CARLOS ALBA

A Reform win could be the clincher for indy. Here's why

Could Nigel Farage in No 10 open the door for independence supporters? <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Could Nigel Farage in No 10 open the door for independence supporters? (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The argument against separatism has always been largely economic. The apparent generosity of the Barnett Formula has meant, to most Scots, that it is better to remain under the protective UK umbrella. But that might all be about to change, writes Carlos Alba


There are some examples of unplanned theatre that capture a moment, setting political orthodoxy for years to come, particularly when they are caught on camera.

Margaret Thatcher emerging from the British Embassy in Paris to address waiting press, after she failed to secure an outright victory in the first round of the 1990 Tory leadership contest, looked hurried and desperate. Within a few days, she was gone.

The beginning of the end of former Scottish Labour leader Iain Gray’s political career was arguably when he was filmed hiding from protestors in a sandwich shop.

The economic case for Scottish independence was fatally holed by an excruciating episode during the the first Scottish Parliament election campaign in 1999.

At a press conference held to unveil the SNP’s alternative budget, the party’s finance big hitters – Alex Salmond, John Swinney and Andrew Wilson – sat huddled over the back of an envelope trying to work out whether an independent Scotland would have a budget deficit.

With just three days to go before voters went to the polls, the main pretenders to government north of the Border had no answer to one of the biggest questions at the heart of their programme, and they looked woefully unprepared.

In time, the SNP would go on to dominate Scottish politics for a generation but its main proposition – the fiscal and economic case for independence – has never recovered.


Read more by Carlos Alba


Electorally, unionist parties may have lost virtually every other argument affecting the governance of this country since devolution, but their position on the financial unviability of an independent Scotland continues to hold sway.

The 2014 referendum was lost because too many people believed that the cultural and civic benefits would be outweighed by the economic shock of going it alone. Even the economic carnage of Brexit failed to shift the dial on support for independence. This week the former Conservative prime minister, Sir John Major, cited analysis by Cambridge Econometrics which has forecast that the UK economy will be £311 billion worse off by 2035 as a result of Britain leaving the European Union. By losing out on an estimated £100bn a year in lost trade, the UK Treasury is deprived of tax revenues amounting to £40bn annually, forcing the Labour Chancellor into making difficult decisions she could otherwise have avoided, according to Sir John.

In public spending terms, there is no denying that Scotland benefits from being part of the UK, with £15,563 allocated per person last year, compared with a UK average of £13,504, according to the annual Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland (GERS) report.

There are other statistical arguments against independence. In 2022-23, Scotland's net fiscal deficit was £19.1bn, or 9.0% of GDP, compared with the UK's overall deficit of 5.2%.

The case for independence has historically been tied to North Sea oil revenues, but this has become a key argument against it, due to price volatility and the long-term decline of the oil and gas sector. The question of what currency an independent Scotland would use has also created uncertainty, and without its own central bank to set rates, the country would likely face higher interest rates on its public debt. Then there are the start-up costs of separatism – estimated in 2013 to be as high as £2.7bn – as well as the border question. If Scotland sought to re-join the EU, it would likely create a customs and regulatory border between Scotland and England, introducing tariffs, checks, and red tape that could disrupt integrated supply chains.

But could the same dynamics that have worked in favour of the Union for so long, be about to turn against it?

Could the apparent shift in voting preferences – mainly in England – signalled by opinion polls over the past year, mean that the greater risk for a majority of Scottish voters could soon be to remain part of the UK? Reform UK, the right-wing party on course to form the next government at Westminster, has pledged to ditch the Barnett Formula, which has maintained higher levels of public spending north of the Border for the past 50 years.

A less generous settlement for Scotland, combined with Reform’s highly speculative fiscal policy, could soon make the economic case for independence seem a whole lot less unattractive.

Reform UK has proposed significant tax cuts – raising the income tax threshold to £20,000, abolishing IR35 and cutting corporation tax for small businesses – while also increasing spending in areas like defence and the NHS, without specifying equivalent spending cuts.

The UK's national debt is already over 100% of GDP, a level not seen since the early 1960s, and the UK Government's Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) forecasts that debt will continue to rise over the next five years under current plans.

Adding an estimated £40-£90bn per year to borrowing would require a huge increase in government bond issuance, which would likely spook financial markets, leading to higher interest rates on UK government debt.

Reform's core policy is to leave the European Single Market and Customs Union further behind, aiming for an even looser relationship based on World Trade Organization (WTO) terms, if a preferred deal isn't reached.

Would Reform UK’s economic policies shift the dial on independence? (Image: Getty)

Reduced trade with the EU, the UK's largest trading partner, would shrink the size of the UK economy further, reduce tax revenues, and make funding public services more difficult.

A Reform government would also introduce a policy of "net zero immigration", involving a significant and rapid reduction in migrant numbers, disproportionately impacting Scotland which relies more heavily on a migrant workforce than the rest of the UK.

Voting north of the Border is epochal and hegemonic – once Scots decide on a pattern of behaviour, they tend to stick with it – and, for now the mood is against independence. It might only take a moment for all that to change.


Carlos Alba is former newspaper editor who now works as a freelance journalist, author, and PR and digital marketing consultant at Carlos Alba Media where he helps businesses and organisations to improve their visibility in the media. He ran the media campaign for Ken MacIntosh’s bid to become Scottish Labour leader against Kezia Dugdale.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos