2026 is an election year and it looks as though the SNP will win a fifth straight term in office. With the Parliament’s performance under scrutiny, Andy Maciver suggests three major changes which he argues could make people proud of Holyrood.
As we enter a new year, we also enter an election year at our Scottish Parliament. This will be the seventh election to Holyrood, and it comes at a time when devolution is in trouble.
Public sentiment is on the slide. In days past, you would struggle to find one-in-10 people who wanted to see the Scottish Parliament scrapped; in a number of polls over the last couple of years, this proportion has risen to around one-fifth.
This is tough for someone, like me, who believes in devolution conceptually and wants it to succeed. But it is also perfectly understandable. Even as a supporter, and as someone who has been involved, on and off, with the devolved Parliament for almost all of its quarter century, the performance of the institution troubles me. I cannot unthinkingly support the claim that Holyrood has tangibly improved the lives of people in Scotland.
Indeed, it feels compelling to entertain the notion that decisions made by devolved Parliaments and Governments have actually damaged Scotland and Scots. That is not to say the rest of the UK is in particularly good shape; it most decidedly isn’t. Nonetheless, one can look at particular policy areas and see Scotland as dangerously deficient.
Read more:
- Reform earthquake will bring British mainstream politics crashing down
- Doctors’ pay is poor, but they should never strike
- What Malcolm Offord’s move to Reform means for Scottish politics
- Scottish Labour needs to declare independence from their London bosses
School education, a blind spot for the Scottish Government, is in a terrible place, and is probably the best example of a public service which has decayed during the devolution era. However it is a component of a worrying trend, of more and more money being spent without an identifiable improvement in performance. In 1999, at the outset of devolution, Scotland spent something around 41 per cent of our GDP on public expenditure; today, we spend 52 per cent.
To place this in context, aside from Finland, all of our Scandinavian neighbours spend between 47 and 47 per cent. Comparing us to other Anglo-Saxon countries with similar systems is no more heartening; the US, Canada, Australia and New Zealand all spend between 36 and 42 per cent. The Irish spend only 23 per cent.
The sad truth is that devolution is in a bit of a doom loop. We are short of ambition, and we are short of ideas. So for Holyrood, this new year and this new election also represents another chance to get it right. As a political ‘community’, there are three major, structural changes we could make which would give devolution a fighting chance.
None of these three proposals would be popular with the public. It doesn’t matter. Sometimes we must make changes which we know, in the long-term, will improve the Parliament, create the foundation for better decisions and, as a result, make life better for everyone.
The first change is to the party system. UK political parties have, in essence, rigged devolution against themselves, and created a situation where when their Westminster party sneezes, the Scottish party catches a cold.
If there is one person who should understand this the most, today, it is Anas Sarwar, Labour’s Scottish leader. He is a deeply competent and credible leader, but in May he will be judged based on Sir Keir Starmer’s performance rather than his own. He is not the only one. Tavish Scott, the former leader of the Liberal Democrats, suffered the same fate, as has every leader of the Conservative party. That fate is to be defenestrated by the Scottish electorate because of something done by your party at Westminster.
It makes life incredibly easy for the SNP, which in truth has to do very little to repeatedly win. The party of nationalism is about to win a fifth term in office despite poor approval ratings, and despite, in some cases by its own admission, having made a very poor fist of government in the few years before John Swinney took the helm.
What Holyrood needs is a series of new parties who believe in remaining in the UK, in one form or another, but who are completely independent of parties at the Westminster parliament. The party which eventually beats the SNP does not yet exist, in my view. It needs to be created very, very soon.
The second change revolves around the MSPs who will populate these new parties, and indeed who will populate the SNP in future. I regularly give political presentations to clients and audiences, and I often ask them to raise their hands if they would be an MSP. No hands rise. I then ask them to raise their hands if they would be an MSP if the salary was doubled to £150,000. Several hands rise.
The reality is that there is a cohort of very able, very engaged people who currently have jobs which pay around the same or more than an MSPs earns, but with none of the abuse, none of the negativity and none of the scrutiny, and which take less time, less travel and less intrusion into family life.
These are the people with the ideas and the ambition we need. If we pay them, we get them.
However, when they get there, they need to be able to put these ideas and ambition into practice. And, therefore, the third structural change we need is to dramatically increase the power of the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Government, particularly when it comes to tax.
I know that, for many people, the thought of this Parliament being given more power will be horrifying. However the truth is that, in many cases, Scotland’s relatively poor performance is exacerbated by devolution’s limits.
For instance, it is difficult to use taxation as a tool to promote economic growth when the only meaningful tax over which Scotland has control is income tax, and when the fiscal framework in place to manage the relationship between Westminster and Holyrood is itself a straight-jacket.
Earlier, I noted that the Irish spend only 23 per cent of their GDP. It is helpful, in that endeavour, for them to have control over Corporation Tax, which they set low in order to attract major corporations, paying tax and employing lots of people who also pay tax.
None of these changes are easy or uncontroversial, but they are all necessary in order to turn the Scottish Parliament into the institution the Scottish public need it to be.
If the Scottish Parliament doesn’t change, we might legitimately ask the question why it is there at all.
Andy Maciver is Founding Director of Message Matters, and co-host of the Holyrood Sources podcast
Share