LETTERS

Jenrick jumps to Reform – but what’s the reason behind move?

Nigel Farage has enticed another high profile politician to Reform UK. <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Nigel Farage has enticed another high profile politician to Reform UK. (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

I am less than convinced by the explanation given by Robert Jenrick concerning his departure from the Conservative Party, i.e. that he decided to join Nigel Farage because the Reform UK leader is the only person capable of fixing ‘broken Britain’ (“Robert Jenrick Joins Reform UK after being sacked by Kemi Badenoch”, www.herald.com, January 15).

To me this smacks of thwarted ambition.

After all, he stood for leadership of the Conservative Party against Kemi Badenoch in November 2024, and lost.

Had he won, he would no doubt be singing a different tune now.

The Jenrick announcement certainly meant that the appointment of Lord Offord, former minister at the Scottish Office, who is to lead Reform UK in Scotland, was greeted with less than acclamation.

Ian W Thomson, Lenzie.


More letters...

Roadmaps out of lockdown ignore the very real problems millions will face in months to come

Shackles of the Union mean that England can dictate our health spending choices

Calculating Johnson has one eye on developing Tory leadership vacuum


Conservatives’ immigration betrayal

Listening to a member of the shadow cabinet on the radio call Robert Jenrick, the MP who has just defected to Reform UK, a “Judas”, I was struck by the Tory’s complete lack of self-awareness.

It is only because the Conservative Party has, over fourteen years, repeatedly promised to reduce immigration, and has not merely failed to do so, but during the ‘Boris wave’ actually raised it far beyond anything previously seen, that Reform UK has become a major party.

As a result, much of the British public views the Conservatives as a party of Judases.

At the same time, they see Mr Jenrick as being on the side of the angels, because he sincerely wants to control immigration.

Otto Inglis, Crossgates, Fife.

Reject Reform UK

Ian Lakin (Letters, January 14) rejects the opportunities independence would create for Scotland, preferring, instead, to be influenced by the same self-interested opportunists who foisted Brexit upon us.

If Reform UK was given the chance to “break the consensus” as he suggests, they certainly would be a “genuinely disruptive alternative” as they attempted to mimic the behaviour of the current occupants in the White House.

Hopefully the prospect of such a toxic future will be rejected overwhelmingly by true Scots who are capable of making more optimistic political choices.

Charlie Shaw, Rutherglen.

HMG shouldn’t warn SNP

John Swinney is “deeply concerned” that he did not know about the Venezuelan-linked oil tanker being in the Moray Firth until he learned about it from the media (“Russian tanker berths for supplies”, The Herald, January 15).

He feels aggrieved about not having had an advance briefing on the issue from His Majesty’s Government (HMG).

Waters around the UK are UK waters. HMG is responsible for security within these waters. Security is provided by the British armed forces.

Further, some of us remember how Ms Sturgeon used to rush out of Cobra meetings, during Covid, to ensure her version of them reached the media before official government statements.

It can scarcely be a surprise to Mr Swinney that HMG wishes to maintain confidentiality in security matters, and does not feel an SNP regime trustworthy in that respect.

Jill Stephenson, Edinburgh.

Slightly used peace prize

IF anyone was in any doubt about the childlike behaviour of Donald J Trump, it was notable in his obvious pleasure at receiving the second-hand Nobel Peace Prize from the actual winner, Maria Corina Machado.

It was also a waste of time for Ms Machado, as it achieved nothing for her.

However, it made Mr Trump smile inanely, as it was his second peace prize.

A tremendous ‘achievement’ for someone who recently grabbed the Venezuelan President, and has launched several military strikes.

His reaction only goes to prove his unsuitability for the position of President.

Ian Smith, Troon.

Burns understood Gaza

We have all heard how ‘complicated’ the conflict in Gaza and the West Bank is. That complexity lies in competing versions of history.

The current appalling situation does not.

The brutality inflicted on innocents is untenable. The suffering and injustice are simple; it is the excuses used to justify them that create a fog, obscuring the truth.

Politicians and diplomats speak of necessity and conditional agreements. They do not speak of the unnecessary deaths, the torture, or the starvation.

And civilians pay the price for that arrogance.

Robert Burns says it best: “Ye Hypocrites, are these your pranks? To murder men and give God thanks? Desist for shame! Proceed no further: God won't accept your thanks for murder.”

Judith Campbell, Portree.

Government must consult fishermen

The flawed articles by Sarah Campbell and Vicky Allan, quoting research by Open Seas, require a response (“Scallops in boost to economy”, The Herald, January 13); (“They are one of Scotland’s food treasures, so why are scallops now so problematic?”, The Herald, January 14).

The ‘survey’ by Open Seas is an Argyll report, and I would not comment were they not, as environmental lobbyists, pressurising government to close more fishing grounds to already hard-pressed fishermen.

It appears that fishermen in Argyll need to improve marketing of their catch if they only achieve £849 per tonne for scallops caught by dredge (The Herald’s figure).

The Scottish average was £1973 per tonne and the Western Isles average was £400 per tonne, more than the Scottish average, reflecting better quality. Argyll scallops will be equally good.

These figures are easily verified and obtainable.

It appears not much effort went into establishing the accuracy of Open Seas ‘survey’ by your journalists.

In the weeks before Christmas, the price of dredged scallops in the Western Isles was a high of £3090 per tonne and so far, landings in 2026, are £2671 per tonne.

I will leave it to your readers to conclude the effect Open Seas’ erroneous figures have on their Economic Impact Assessment.

Other assertions in their report are equally inaccurate.

There must be a wide variety of fishing methods in Scotland.

The creeling sector does not want trawling and dredging banned. These two methods are much reduced already, and the creeling sector want a creel limitation brought in.

There has been an explosion in creel numbers to try and maintain catches, and if the trawling and dredging sector moved to creeling, the price of langoustine and other shellfish would collapse.

A few consecutive days of good weather, even at current levels of effort sees a glut on the market.

What will this number of floats and ropes do for cetacean entanglements and ghost fishing?

All food production leaves a footprint, whether on land or at sea.

Scallop dredging and bottom trawling seabed damage is extremely small in comparison to natural events which completely alter the seabed and destroy huge areas of shellfish and habitat.

Thousands of creels have gone into the water in the last thirty years. Where do they all finish up?

The Scottish Government needs to take time for a proper management plan, taking account of all fishing methods, as well as other marine users including leisure, wind farming and aquaculture.

After the disastrous HPMAs (Highly Protected Marine Areas) episode, knee-jerk reactions are not what is needed.

It is too bad Open Seas are miffed that instant closures of seabed areas aren’t happening and processing factories aren’t closing, leaving whole communities in ruins.

Given the inaccuracies of Open Seas research, the Scottish government would do well to ignore them and consult with fishermen and marine scientists.

When making Economic Impact Assessments, ensure your economic values are correct.

To avoid modern jargon and to use a more polite term, we will say that when you put rubbish in, you get rubbish out.

Hector Stewart, Manager of Kallin Shellfish, Isle of North Uist.

Heat pumps not viable

The recent MCS (Microgeneration Certification Scheme) Foundation survey indicated 60% of Scots would chose a heat pump "if cost were guaranteed to be lower than a gas boiler" (“Ministers told to ban gas boilers in 2035”, The Herald, January 15).

As an early adopted of a heat pump, can I persuade them otherwise.

Unlike a gas boiler, which heats a house quickly, professional advice and personal experience is that to heat a house effectively, a heat pump has to run 24 hours a day.

At 2000 electricity prices that was still economic, but present prices make a heat pump much more costly to run, notwithstanding the capital cost of installation.

Heat pumps are promoted as extracting four times the heat per kilowatt of energy used than boilers.

Unfortunately electricity prices are 4-5 time higher per kilowatt than gas, all because of Government decarbonization policies.

Furthermore, electricity prices do not fall when wholesale gas prices do. Electricity price increases are such that I have switched off my heat pump and reverted to a gas boiler, and my energy bill has fallen.

The idea of a heat pump is good, but only with Norwegian hydroelectric electricity prices or cheap Scottish wind power.

In the UK heat pumps are presently not economic, and forcing change may increase rather than decrease fuel poverty.

Gavin R Tait, East Kilbride.

The dirt on Glasgow

I am hoping councillors wake up and smell the coffee… Glasgow is a mess.

I note the Transport Convenor is suggesting more Glaswegians are using cycle lanes (“City looks at bringing in free bus shuttle service”, The Herald, January 10).

Would he like one to run past the main entrance of the City Chambers?

Doesn’t he realise potholes are worse than ever, with the council paying three times more than previously in compensation claims to motorists who keep this city moving and alive?

The council is spending £20 million to spruce up George Square, with no indication of erecting more street lights or CCTV in this prestigious part of the city.

Meanwhile, residents have been waiting up to forty two days to get bins emptied, meaning a Christmas party for the rats.

Unlit lamps are in many places in the city, which is a safety issue for males and females.

The city centre is like a third world city; people with addiction problems hang around, drug dealing.

I just hope the city is in a fit state for the Commonwealth Games.

S. Smith, Glasgow.

The numbers racket

Having settled into a splendid read of the Herald, it became apparent there have been a number of surveys taking place, all condemning something or other.

Nowhere was it indicated the volume of people questioned for such important surveys.

I’m just curious to know…

Hamish Donald, Bathgate.

Bad sportsmanship

Donald Trump has suspended immigration into America from seventy five countries.

Some of these nations will be playing at this year’s World Cup.

Nations affected by the ban include Brazil and Morocco, who will be competing in the opening game of Scotland's group in the tournament.

If FIFA had a backbone they would immediately cancel the World Cup and reschedule for 2027 in Europe.

I’m sure London, Paris, Rome, and dare I say Scotland, would be happy to host.

We mustn’t allow Mr Trump to dictate the running of the biggest tournament in the world.

Jim O’Neil, Renfrewshire.

TV used to involve The Sopranos, Succession and Mad Men. Now it’s just about a chap called Nigel… (Image: Derek McArthur)

Do not adjust your set…

Something went wrong with my TV reception the other evening. I could only get “Farage news conference” on all the channels.

GR Weir, Ochiltree.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos