Exclusive

Scottish Budget report card: SNP 'could do better' on education

The Scottish Budget confirms that education is no longer a top priority <i>(Image: Derek McArthur)</i>
The Scottish Budget confirms that education is no longer a top priority (Image: Derek McArthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

We already knew that the days of education being the SNP’s ‘top priority’ were long gone, but there’s an election around the corner, so a few giveaways were always likely.

The party has already been posting on social media about the promise of ‘a breakfast club for every primary school by August 2027’, and that certainly sounds like a good idea, but if you go back to their 2021 manifesto (which they’re very much hoping you don’t) then you will find a pledge to provide “provide free school breakfasts and lunches to every primary school pupil.” As parents of pupils in upper-primary will already know, that promise has been broken.

So today’s Scottish Budget announcement is actually offering less than what the party promised a few years ago, and if they do manage to make this happen, the new deadline will still leave them a couple of years late on the breakfast element.

But even leaving that aside, we need to know more about the details. This is, after all, the government that insisted that it had funded a significant increase in teacher numbers, only for the latest stats to show that it had failed to hit any of its own targets in that area. The party also promised every single pupil in Scotland a free laptop and free internet, and then did not bother to follow through.


Read more:


Given that councils actually run schools (something that government press officers are always at pains to point out…when it suits them) it seems likely that the breakfast club money will go to local authorities, who will then be expected to actually implement the policy. The money might be ring-fenced, but it might not, and councils might not agree that this proposal is in fact fully funded. The government can’t possibly expect teachers to staff these breakfast clubs (the profession is currently being balloted for strike action over other broken promises and unmanageable workloads) so new employees could be needed in many cases, which complicates things even further.

Ultimately, this announcement is very much in keeping with the SNP’s approach in recent years, and that isn’t a good thing.

The budget also included other announcements that will, directly or indirectly, affect Scottish education. The small increase in council funding could support a much-needed reduction in teachers’ contact time, and it could be used to enhance provision for those with additional support needs (who now make up nearly half of all pupils). But given cuts to council budgets in recent years, the impact of inflation, and the sheer scale of problems to be addressed, it probably makes sense to hold off on too much optimism at this stage.

The budget also included other announcements that will, directly or indirectly, affect Scottish education (Image: Derek McArthur)

Colleges are getting more money, but the increase doesn’t make up for the scale of the cuts they have faced over the last few years: the government has announced a 10 percent increase, but the sector has faced a 20 percent real terms cut since 2021. The government will want to present this as a major step forward for further education in Scotland, but in reality it looks like an attempt to undo a proportion of the damage that ministers have already inflicted in recent years.

Some absences have already been noted as well. The National Day Nurseries Association, for example, said that it is disappointed that the government has not moved to “address [their] concerns about underfunding and access to early learning and childcare.”

If the Scottish Government’s final budget before the election is getting a report card, the kindest conclusion is probably: could do better.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos