Unspun 🗳️

Holyrood prepares for major turnover as SNP prepare budget

Sign up for the Unspun politics newsletter and receive exclusive analysis and opinion straight to <i>(Image: Herald Design)</i>
Sign up for the Unspun politics newsletter and receive exclusive analysis and opinion straight to (Image: Herald Design)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter.


For some of our MSPs, returning to Holyrood next Tuesday after the Christmas recess, it will be their final term in Parliament.

We know that at least 40 are standing down at the election, but if the polls are correct it will likely be the final term for a good few more too.

It’s hard to overstate how much Holyrood will change in May.

It’s not just that there’ll be new faces — a sizeable bloc of which seem likely to come from Nigel Farage’s Reform UK — but a real loss of institutional knowledge.

People who know how government works and, crucially, some of the Parliament’s most effective opposition.

John Swinney should, by rights, be one of those heading for the door.

You may remember that in December 2023, the University of Glasgow’s Centre for Public Policy made him an Honorary Professor, and had tasked him with helping to develop their education programme and supporting staff in how to “engage effectively with the policy process.”

Four months later, Humza Yousaf resigned, forcing Professor Swinney — like that other famous Scottish academic, Indiana Jones — to abandon the lecture hall and mount a rescue bid to stop a powerful relic falling into the wrong hands.

When he took over, he was described as a reluctant leader.

“I felt I had — to coin a phrase — done my bit,” he said during his first speech as SNP leader.

“To find myself accepting office as first minister of Scotland today is therefore, to utter a classic understatement, something of a surprise.”

When I spoke to the First Minister before Christmas for the interview that ran in last Sunday’s paper, he confirmed that his ambition was to fight the 2031 election, that there was more of his bit to do.

John Swinney speaking to The Herald's Andrew Learmonth (Image: Gordon Terris)

I wasn’t surprised, I don’t suppose he could have said anything else when I asked, but the truth is that Mr Swinney is not just no longer reluctant, he’s ambitious.

Very few First Ministers get to choose the timing of their resignation, and Mr Swinney doesn’t know how long he has left in office, but unless something dramatic happens he seems likely to outlast Sir Keir Starmer.

Thanks a good part to the Prime Minister’s ability to stand on rakes which smack Anas Sarwar in the face, the SNP are on course to remain Scotland’s largest party — though likely without a majority and possibly with fewer seats than they currently hold.

There is an irony in the prospect that this could be the most consequential election of devolution, and yet its most important outcome — who governs Scotland — appears set to follow the same path as the last four.

Still, we are four months away from the vote, and much could happen.

One of the big hurdles for the First Minister is this month’s budget.

Finance Secretary Shona Robison — who is one of those MSPs with less than 100 days left to enjoy the think-pod in their Holyrood office — will set out the Scottish Government’s tax and spending plans on January 13.

Every choice will come under scrutiny for both its economic impact and its political consequences.

In recent years, the Scottish Government has used powers over tax to add new income tax bands, freeze thresholds, and set higher rates for top earners.

That means Scots earning above around £28,850, pay more income tax than they would elsewhere in the UK.

However, as well as the political appetite for any further hikes being low, the government’s tax strategy for the remainder of this Parliament commits to no new income tax bands or rate increases before May 2026.

It allows ministers to uprate the starter- and basic-rate bands by at least inflation, and while it commits them to freezing the higher, advanced and additional-rate thresholds, it says this “will be reviewed annually at the Budget”.

According to ITV Border, Mr Swinney and Ms Robison could look at increasing the higher-rate threshold — the point at which people start paying the higher 42% rate.

Get Scotland's top politics newsletter straight to your inbox.

Raising that threshold modestly — effectively giving middle earners a tax break — could differentiate Scotland from the UK, where Chancellor Rachel Reeves froze income tax bands in her last budget, a move widely seen as a “stealth tax”.

That could help John Swinney win back the middle-class voters who deserted the SNP in the 2024 UK general election.

Of course, to get the budget of his minority government passed, the First Minister will need to make a deal.

That’s no mean feat, especially as we hurtle towards the dissolution of Parliament and the seventh Holyrood election.

Happy new year!

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos