Work at the Loch Craignish seagrass project has involved counting the number of new shoots (Image: Seawilding)

The latest attempt at a better oxygenated site saw an increase in seabed coverage from 10% to more than 70% in just 15 months.

This year’s new trial achieved 97% survival of transplanted seagrass shoots and an average four-fold increase in seabed coverage in just six months.

The group say it has resulted in an area of 0.3 hectares of newly created seagrass habitat.

It adds: “Crucially, the impact of shoot extraction from the existing ‘donor’ meadow appears negligible.

Existing seagrass meadow at Loch Craignish (Image: Seawilding)

“Even when harvested at 25% across an area, in just five months shoot density was back to near-natural levels.

Underwater and drone images captured at the site show dramatic differences between a barren area of loch floor where there is only sand, and one that appears to be thick with growth.

The seagrass 'donor' bed at Loch Craignish is providing plants for a new area of meadow (Image: Seawilding)

“It’s an exciting break-through,” adds Will.

“We’ve trialled multiple methods over the last five years, and had our fair share of failure, but with this methodology we’re proving it’s possible to restore seagrass at scale.

“The next step will be to work out if it will work elsewhere.

“We have been looking at other sites where there is healthy seagrass meadows, where we might be able to run some further trials.”

The Loch Craignish project was the first project of its kind in Scotland and has been supported by around 60 local volunteers, including children.

It has also tourists from around the world who have combined their travels with taking part in the environmental  project to help offset their carbon footprint.

Seagrass meadow at Loch Craignish (Image: Seawilding)

As well as supporting seagrass revival, Will says the project has had a social impact, generating seven ‘green’ jobs, bringing the community together and attracting visitors to the area.

“Seagrass is an incredibly important habitat for a huge range of species,” he adds.

“It’s an important nursery garden for commercially important fish stocks, herring lay eggs there and cod and whiting use it as a spawning ground.

“The seagrass we have in the loch is doing a massive job.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos