What happened when Waterstones planned to move next to indy book shop?

Leith Walk bookshop owner Adam Barclay of Argonaut Books <i>(Image: Gordon Terris)</i>
Leith Walk bookshop owner Adam Barclay of Argonaut Books (Image: Gordon Terris)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Heard the one about the independent David taking on the corporate Goliath at the Foot of the Walk? If not, it’s the ongoing face off between Argonaut Books, since 2022 a welcome literary oasis in Edinburgh’s Leith district, and Waterstones, which already has around 300 UK shops but wants to establish another just metres from Argonaut’s front door.

The site the company has its eye on is an empty unit of the 1960s Newkirkgate shopping centre which was purchased recently by a London-based property investment company. But this is also a story involving regeneration and gentrification, which may be the same thing depending on who you speak to, and if there’s a low rumble in the near distance it’s probably a tram. They feature also. We’re in Edinburgh: how could they not?

To say the Waterstones plan has met with pushback would be an understatement. Adam Barclay, local boy and the founder and owner of Argonaut Books, has mounted a nimble, visible, and media savvy defence which has caught the attention not just of his corporate opponent but of the world’s media.

Leith Walk bookshop Argonaut Books (Image: GordonTerris/Herald&Times)

His predicament – portrayed by many as a successful independent retailer standing its ground against Billy Big Bucks – has made the news as far away as North America. Sensing a PR disaster which may damage their brand but also showing genuine contrition given their stated support for the independent sector, Waterstones have rowed back. They have apologised and, to their credit, are now in meaningful dialogue with Mr Barclay. Watch this space.

“I was hoping we would get some support, but the scale and the scope of it has been unbelievable,” Mr Barclay tells me. “It’s beyond the city at this point now, I think. The story that seems to have come out of this is that it’s happening everywhere – independent businesses and chains coming more and more into conflict, with larger companies moving carelessly into communities. I was on radio in Canada last week. People are really interested in this story, seemingly as an example of the situation.”

Sitting in the cafe section of Argonaut Books and waiting for a friend is Bulgarian national Yasemin Hyuseinova, a regular customer. She knows Mr Barclay and remembers people telling him a bookshop in Leith wouldn’t fly. Time and experience have obviously proved the doubters wrong, to the point where the UK’s only major bookshop chain has taken notice and wants to move in. “There are plenty of people who read books in Leith,” she says. “It’s just knowing how to bring them together, and they’ve done an amazing job doing that here.”

As for the area itself, she sees a strong community well served by small businesses which have an investment in those communities – which is why the arrival of bigger players could be seen as a threat. “I work in a private gym down the road but we are also a social enterprise business. We help with stroke survivors, so it’s people around here. Let’s say we had other huge gyms built around us, that would impact us as well. So I understand how that feels when it comes to smaller businesses.”


Read more


What, though, of that wider picture as it relates to Leith? Might the trams be a double-edged sword, increasing footfall and access but in doing so opening up this celebrated enclave of the capital to the property speculators and chain stores? If so, can the encroachment be resisted successfully?

Much of Leith Walk, particularly the bottom section, is a retail success story thanks to independent outlets such as Argonaut Books. Here you will also find artisan bakers, cafes, gift shops, delis and more, though the area’s rumbustious pavement life hasn’t slackened much and the newcomers sit alongside century-old fixtures like The Central Bar. Even if you’ve never stepped over the threshold you will have seen inside this legendary boozer, so often does it feature in films and adverts.

Brian Malloch, co-owner of gift shop Logan Malloch, bristles slightly at the use of the g-word: gentrification. He’s aware it’s too often used as a pejorative. What he sees in his bit of Leith Walk reflects Adam Barclay’s opinion that it is probably Scotland’s longest and longest-established street of mainly independent businesses. In other words a retail ecosystem in which yes, there is churn, but in which the shifts are benign and generally helpful to consumers as well as to the wider community. “Leith has always been a melting pot and it has always had a mixed and diverse population,” he says. “Old has been next to new and we respect each other.”

He doesn’t see gentrification. Instead he sees “small businesses replacing small businesses.” Regeneration, in other words. Some change for the worse is hard to prevent, he admits, “but at the same time we can try to stop the big companies just walking in. We’re not doing the groundwork for them to just take over from here … If you let them get away with it even once there’s no stopping them.”

Leith Walk (Image: GordonTerris/Herald&Times)

One undeniable difference is that the foot of Leith Walk is now easily accessible by tram. To Mr Barclay’s eye, the project has been “mostly positive.” But the increase in footfall has perhaps come at a cost. Although he thinks the proposed Waterstones move may be related to the closure of the chain’s store in Ocean Terminal, the tram may also have been a consideration in their choice of location for a new store. “I think basically they have come out of Ocean Terminal and they were maybe looking for somewhere in Leith to go into,” he says. “I think, potentially, the tram could have pulled them to look at the Foot of the Walk, where they previously wouldn’t have.”

More broadly, there are other tram headaches such as ongoing issues with the infrastructure. “It’s hard to deny the tram has brought more people down,” he adds. “[But] I think the lasting legacy of the tram is the sadness of all the businesses that didn’t make it through the tram works. At the same time the way the tram work project was implemented – we’re still dealing with it, things like the cycle lanes. There’s bits of it that still aren’t finished. Junction Street has been under road works for about six months now … It’s all being done in a multi-contractor, haphazard way that just disrupts everyone’s lives.”

Waterstones want to put their new store in the shop which has long stood at the foot of Leith Walk, and behind the pigeon-bedevilled statue of Queen Victoria which faces back up it. Old Edinburgh hands will remember it as a Woolworths. More recently it was a British Heart Foundation shop selling second hand furniture, a commodity many Leithers still have great need of in Mr Barclay’s opinion. But whoever holds the lease, there’s no doubt it is a prime location. It’s hard to miss as you approach the Foot of the Walk tram stop which lies just beyond it, at the top of Constitution Street.

Standing outside the unit in the late morning sunshine – and greatly outnumbered by those ever-present pigeons – is Vanessa Tombs and her friend Linda Campbell. What does Ms Tombs think of the Waterstones plan and the impact it might have on the area?

Leith Walk Newkirkgate centre. (Image: GordonTerris/Herald&Times)

“My immediate thought was: ‘Great’,” she says. “It’s going to be part of the community, it’s encouraging people to read, which is great. I’m assuming there’s going to be a cafe, so it’s a place for people to meet. I can understand why they [Argonaut] might feel threatened by it, but couldn’t they just come together and work together somehow?

She adds: “I think it would really add to this area … But at the same time I don’t want others to suffer.”

As for the trams, she thinks it has been a long and at times difficult journey but broadly she is in favour. “It took a while but yes,” she says. “I think it is bringing people down here.”

Around the corner in the Newkirkgate shopping centre proper you can find branches of Costa, Poundstretcher, Poundland, Superdrug and Peacocks, the budget clothes chain. There is also a Specsavers, a Bank of Scotland and a large Lidl, as well as a pawnshop and a charity shop. In September it was bought, all 93,867 square feet of it, by Sheet Anchor Evolve, a property investment company based in Soho in London. The company also bought a shopping centre in Wallsend on the same spree. “We see great potential to reposition and enhance these assets,” said Sheet Anchor Evolve co-founder Danny O’Keefe at the time of the purchase.

For Adam Barclay, that may mean parachuting in more big name brands to disrupt one of the few retail landscapes in Edinburgh in which independents can still thrive. In agreement with that sentiment, though for different reasons perhaps, is Alison MacKenzie, who has worked in the Newkirkgate branch of Superdrug for 26 years. She doesn’t think a branch of Waterstones would have much effect on the area, and anyway it isn’t the kind of retail outlet Leith needs. And she’s scornful of the ‘re-positioning potential’ and ‘asset enhancement’ of the sort Sheet Anchor Evolve promise. “You’ll never make it posh,” she laughs, gesturing around her. “What we need here is a Farmfoods and an Iceland.”

Vanessa Tombs has thoughts on the subject too. “There’ll be blood on the streets if they close the Poundland,” she says.

With opinions divided and battle lines drawn, as the trams rumble down the famous old street, Leith Walk watches and waits.


Barry Didcock is an Edinburgh-based Herald writer and freelance journalist specialising in arts, culture and media. He can be found on X at @BarryDidcock

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos