Exclusive

Constance denies misleading Holyrood in grooming gang row

Constance insists she ‘accurately quoted’ expert on grooming gangs despite correction <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Constance insists she ‘accurately quoted’ expert on grooming gangs despite correction (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Justice Secretary Angela Constance has insisted she “accurately quoted” Professor Alexis Jay during a Holyrood debate on grooming gangs, despite the government being forced to issue a correction over the child abuse expert’s position.

The minister rejected suggestions she had misled Parliament ahead of a key vote in September.

She also said she had “no objection” to releasing correspondence between her and Prof Jay.

Last week, The Herald revealed that officials had quietly published a correction admitting the minister’s comments, made during a debate on the Victims, Witnesses and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill, were incorrect.

Scottish Tory justice spokesperson Liam Kerr had tabled an amendment to the legislation which would have required the new Victims Commissioner for Scotland to carry out research on grooming gangs.

However, Ms Constance said work in this area was already being carried out by Police Scotland and the specialist National Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation Strategic Group, established in 2024.

She told Parliament: “Is Mr Kerr aware of the work led by Professor Alexis Jay, who was the chair of an independent inquiry into child sexual abuse in England and Wales and who currently sits on our national strategic group?

“She shares my view and has put on the record and stated to the media that she does not support further inquiries into child sexual abuse and exploitation, given the significant time and resource already spent in the review that she led, the Casey audit and other reviews.

“She says that it is now time that ‘people should just get on with it’.”

Mr Kerr’s amendment was defeated by 62 votes to 51.

However, minutes of October’s meeting of the National Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation Strategic Group show Ms Constance had taken Prof Jay's comments out of context.

Under the heading “Clarification of Alexis Jay’s position on inquiries”, they state: “During the debate on the Victims, Witnesses and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill in Parliament on 16 September, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice quoted the views of Professor Alexis Jay on calls for further inquiries into child sexual abuse.

“Co-chair clarified that Professor Jay shared these views in January of this year in the context of her work on the Independent Inquiry in England and Wales and was not related to the debate on the Victims Bill or the position in Scotland.”

News of the correction sparked anger from MSPs and survivors.

Ms Constance was not in Parliament during an urgent question on the revelation.

However, the minister was back in Holyrood on Tuesday, where The Herald was able to doorstep her.

Asked about her remarks during September’s debate, Ms Constance said: “I gave an accurate quote, and indeed the correspondence Ms Jay sent to me acknowledged the quote that I gave was accurate, but she wanted to make clear to the Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation Group that she was not expressing an opinion regarding Mr Kerr’s amendment to the Victims, Witnesses and Justice Reform Bill, which of course was my understanding at the time.

“I was speaking at a general point that we should be getting on with the job of protecting children.”

Asked why Ms Jay’s clarification was issued in the minutes of the strategic group rather than publicly, Ms Constance replied: “Well, that is what Ms Jay wanted to do. She wanted to make clear that she was not expressing an opinion with respect to the amendment. And my position is that I was speaking at a general point. I quoted her accurately. I had referred to the fact that she had made this remark on record in the media. So, you know, I am not sure that I have anything to add.”

Asked whether she had sought Prof Jay’s view on a grooming-gang inquiry, the minister said: “No, I have not had any contact with Ms Jay because the Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation Strategic Group does not sit within my portfolio. It is within the education portfolio. But obviously, as a former social worker, I am firmly of the view that all ministers have a responsibility when it comes to the protection of our children, whether they are education or justice ministers.”

Meanwhile, the Scottish Government has come under renewed pressure over its handling of calls for a grooming-gang inquiry after a heated Holyrood exchange in which ministers were accused of confusion, evasion and a lack of leadership on child sexual abuse.

The clash followed The Herald’s report on Tuesday in which the NSPCC warned Scotland still lacks a clear understanding of the scale and nature of child sexual abuse and called for “ministerial leadership” to tackle the problem.

In an urgent question, Tory MSP Megan Gallagher said the NSPCC’s remarks were an “unprecedented intervention” and questioned whether the Scottish Government’s structures were remotely equipped to deal with organised group-based exploitation.

She highlighted that the government-backed subgroup produced a “27-page deep dive on child sexual abuse, yet there was not one mention of grooming gangs, not one single reference”.

“More evidence that the national structures the minister points to are focused on general practice, not on identifying or analysing organised group-based exploitation,” she said.

“Given this detailed report has overlooked the issue of grooming gangs entirely, does the minister still believe the Scottish Government is truly committed to confronting the issue?”

Ms Don-Innes responded that ministers would “give every consideration to an inquiry” but insisted resources had to be “diverted in the most appropriate way”.

“I have been very clear that we are not closed off to this,” she said. “We want to ensure that we are putting resources in the appropriate way and that is inclusive of the work that is ongoing by Police Scotland and the national group to inform that.”

Labour’s Pauline McNeill warned ministers risked “completely losing their grip over what approach to take tackling organised child sexual abuse”.

Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay asked whether all correspondence with Prof Jay would be made public. Ms Don-Innes replied the matter had been “appropriately cleared up” last week and said Prof Jay was a “valued member” of the national group. She did not commit to releasing the correspondence.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos