What polling reveals about the 2026 Holyrood election

How much will change come the Scottish elections in May? <i>(Image: NQ)</i>
How much will change come the Scottish elections in May? (Image: NQ)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

In just over four months, voters will elect a Scottish Parliament unlike any before it.

Whatever the result in Holyrood’s seventh election, the Parliament that returns in May will be a markedly different place from the one that dissolves this spring.

At least 40 MSPs have already confirmed they will stand down. A handful more are expected to follow. Add to that those who will contest the election and lose, and the scale of turnover begins to look extraordinary.

It is no exaggeration to suggest that as much as half of the Parliament — and possibly more — could be new.

This could be the most consequential election of the devolution era — and yet, in its headline outcome, one of the least surprising.

Ahead of a pivotal year in Scottish politics, The Herald on Sunday sat down with polling expert Mark Diffley of the Diffley Partnership to look at how the 2026 election might play out.

John Swinney’s party has spent much of the past year hovering around the mid-30s in vote share — a far cry from the 48% it secured in the 2021 Holyrood election, but still enough to dominate the electoral map.

In normal circumstances, a party shedding more than 10 points since the last election might expect to be staring at defeat. But these are not normal circumstances. What has changed most dramatically since 2021 is the fragmentation of the opposition.

Because the non-SNP vote is now split across Labour, the Tories, the Greens, the Liberal Democrats and — crucially — Reform UK, polling suggests that the SNP can “do almost as well” in terms of seat distribution on 35% as they did in 2021 on 48%, Mr Diffley says.

“That would be enough to win the vast majority of the constituencies that they currently hold, so they might not get up to the 64 seats they got in 2021. It looks like they will get somewhere in the mid to late 50s.”

That leaves the party short of a majority, perhaps, but still comfortably ahead of their political rivals.

Polling suggests John Swinney could lead the SNP into its fifth term (Image: Andrew Milligan)

The bigger question might now be who finishes second.

The most striking development in Scottish polling over the past year has been the rise of Reform UK.

The party began 2025 polling in the low teens. By the end of the year, it was regularly touching 20%, and in four of the last five polls it has been in second place.

That could mean around 20 MSPs — almost all elected via the regional list, predicts Mr Diffley.

“There are signs UK-wide that Reform may have hit something of a ceiling, with their polling beginning to edge down slightly. Whether that is a temporary blip or something more significant remains to be seen. They are still ahead in UK-wide polls, but by smaller margins than before. We are not really seeing that in Scotland yet. It does not look as though they have reached a ceiling here, so that is something to watch over the next few months.”

That poses a direct threat to Labour, whose collapse from the highs of the 2024 general election has been one of the more brutal reversals in recent Scottish political history.

After winning 37 Westminster seats north of the border in 2024, the party's expectations of a Holyrood revival were high.

Scottish Labour is still better resourced than the SNP, and they believe — as was shown in the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election — that they have a better ground game.

But hopes that they can turn round a 20-point deficit are fading.

“This is really a battle of two incumbents,” Mr Diffley says. “The 19-year incumbency of the SNP versus the two-year incumbency of the UK Labour government. And voters at this point seem to be more inclined to punish the record of the UK government rather than the SNP Scottish Government.”

Anas Sarwar needs a 'period of calm' from Keir Starmer (Image: PA)

If Labour fails to make a breakthrough in May, then Sir Keir Starmer will almost certainly find himself facing a leadership challenge.

And even if Labour defy the odds and do better than expected in Holyrood, he will need a decent result in the elections in Wales, and the local elections in England, to silence the chatter.

That is a big ask.

So can Scottish Labour defy the odds? For Anas Sarwar, the hope is that as the election approaches, the electorate’s focus will turn to the domestic record of the SNP.

“The Scottish Government is not popular with voters,” says Mr Diffley. “The SNP’s vote share is down. If you look at what the public thinks about the Scottish Government’s performance on things like education, health and so on, it is not good.

“But Labour, equally, does not appear to be in a position to capitalise on that as things stand.”

“Scottish Labour really needs a period of quiet from down south,” he adds. “It needs there to be less calamity and chaos, and more governing. It strikes me that Labour in Scotland just cannot get on the front foot.

"They could have the best manifesto known to man, but if what people are consuming is just chaos, division, a leadership contest, or whatever else is coming out of the Labour government in Westminster, then voters just will not be listening.”

Could Scottish Labour claw back votes from Reform?

“Interestingly, the fall in support for Reform at a UK level — whether that is temporary or more permanent — comes at a time when the party is under greater scrutiny.

“If you look at UK-wide polling data on economic competence, that is where Reform tends to struggle.

“It is not seen particularly favourably by the electorate in terms of its position on the UK economy.

"Given what we know about voters in Scotland, where the economy is one of the two big issues alongside the NHS going into the Holyrood election, there may be an opportunity for other parties to claw back some of that support from Reform if they are not seen as economically competent once manifestos are launched and detailed policies are scrutinised.

“That is probably one of the reasons they have brought Malcolm Offord in. He is seen as more pro-business and economically competent, and quite different from some of the other semi-well-known figures in Reform in Scotland at this point.

"They clearly see the danger of where their Achilles heel might be and will be hoping he helps project that sense of economic competence when it really matters.”

“If Labour can claw back some of the support it has lost to Reform over the last 18 months, that would obviously benefit Labour — not necessarily to the point of winning the election, but certainly enough to make it a closer contest and potentially push Reform back into third place.”

Malcolm Offord and Nigel Farage (Image: PA)

What about independence? John Swinney's position, backed by SNP members at conference, is that if the party wins a majority of seats at the Holyrood election, this will then be taken by the Scottish Government as a mandate to start negotiations for a second vote.

The First Minister has not said what happens if the SNP gets less than 65 MSPs.

Polling suggests support for independence is around 50%. But with the SNP stuck in the mid-30s, the party’s task is to mobilise Yes supporters without turning independence into a turn-off for voters focused on day-to-day concerns.

“Very few people want an independence referendum any time soon,” Mr Diffley says. “When you ask people what their priorities are, another referendum ranks relatively low — only around one in ten mention it as a top-three issue."

“The SNP needs to walk the line of keeping independence on the agenda, because it is the SNP and because it still motivates the party’s core support, but without talking about it so much that it puts off voters who are not looking for a referendum in the near future.

“The SNP read the polls. They can see the mood, and talking about independence too much becomes a gift to the Conservatives and to Reform in particular. So it is a delicate path for them to walk, as ever.”

If the polling is borne out, by the end of 2026 Scotland may well have the same party in government, the same First Minister and the same unresolved constitutional questions — but a very different Holyrood.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos