What has Nicola Sturgeon done since resigning as First Minister three years ago and has she already checked out of frontline politics?
Ms Sturgeon continued to be the SNP MSP for Glasgow Southside after she stood down as First Minister in March 2023 and still has three months left to go in that position before parliament dissolves ahead of the May election.
Her allies insist that since stepping down as First Minister she still continues to represent her constituents and champion issues she cares about - such as care experienced young people, gender equality, and climate justice.
But since announcing her resignation at her Bute House press conference almost three years ago it is not hard to get the impression she has already essentially moved on from the day to day business of politics.
Read More:
- Swinney legal action to stop secret Sturgeon files release
- Scotland population - the data on how the nation is changing
- Nicola Sturgeon: 'I'm happier now than I've ever been'
- Nicola Sturgeon to make last minute appearance at SNP conference
- Nicola Sturgeon named best politician of the last 30 years
- Nicola Sturgeon: 'I’m not coming back to frontline politics'
Unlike John Swinney, who became a member of a Holyrood committee after he resigned as her deputy - only later to be elected SNP leader and First Minister - the former FM - like her immediate successor Humza Yousaf - does not sit on any parliamentary committees nor has she any other role in parliament beyond being a humble SNP backbencher.
She holds no role for instance on the body which runs parliament - its corporate body - as other former party leaders have - and critics say she has not appeared to have devoted herself to a particular cause close to her heart as other former SNP and Labour First Ministers have done.
She did not play a prominent role in her party's 2024 general election campaign, though she did appear as a pundit on ITV, alongside former politicians George Osborne and Ed Balls, to comment as the results came in - a decision which raised eyebrows in Holyrood at the time.
Nicola Sturgeon signing copies of her memoir at the SNP conference last year (Image: Jane Barlow)
The main perception many voters have of the former FM is of someone who has been writing and enthusiastically promoting her memoir, Frankly, published last August, and embracing a new career as a writer.
She is currently more often pictured at book festivals and cultural events up and down Britain and Ireland than at political or parliamentary meetings.
And while she did speak at a fringe meeting at last year's SNP annual conference to defend her work on care experienced children, she also found time to sign copies of her book at the Aberdeen gathering.
Ms Sturgeon herself has been keen to give the impression of someone who has embarked on a new life outside the cut and thrust of Holyrood.
Read More:
- Sturgeon legacy: SNP wins, Branchform, Salmond, gender
- Scot pushing for secret Sturgeon files not 'hopeful'
- Scot Gov told to release evidence into Nicola Sturgeon probe
- A marriage hit by heartache and a police investigation
Speaking at Edinburgh’s Hogmanay festival, the former First Minister, who will turn 56 this summer, said she felt younger than she had felt “in a long, long time” after stepping down from the “all-consuming” role, and that she was still undergoing a “transition” and “reimagining” of her life.
At Muckle Be The Light, an event hosted by the Edinburgh Makar, poet and novelist Michael Pedersen and rock singer Shirley Manson, frontwoman of the band Garbage, the SNP MSP told the audience at Portobello Town Hall that she had a “different perspective” and could view issues more “objectively” since leaving Bute House.
Mr Pedersen, who suggested that Ms Sturgeon had embarked on a "rock star tour" to promote Frankly, asked whether launching herself as a writer had made her happy.
Ms Sturgeon said: "I’ve loved it. I’m probably happier now than I have been in my entire life. I feel younger than I have felt in a long, long time. Part of that is the experience of writing, publishing and promoting the book."
She added: "My caveat is I don’t feel that I can justifiably call myself a writer yet. People who write non-fiction are real writers who write wonderful books. I’m not suggesting otherwise.
"Maybe this is because of my love of novels, but I don’t think I will feel that I can really do that until the point that I have written and published and novel."
Unlike most writers, eking out a living in a chilly garret, Ms Sturgeon has a high income as an MSP, earning a salary of £74,507 this year and of course received a handsome advance for Frankly from her publisher.
Nicola Sturgeon was a pundit for ITV commenting on the general election (Image: ITV)
James Mitchell, professor of public policy at Edinburgh University, and a critic of the former First Minister, said she is unusual in being a former First Minister who has not championed any specific cause or causes since leaving office.
"Other than Donald Dewar, who of course died in office, all other former First Ministers continued to contribute significantly to politics and/or public life after leaving office," James Mitchell, professor of public policy at University of Edinburgh told The Herald on Sunday.
"Henry McLeish has chaired various important Commissions, notably on prisons, and is active across a variety of policy areas including brain health and dementia research as well as contributing to public debates (not least in his recent co-authored book reflecting on and learning lessons from our experience of devolution).
"Jack McConnell’s work in Malawi along with his other contributions continue his life-long commitment to social justice. He has also chaired Enlighten, formerly Reform Scotland think tank. Alex Salmond continued to play a prominent part in campaigning for independence. Even Humza Yousaf, hapless as First Minister, has been a keen and determined campaigner on Palestinian rights.
"Nicola Sturgeon stands out from former First Ministers in deciding to largely abandon the political field while remaining an MSP though with the occasional foray trying to defend her record. All senior politicians love the limelight of course but usually do try to align personal interests with personal political commitments.
"Many take time to reflect - more or less honestly - on their period in office. That can be helpful as lessons can be learned for other aspiring senior politicians and from the perspective of political history. Having read countless political memoirs and autobiographies over many decades, I can think of none that lack as much self-awareness or as unreliable as her mistitled ‘Frankly’".
It is a view those close to Ms Sturgeon reject.
"Since stepping down as FM, Nicola has represented her constituents and championed the issues she cares about - such as care experienced young people, gender equality, and climate justice," her spokeswoman told The Herald on Sunday.
"She doesn't expect her long-standing critics to ever see past their blinkered views of her - but she has enjoyed sharing her thoughts on these and other issues with the several thousands of people who have come along to hear her speak at a events all over the UK in recent months."
Her spokeswoman went on to say that "Nicola is looking forward to unveiling the projects she intends to pursue when she leaves parliament later this year."
Nevertheless few could deny that while, on leaving office, Mr McLeish embraced prison reform, Mr Salmond the fight for Scottish independence, Mr Yousaf the plight of people in Gaza and Lord McConnell tackling poverty and ill-health in Malawi, Ms Sturgeon has been occupied writing and promoting her book.
Maybe with the circumstances she faced - she was arrested during the long running Police Scotland investigation Operation Branchform - which ended last year with her no longer being under investigation - she felt a need to spend time dedicated to her interpretation of her record.
This would not have been an issue had Ms Sturgeon stepped down as an MSP in February 2023 as well as First Minister.
Had she done so, she would not have faced the accusation of side-lining her role as an elected politician for her apparently preferred role as a writer.
But by not doing so, she has left herself open to criticism.
“It’s clear Nicola Sturgeon has already downed tools to embrace her new post-politics lifestyle when she still has constituents in Glasgow Southside to represent," said Scottish Conservative MSP Annie Wells.
“They’re entitled to be furious that she has been off on lavish jollies and busy promoting her book, when she is being paid handsomely to be their MSP.
“While some of her predecessors may have chosen to focus on more charitable causes, the only thing Nicola Sturgeon now seems interested in is promoting herself.
“For as long as she’s still drawing an MSP salary, she should focus on the day job.”
As a high profile public figure, in the three years since stepping down as FM, Ms Sturgeon could have become a prominent advocate for tackling important causes at home or overseas she championed while in office - fighting child poverty and abuse, addressing climate change, promoting women's rights and access to health and education.
Maybe she will still do, once the book tours and signings are over.
Share