Updated

First Minister talks to abuse expert about grooming-gangs

First Minister John Swinney arrives with Finance and Local Government Minister Shona Robison (right) for First Minister's Questions <i>(Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire)</i>
First Minister John Swinney arrives with Finance and Local Government Minister Shona Robison (right) for First Minister's Questions (Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

John Swinney has insisted that the Scottish Government is giving “every serious consideration” to calls for a grooming-gangs inquiry and will come to a decision before Christmas.

The First Minister said the issue had his "personal attention".

The comments come after the NSPCC told The Herald that “ministerial leadership” was needed to tackle child sexual abuse.

During First Minister's Questions, Tory MSP Pam Gosal claimed that ministers were “sticking their heads in the sand” over the issue.

Mr Swinney rejected that.

"There are complexities about the interaction on the call that has been made with the child-abuse inquiry that we have already statutorily established,” he told MSPs.

“There are no straightforward ways through this issue, but I assure Parliament that the Government is giving every serious consideration to this important issue.”

He added that this week he had held meetings with Police Scotland, the National Child Sexual Exploitation Group, and had “personally conducted a discussion with Professor Alexis Jay” — the former chair of the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse in England and Wales.

“I hope these details will give colleagues confidence that the Government is looking in detail at all these questions. Nobody is putting their head in the sand,” he said.

It is understood the First Minister spoke to Prof Jay on Wednesday, a day after Justice Secretary Angela Constance insisted to media that she had quoted the child-abuse expert accurately during a debate in September.

Last week, The Herald revealed that Officials quietly published a correction admitting the minister’s comments, made during September’s debate on the Victims, Witnesses and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill, were inexact.

Talking to journalists after First Minister’s Questions, Mr Swinney also confirmed that the government has reached out to Taylor, who says she was abused as a child while living in a Glasgow care home.

She had written to the SNP leader asking for a meeting.

Taylor said she and her friends “were plied with alcohol and drugs and sexually abused by at least 10 Pakistani men”.

She also says her social work files show that Police Scotland failed to investigate.

The First Minister said he had to be "enormously careful as a minister to respect the terms of reference" of the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry (SCAI).

"I understand the public concern, of course I do, and I listen carefully to members of the public and to the issues that are expressed.

"But what I was trying to do in my answer today was to set out to parliament that there are a number of considerations that we have to be mindful of, not least of which is the significance of the agreement of the existing child abuse inquiry, which I dare not intrude upon because of the statutory rights of that inquiry.

"As I've said to parliament before, I'm open to this question and that's why it's been looked at in the detail that it's been looked at.

"And it has, of course, my personal attention and the attention of my senior ministers."

Mr Swinney said he had "more conversations to undertake, as do my senior ministers, and we will, of course, share that."

SCAI’s mandate is confined to investigating serious historic abuse of children while in care — meaning children under 18 who were placed in long-term residential care or foster care in Scotland.

It looks into the “nature and extent” of physical or sexual abuse and whether institutions with legal responsibility for children in care failed in their duty to protect them.

Joani Reid, Scottish Labour MP for East Kilbride and Strathaven, who has long called for a probe, said: “After months in which he and his government blocked every move towards a proper examination of the extent of organised child abuse in Scotland no victim or campaigner is going to take John Swinney’s words on trust.

“It is essential we see action and that an independent review of the case files is announced immediately. Survivors of abuse in Scotland have had enough of delay.

“Today’s statement by the First Minister seems to mark the end of Angela Constance’s role as the key policy maker here. That can only be good news. Her misrepresentation of Alexis Jay’s views and her subsequent refusal to even apologise ought to have seen her get the sack.”

Police Scotland is currently reviewing both current and historical child sexual abuse investigations, while the Scottish Government’s National Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation Strategic Group is examining findings from the Casey National Audit, IICSA and the Jay Review of child criminal exploitation.

That group — which includes representatives from Police Scotland, local authorities, third-sector organisations, health bodies and Professor Jay herself — has already identified major data weaknesses.

Minutes show members repeatedly raising concerns about the lack of reliable information on where and how child exploitation occurs in Scotland, the difficulty of linking health and criminal-justice data, and significant differences in how agencies record, interpret and respond to abuse.

The row over Ms Constance's comments stems from her opposition to an amendment tabled by Tory MSP Liam Kerr that would have required the new Victims Commissioner for Scotland to carry out research on grooming gangs.

However, the Justice Secretary said work in this area was already being carried out by Police Scotland and the specialist National Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation Strategic Group, established in 2024.

She said Prof Jay “shares my view and has put on the record and stated to the media that she does not support further inquiries into child sexual abuse and exploitation, given the significant time and resource already spent in the review that she led, the Casey audit and other reviews.

“She says that it is now time that ‘people should just get on with it’.

“I contend that that is what the Scottish Government is doing right here, right now — we are getting on with the work that we need to do to protect children.”

Mr Kerr’s amendment was defeated by 62 votes to 51.

However, minutes of October’s meeting of the National Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation Strategic Group include a “clarification of Alexis Jay’s position on inquiries”.

It states: “During the debate on the Victims, Witnesses and Justice Reform (Scotland) Bill in Parliament on 16 September, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice quoted the views of Professor Alexis Jay on calls for further inquiries into child sexual abuse.

“Co-chair clarified that Professor Jay shared these views in January of this year in the context of her work on the Independent Inquiry in England and Wales and were not related to the debate on the Victims Bill or the position in Scotland.”

The government has refused to say if they asked Alexis Jay about a grooming gang probe

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos