Exclusive

Thousands still attending crumbling and overcrowded schools

Despite progress, thousands of Scottish pupils still attend school in poor quality buildings <i>(Image: NAC)</i>
Despite progress, thousands of Scottish pupils still attend school in poor quality buildings (Image: NAC)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Tens of thousands of pupils in Scotland are still being educated in school buildings that are either substandard or overcrowded, according to official data.

Despite significant improvements since 2007, Scottish Government figures on the nation’s school estate show that significant numbers of young people go to schools that are in poor physical condition, are considered unsuitable for modern education, or have been filled to, or above, their stated capacity.

In response to the revelations, Scotland's Children's Commissioner has warned that pupils must not miss out on educational experiences because of problems with their school environment, while the leader of the country’s largest teaching union raised particular concerns about schools operating over their planned capacity.

Scottish Labour accused the SNP of being complacent over school standards, but the Scottish Government says that its investment has seen a record number of schools rated as ‘Good’ or ‘Satisfactory’.

According to the most recent statistics, more than 50,000 pupils – around 7.5 percent of the national total – attend class in buildings that are either rated as being in ‘Poor’ or ‘Bad’ condition.

The figures, published in September 2025m show that a total of 189 schools have been categorised as ‘Poor’. This means that they are “showing major defects and/or not operating adequately”, for example because it cannot function without being continuously repaired.

In addition to this, six schools are rated as ‘Bad’, which is simply defined as meaning that the “economic life” of the building has expired, or that there is a “risk of failure.”

A more detailed breakdown reveals that roughly 7 percent of primary schools, 8 percent of special schools, and 11 percent of secondary schools fall into these categories.

As well as the physical condition of the buildings, schools in Scotland are also assessed for overall suitability. Government figures show that on this measure, a larger number are considered to be inadequate.

In total, 252 schools are rated as ‘Poor’ for suitability, which means that the school building or its grounds are “showing major problems” and actively “impede the delivery of activities that are needed for children and communities in the school.”

A further 11 schools have been assessed as ‘Bad’ under this measure. These buildings simply do not support appropriate activities and are a “serious” impediment to education.

Around 10 percent of primary schools, 13 percent of secondary schools, and 16 percent of special schools, are not regarded as offering an acceptable level of suitability for educational purposes.

This affects more than 70,000 pupils – equivalent to around 11 percent of all those attending school in Scotland.


Use our searchable database to find out the current ratings for your child's school


The condition and suitability of Scotland’s school estate has improved dramatically over the past two decades thanks to rebuilds and refurbishments. Many of these were initially funded through PFI schemes under the Labour-Liberal Democrat administration, or under the NPD model introduced by the SNP when it first won power at Holyrood in 2007.

However, a significant number of pupils are still expected to attend school in buildings that are considered inadequate. Of the schools currently classed as being in ‘Poor’ or ‘Bad’ condition, only around one-third are scheduled for improvement works in the coming years.

More than 85,000 pupils are also attending schools that have either reached, or exceeded, their planned capacity, raising fears about the impact of classroom overcrowding on their education.

In total, 108 schools are currently recording pupils numbers equal to, or above, the expected maximum occupancy figure, and a further 102 schools have reached 95-100 percent of planned capacity.

The most overcrowded primary school in Scotland is in Gartcosh, North Lanarkshire. This school was built to accommodate 188 pupils but, according to official data, had a recorded school roll of 265. This means that the school has been operating at 141 percent of capacity.

At secondary level, the most overcrowded school in Scotland is Kemnay Academy in Aberdeenshire, which has space for 730 pupils but reported an actual total of 958, taking it to 131 percent of capacity.

Across the country as a whole, 46 primary schools and 62 secondary schools are noted as being at, or over, 100 percent capacity.

Although government data does contain information about the total number of learners at each special school in Scotland, the figures for planned capacity are not provided, making it impossible to determine how many have been pushed beyond their intended pupil numbers.

Nicola Killean, Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, said:

“The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) – which is enshrined in Scots law – says that every child has the right to an education that develops their personality, talents, and abilities to their full potential.

“The state has an obligation to use resources to the maximum extent possible to realise children's rights and that includes in school buildings to make them as positive and accessible an environment as possible. They should be safe, warm, and comfortable and have the space needed for an effective human rights-based education.

“Children should not miss out on activities or curriculum choices because their school environment cannot deliver this. 

“I spent nearly a year talking to many children and young people about their experiences of education, culminating in my report This Is Our Lives, It Matters A Lot: Putting Children’s Rights At The Heart Of Education. It contains recommendations for the Scottish Government and education authorities to urgently reform the system so it works for all children. One recommendation – from children – was to ensure all education settings have the funding and resources they need to provide the best support and education. The Scottish Government must listen to what children are telling us and act accordingly.”


READ MORE


Andrea Bradley, General Secretary of the EIS teachers’ union, said:

“The EIS acknowledges the progress that has been made in improving the school estate, nationally, in recent years. The Scottish Government has placed a priority on supporting the refurbishment and rebuilding of many schools, which has brought benefits to learners and staff alike.

“As these figures make clear, however, there is still much work to be done to ensure that all learners and teachers are working in school buildings which are both well maintained and fit for purpose. In particular, it is concerning that so many young people are being taught in schools that are over capacity. Such environments are not sustainable. Furthermore, with around 7.5% of pupils and teachers in schools that are in bad or poor condition, and with over 10% in schools which are deemed poor or bad for suitability, the Scottish Government and local authorities must commit to taking all necessary steps to improve these schools."

“The working conditions of teachers are the learning conditions of young people and the EIS takes the matter of ensuring that school buildings are safe extremely seriously. An example of this is the current statutory ballot for industrial action of EIS members at Lenzie Academy, in response to long held concerns regarding the safety of the school building. The formal dispute at Lenzie Academy must be resolved urgently.

“All learners and teachers must have the right to work and to learn in school buildings which are both safe and secure and which also provide an appropriate environment for learning and teaching.”

Scottish Labour education spokesperson Paul O'Kane accused the SNP of being “complacent” and “content to rest on its laurels while thousands of kids are stuck trying to learn in woeful conditions.”

He added:

“Every child in Scotland deserves the best possible education and we need a government with the ambition to deliver that.

“We need a Scottish Labour government will deliver the leadership that has been sorely lacking under the SNP and build an education system that provides opportunities for all.”

A Scottish Government spokesperson said:

“Direct Scottish Government investment, in partnership with local authorities, has seen the number of schools in ‘good’ and ‘satisfactory’ condition increase from 62.7% in 2007 to a record 92% in 2025.

“It is the statutory responsibility of councils to manage and maintain the school estate and to ensure there is adequate and efficient school provision in their area. Decisions on the school estate are for them to take.

“The Scottish Government is continuing to invest in the school estate through the £2 billion Learning Estate Investment Programme and over 1,150 school builds or substantial refurbishment projects have been completed during the last 17 years.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos