Swinney: Starmer will not stay PM if SNP win majority

First Minister John Swinney has ramped up pressure on Prime Minister Keir Starmer <i>(Image: PA)</i>
First Minister John Swinney has ramped up pressure on Prime Minister Keir Starmer (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Keir Starmer will not survive as Prime Minister if the SNP win a majority in next year's Holyrood elections, according to John Swinney as he set out his demand for a new independence referendum.

The First Minister ramped up pressure on Mr Starmer, who is facing growing discontent among some of his backbenchers, when he delivered a speech today at the Institute for Government in London.

During his address Mr Swinney outlined the SNP's demand that if the party wins a majority in the May election that would be a mandate for a new independence referendum following a precedent set in 2011.


Read More:


In that year's Holyrood election the SNP, then led by Alex Salmond, secured a majority with then Prime Minister David Cameron agreeing to the referendum, which was held in September 2014 with the result by 55% to 45% for Scotland to remain in the UK.

The 2011 result was the first time a majority has been achieved in a Scottish Parliament election for any party and has never been repeated.

Mr Swinney was asked why he was setting such a high bar for his party given the difficulties in achieving a majority in the Scottish Parliament.

Prime Minister Keir Starmer is under growing backbench pressure (Image: Leon Neal/PA NEWS WIRE)

He said there was currently a "a log jam" over the constitutional question with a majority of the Scottish Parliament that believes Scotland should be an independent country, "and there should be a referendum to enable that to be the case" but that could "not be advanced" because opposition to it of the United Kingdom

He added: "I've looked at that and said to my party if we want to break the log jam, we've got to have a very clear and unanswerable case that we put to the people of Scotland, and that is, relies upon the precedent that was that pertained in 2011 whereby a majority of SNP members were elected [to the Scottish Parliament] and a referendum followed.

"And in my view, there is a very clear and demonstrable case that that precedent should be respected."

He was pressed how a Westminster government could consider the difference between an SNP and Scottish Green majority for independence, as there is currently in Holyrood, and an SNP only majority for independence.

The First Minister replied: "I think the difference is that the SNP only majority was not ignored. That's the big difference, and that's what sets the precedent."

And he added: "If that was to happen in May of next year, then I have no doubt that the Prime Minister would not survive in office. So that breaks a log jam right away."

The First Minister faced a major battle with some in his party over his independence strategy when members gathered for their annual conference last month in Aberdeen.

Critics were sceptical that the Prime Minister could simply refuse the demand for a plebiscite even if the SNP won a majority.

But he told SNP activists that "nobody knows what tactics I will deploy" after he win the fierce internal battle on the party's strategy.

His comments have led to speculation about whether the Scottish Government would pursue legal case against the UK Government should the SNP win a majority of Holyrood seats next year and the UK continued to refuse agreeing to a new referendum.

The First Minister was asked today if it was his plan to test the precedent in court.

Mr Swinney was reluctant to go into detail about his plan.

"I said to my party conference I was going to have a tactical approach to how I move through this," he said.

"So I'm not going to shed more light on that. What I'm simply saying is I'm setting out a route that will trigger a process that we will pursue."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos