Exclusive

Is the SQA being replaced or is this just a rebrand?

Replaced or rebranded? What's going on as the SQA becomes Qualifications Scotland? <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Replaced or rebranded? What's going on as the SQA becomes Qualifications Scotland? (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

As of today, Scotland has a new exam board called Qualifications Scotland. This organisation is to take over from the much-criticised Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA), which the government says it has scrapped and replaced. Critics, on the other hand, are not convinced, and many say that the current process is little more than a rebrand.

Here, education writer and former teacher James McEnaney explores the background to this story and asks whether Scotland really is getting a “new” exams body.

 

What’s the background?

Way back in 2021, on June 21, the Scottish Government announced that it was planning to replace the SQA as part of a package of education reforms. This announcement, which took many by surprise, was made as an OECD review of the Scottish education system was published.

Although the government tried to present the findings of this report as a positive endorsement of Scotland’s schools, the reality was different. Twelve recommendations were provided, and a wide range of criticisms levelled, but the technical language in which the report was written, as well as its length (the PDF is 141 pages long) meant that very few people fully engaged with the work.

What is notable, however, is that replacing the SQA was not one of the OECD’s recommendations.

Nonetheless, making this the key announcement of the day of publication drew the majority of attention, and by that point the SQA had few if any friends looking to defend the organisation.

For most of its existence, the exam board was seen as arrogant and detached at best, and an active blight on Scottish education at worst. The SQA Wikipedia page details a near-annual series of problems and scandals going back to 2015, but the true list is even longer and goes right the way back to the organisation’s inception.

Then, in 2020, when Covid forced the cancellation of exams, the SQA tried to use an algorithm to suppress the grades of pupils from the poorest areas – although it is only fair to recognise that this happened with the full support of the Scottish Government, which spent days trying to defend the policy before being forced into a humiliating U-turn in the face of huge public pressure.

The following year, with traditional exam diets still not possible, the exam board introduced another system which once again led to enormous criticism of both the way in which pupils were being treated and the SQA’s refusal to trust teachers.

At a time when the government was under ever-increasing pressure on education issues, announcing that the SQA would be scrapped drew fairly widespread support for the SNP while also keeping attention away from the specifics of the OECD’s critique.

 

How were things supposed to change?

Having confirmed that the SQA would be removed, the government immediately commissioned an independent review to work up proposals for its replacements. This work was led by Professor Ken Muir, and explored the organisational structures of the key bodies in Scottish education – the soon-to-be- abolished exam board, and Education Scotland – a hybrid organisation charged with both curricular development and school inspection. The government had already confirmed that inspections would be removed to an independent body, reversing the SNP’s own policy decision from several years before.

Muir’s report recommended a range of changes, including that the functions of the SQA be split and an entirely new organisation created. The review identified a critical but little-discussed issue in Scottish education – that the SQA was both an exam board and the regulator of the sector as a whole. It also pointed out that the organisation faces no competition in Scotland.

Instead, Muir and his team advised that the new exam board should focus simply on developing and awarding qualifications, while a new national agency be tasked with accreditation and regulation. The idea was to make the systems underpinning Scottish education far more robust and avoid a situation where the SQA could be accused to marking its own homework. Although the report acknowledges the argument that Scotland, as a small country, benefits from having the SQA perform dual roles, Muir argued that “these advantages are significantly outweighed by the need to restore the trust and confidence of the public.”

So the SQA was to be scrapped, with a genuinely new organisation built to replace it, while the powers it held were to be split across two organisations, as is the norm elsewhere.


Read More:


 

What is actually happening?

Ultimately, the SNP decided that it did not want to split the functions of the SQA; instead, the exam board’s successor organisation would retain all of powers and responsibilities that were already in place. Although political parties pushed back to varying degrees, the Greens ultimately fell in line as expected, and the Liberal Democrats also offered support, allowing the government to push through changes that failed to implement what was arguably the critical recommendation of the government’s own review.

Defenders of this move argue that the creation of new roles and rules and committees will solve the problem, but it seems unlikely that those sorts of changes would be able to affect the sort of major cultural changes that are apparently required. It is also optimistic in the extreme to think that they will “restore the trust and confidence of the public.”

The new SQA – to be known as Qualifications Scotland – therefore has the same powers as the old SQA. It therefore remains open to the same criticisms that it benefits from, and protects itself via, a glaring conflict of interest that undermines Scottish education more broadly. In short, many will still believe that the exam board is permitted to mark its own homework.

The leadership structure of the organisation has also been changed, with some new roles being created and a new CEO appointed – although the latter only happened after the previous leader resigned amidst huge criticism and a disastrous committee appearance at Holyrood.

Officials at the exam board now claim that they work for a new organisation that has been “designed from the ground up to work differently”.

According to a press release from the SQA, Qualifications Scotland began work on December 2, 2025 and will become “fully operational on February 2, 2026.”

 

What happens now?

Unsurprisingly, the main criticism of this whole process has been that the SQA is simply being rebranded, not replaced. It is certainly the case that mostly the same people are continuing in mostly the same roles, and that the apparently new organisation has retained all of the same powers as its predecessor. To many, this falls considerably short of what the government promised.

The refusal to split the functions of the exam board has also been sharply criticised, including by Professor Muir himself, who called the changes that had ultimately been delivered “disappointing.” Scotland’s biggest teaching union also lamented a “missed opportunity” that would not deliver the changes that were needed.

The exam board is also yet to shake off recent criticism of the way in which it handled Higher History marking in 2024, or of the attempt to dismiss concerns after the SQA’s own staff investigated the situation and exonerated their colleagues.

More recently, the exam board admitted that nearly a fifth of markers are considering quitting, with a significant number citing their frustrations with the SQA as a main reason.

New research confirms that teachers have become even less positive about the SQA than they were a year ago. Just two percent of the profession said that credibility of the organisation is “very high”, while more than two thirds said that it is either fairly or very low. Some describe the repeated insistence that everything is getting better, and that the SQA really is being “replaced”, as gaslighting, which might help to explain rising levels of hostility from those in the classroom. Those in management have also become dramatically less positive about the organisation in the space of just one year – in fact, their views have shifted even more than teachers.

In recent weeks, the SQA has once again been criticised for the alleged “unfair” treatment of pupils over exam timetabling. Officials have refused to consider changes, with one headteacher telling The Herald: “The SQA’s response, intransigence and lack of concern for pupils is as disappointing as it is predictable.”

For Qualifications Scotland to have any chance of convincing people that it is indeed a completely different organisation from the SQA, it will have to change to such a degree that it genuinely becomes unrecognisable.

So far, the early signs don’t look good.

 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos