Updated

Court rejects Biffa’s £51.4m claim over deposit scheme

DALGETY BAY, SCOTLAND - MARCH 6: A sign on works under way outside an Asda supermarket in <i>(Image: Ken Jack)</i>
DALGETY BAY, SCOTLAND - MARCH 6: A sign on works under way outside an Asda supermarket in (Image: Ken Jack)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The Court of Session has dismissed a multi-million pound legal challenge by waste firm Biffa over the collapse of Scotland’s botched Deposit Return Scheme.

In a lengthy judgment issued on Friday, Lord Sandison rejected the company's claims that Scottish Government ministers negligently misled the company or owed it a duty of care when the flagship recycling scheme was delayed and ultimately shelved.

He accused them of "wishful thinking" akin to "something approaching the alchemy capable of transmuting base metal into gold".

Biffa was appointed as the official logistics provider for Scotland’s DRS in July 2022 under a 10-year contract with Circularity Scotland, the non-profit set up to administer the scheme.

The company claims it invested £51.4 million to prepare for the project’s launch, including spending on vehicles, equipment and infrastructure, as well as a depot in Motherwell. The firm was also recruiting staff.

It expected to make £114.8 million in profits over the decade.

Biffa argued that those costs, and its anticipated profits, were lost when the scheme was delayed and ultimately collapsed.

Scotland’s DRS fell through in 2023 when the Scottish Government moved to delay the scheme for two and a half years following a dispute with the UK Government.

Lorna Slater was the minister responsible for the DRS (Image: PA)

At the time, Green MSP Lorna Slater, then the circular economy minister, blamed the Tories after ministers in Whitehall made clear the Scottish Government would only be granted the necessary exemption to the UK Internal Market Act if substantial changes were made.

These included removing glass from the scheme, standardised labelling, and a uniform deposit charge across the UK.

Ms Slater said the lack of detail around the conditions laid down by Whitehall, including uncertainty about the deposit charge, meant the scheme could not go ahead as planned.

However, Circularity Scotland insisted the scheme could have complied with the UK Government’s demands.

Despite that, Ms Slater announced in June 2023 that the DRS would be delayed until “at least October 2025” — before a further postponement pushed any potential start date to 2027.

Circularity Scotland fell into administration weeks later, leaving debts of more than £86 million, including £8 million owed to the Scottish National Investment Bank. Its contract with Biffa was terminated.

The case was heard over eight days last year, and heard evidence from Ms Slater and Lord Alister Jack, the former Scottish Secretary.

The judge said the two politicians "appeared to me to be truthful in relation to the matters of fact to which they spoke and to be recounting in good faith what they thought about the matters of opinion about which they were asked to speak".

Central to Biffa’s case was a letter sent in May 2022 by Ms Slater, which the company said reassured it the scheme was fully supported by government and on a secure legislative footing.

The minister wrote to Michael Topham, the CEO of Biffa, to say that the government's "commitment to delivering DRS" by August 2023 was "unwavering".

She continued: "I hope this letter provides reassurance on the Scottish Government’s continuing commitment to DRS and I am happy to provide any further information that may assist in making a decision whether to proceed".

He regarded that as an "absolute rock-solid commitment" which was "akin to a guarantee" and told the court that it was a "decisive factor" in his recommendation to the Biffa board to sign the contract.

Biffa's legal team argued that the letter constituted a "half-truth" because of what it omitted.

The company claimed the letter amounted to a negligent misrepresentation because it failed to warn that the scheme required approval from the UK Government, which had not been sought at that point and was far from guaranteed.

However, Lord Sandison ruled that the ministerial letter was a statement of political commitment rather than a legally binding assurance covering every regulatory risk.

He concluded that it did not amount to a representation that all legal obstacles — including those connected to the IMA — had been resolved.

"I do not accept that a reasonable person could have looked at the words used in the letter and taken them either as amounting to a general statement that there was no risk that the scheme would not be proceeding and that all would be well," he said.

The judge added that it was "difficult to see" how a reasonable person "could have taken that the message being conveyed was anything more than was being frankly stated."

"Something much more than the wishful thinking upon which the pursuer’s case appears to proceed in this regard would be required, indeed something approaching the alchemy capable of transmuting base metal into gold, so far are the words used from the meaning which the pursuer requires."

Lord Sandison said he accepted that Ms Slater believed the scheme would proceed despite the lack of an IMA exclusion. 

He noted: "The belief of Ms Slater, genuinely held on at least colourable grounds until early 2023, that the matter of the IMA exclusion was unlikely actually to pose a problem for the scheme".

The judge also rejected Biffa’s argument that ministers had assumed responsibility for protecting it from loss.

Biffa has said they will consult with legal advisers over the ruling

While accepting that only the Scottish Government could seek an exclusion from the IMA, he held that this did not create a duty of care to a commercial contractor.

Ministers, he said, were acting in a public policy and regulatory capacity, not as a guarantor of the scheme’s success.

Crucially, the court found that Biffa, as an experienced operator, could not reasonably treat a ministerial “comfort letter” as eliminating all legislative and political risk.

As a result, Lord Sandison dismissed the action in its entirety, meaning there will be no separate hearing on damages and no compensation payable.

Responding to the ruling, a spokesperson for the Scottish Greens said: “This case has shown the worst of Westminster and the contempt the Tories have for the Scottish Parliament and for our environment.

“MSPs voted to introduce a recycling scheme, with businesses investing money to make it happen.

“There are bottles, cans and glass littering our parks, beaches and streets. This scheme would have led to more of them being recycled.

“Devolution is not working for Scotland. The fact that one person in Westminster was able to topple the scheme against the will of the Scottish Parliament underlines the urgent need for our country to have the same powers as every other self-governing nation.”

A Biffa spokesperson said: “We note today’s decision and are reviewing our position with our legal advisors.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos