Douglas Ross is well aware that the leadership style he brings to Holyrood’s education committee is unorthodox.
As convener, the MSP and former Scottish Conservative leader does not hover politely over proceedings. Instead, he presses witnesses. He challenges, interrupts, and becomes visibly impatient when he thinks someone is dodging a question.
It’s a style that has drawn criticism, and a style that he owns.
After being named Committee MSP of the Year at The Herald’s Scottish Politician of the Year Awards in association with Scottish Power, Mr Ross sat with me to talk about what he brings to his committee and what he thinks of the state of education in Scotland.
I saw how naturally he comes by his style as a politician. His time in Holyrood has been spent almost entirely as the spearhead of opposition, after all.
He also left me feeling that it is no accident that here in the twilight of his current Holyrood tenure (he is standing down next year to try for a return to Westminster), he has found himself convener of the Education, Children and Young People Committee.
Douglas Ross winning Committee MSP of the Year (Image: GordonTerris/Herald&Times)
Judging on education
Education has become excruciatingly political in Scotland. Mr Ross knows that and admitted the role he has played in fuelling it. He also said that, for better or worse, it really can’t be any other way.
In 2015, then First Minister Nicola Sturgeon urged Scotland to judge her on her record in education. In the decade since, the SNP has kept that priority, and has in fact doubled down on it repeatedly.
During our interview, data was released which showed the government was thousands of teachers short of key recruitment targets. Mr Ross’s reaction was to be expected.
“There will be lots of blame laid elsewhere, rather than fairly and squarely with a government who made a very clear, unambiguous commitment to do something and who is going to fail.
“I would have a lot more respect for ministers and the government if they just said, ‘Look, we oversold our hand at the time. We wanted to do this, but we can’t.’”
As Mr Ross tells it, the SNP government has essentially handed a playbook to opposition members.
“Education is political because a former First Minister made it her number one priority. Nicola Sturgeon was crystal clear on that. If there are failings in education, you have to look at the government who, again, wanted praise if things are going well and need to be scrutinised and challenged if things are not going well.”
As leader, Mr Ross had pressed for his party to have the education committee.
This was partly personal, because he did not feel that education was getting the recognition it deserved.
It was also political: “In the past, justice is a big committee for conservatives; in the past, we’ve had rural, because a lot of our seats are rural. And I said that these are really important issues, but I want education as our top committee—that’s the one we go for. Because it is a political issue, and it’s the issue that the First Minister at the time wanted to be judged on.
“I felt that made it the most important committee for the main opposition party to get.”
Now that he is himself in the ‘hot seat’ as convener, the committee is a tool for what he feels is the responsibility to hold the government and institutions to account.
'Overly robust', 'adversarial' and effective
Mr Ross was the first to bring up his style in committee hearings—"overly robust” and “adversarial" to use his words—and he was also the first to mention the criticism.
So I asked him why he believes his approach is the right one.
“I wouldn’t say that it’s the right way,” he said. “But it’s my way so people are stuck with it.”
He was quick to stress that he was not being flippant. He described his approach as part of the balance he believes a committee needs if it is to function effectively.
“If the whole committee were like me, it wouldn’t work. And if the whole committee were the polar opposite, it wouldn’t work.
“I actually think you’ve got to have a mixture. I think my style has got some answers out of people that we wouldn’t otherwise have had.
“Likewise, the style of other members of the committee has got answers that I maybe don’t get from being overly robust and adversarial.”
Holyrood's Education Committee (Image: Andrew Cowan)
He was also keen to stress that the criticism does not fall on deaf ears — even if, at times, it may look that way.
“I have listened when colleagues have said, ‘Look, we felt uncomfortable, we didn’t like that.’ I take that on board, and maybe the next week I try to tone it down again.”
He added: “And then something comes up and I forget about it.”
This was a recurring pattern in our conversation: a diagnosis, a recognition that there are ways he can improve, and an acknowledgement that he is who he is and will eventually need another reminder.
Talk of his style also opened the door for us to discuss two committee sessions that stood out over the past year. In one, Mr Ross tangled with government and quasi-government officials in a set of exchanges that would have been right at home in the debating chamber; in the other, his committee clashed with a prestigious institution which, he felt, demonstrated why prestige is no substitute for experience.
Reactive rather than rigid
When asked about his approach to the committee in the most logistical sense, Mr Ross told me he is sceptical of a calendar fixed months in advance.
“All committees do their work programmes for the next few months, and we can fill our days with legislation and other issues.
“But I was getting frustrated that there were emerging issues that the committee — put in place by this Parliament to look at educational issues — apparently had no time to look at.”
That instinct was shown during the committee’s examination of the Scottish Qualifications Authority in December 2024.
Following The Herald’s reporting on large swings in Higher History attainment and teachers’ reaction to the SQA’s response, Mr Ross found himself thinking: “Here we have the opportunity to call the SQA in. We can take in the chief executive and others and get answers.”
“And when I read their report and started listening to the answers from (Chief Executive) Fiona Robertson at the time, I thought, ‘What she is saying does not match what’s in the report that they had done into their own failings.’”
The resulting session was tense and, at times, uncomfortable to watch.
“I was quite robust that day,” he admitted. “Some people on the committee didn’t like it, but I felt it was right that that issue got raised.”
He took further solace from later testimony, when a panel of history teachers took questions and gave evidence. Mr Ross said that he understands completely the fine line that teachers have to walk when speaking openly about the SQA or their employers. But in their evidence session, representatives from the Scottish Association for the Teaching of History were frank and open with their concerns and experiences.
He told me that he hoped some of that was because he had ‘taken the heat’ earlier in the day.
“I could see how difficult it was for those teachers, in some cases feeling like they could have done more years ago about conduct within the SQA. But I also hope that in some way the committee helped them to express themselves, because it had already been pretty robust up to that point.”
What stayed with him more, however, was the reaction from outside the committee room.
“You come back to your office and there’s a heap of emails from people saying, ‘Thank God you’re asking these questions. We’ve been wondering the same thing. Don’t give up on this issue. Keep going at them.’”
SQA leaders were recalled for another session in 2025, but Ms Robertson resigned before the scheduled appearance.
That contrast — discomfort inside the room and something closer to relief outside it — reinforced Mr Ross’s belief that the committee has an obligation to be on top of current events.
He found his next opportunity to do this in March 2025, when news broke of a reported £35 million budget shortfall and potential job losses at Dundee University.
Rather than take a week off after a cancelled session, the committee called in senior university figures — many of them in interim roles following a wave of resignations — to answer questions.
The result was another tense series of hearings, which The Herald’s political editor Andrew Learmonth described as “one of the most astonishing Holyrood committee sessions” he had ever watched.
Senior university officials faced tough questions about how no one seemed to realise what was happening, until an interim finance director flagged the problem on day one; representatives from the Scottish Funding Council (SFC) were grilled about whether they had failed in their oversight duties.
Douglas Ross at committee (Image: Andrew Cowan)
In the aftermath, the Scottish Government stepped in with an unprecedented bailout for the university, and there has been another leadership change at the institution.
Mr Ross defended the tone from the day, arguing that urgency demanded firmness. I also got the sense that, although he didn’t say it explicitly, Mr Ross felt that the committee’s ability to step in at the start of the news cycle was critical.
The answers given that day were not rehearsed, and they cast light on a situation that might otherwise have been blurred by self-preservation if the key players had had more time to consider. It also triggered a rare wave of cross-party consensus among members who appeared universally aghast at what they were hearing.
What’s next for Scottish education?
The urgency he brings to committee work also colours Mr Ross’s view of what comes next. He was adamant with me that education cannot be allowed to drift.
As elections approach, however, he worries that politics will once again crowd out problem-solving. Perhaps because he will not be an active participant—or maybe because he is Douglas Ross—his views were blunter than those I have received from party press offices in recent months.
“The politician in me thinks nothing will change before then, because politics is about winning votes.
“But something has to change, because if we continue doing what we’re doing, we’re going to end up with more Dundees.
“The crucial point is going to be from May to October next year, when a new government, whether it’s continuing the current party or totally new, comes in and has an opportunity to do something different.”
I tried to wrap up with a softball: “What is the biggest problem facing education in Scotland?”
But Mr Ross laughed it off with a very professional response: If he answers ‘x’, then everyone will say he doesn’t care about a dozen other problems.
So I asked: “Out of all those problems you could list but won’t, what is actually fixable?”
He said first that underfunding at universities and colleges can be fixed, though the solution would not be popular.
Then he reconsidered. What he really thinks is achievable is fixing the tone of debate itself — and that he and his colleagues have to pull their weight in doing so.
“In a number of areas where we have problems, we need to make Scottish education more appealing for people to become involved in again.
“And look, some of that is on opposition politicians. If you continually criticise elements, you’re making it less attractive. That doesn’t mean you should stop scrutinising it and challenging it, but maybe there is something we have to look at that makes whatever sector of Scottish education more appealing for the best and brightest to get involved in.”
Mr Ross still has some time left in his tenure as convener, and if nothing else, viewers can count on tough questions, tough answers and, if nothing else, good copy for newspaper editors.
Share