Exclusive

Swinney told to apologise for blocking Sturgeon files release

Nicola Sturgeon with Alex Salmond on the General Election campaign trail in Inverurie in the Gordon constituency in 2015. <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Nicola Sturgeon with Alex Salmond on the General Election campaign trail in Inverurie in the Gordon constituency in 2015. (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Fergus Ewing has called for John Swinney to apologise to a transparency campaigner for the Scottish Government spending five years blocking his request for secret files relating to an inquiry into Nicola Sturgeon.

The former SNP cabinet minister, who now sits as an independent MSP, made the demand as he accused the Scottish Government of risking being in contempt of freedom of information (FOI) laws over the request for evidence from an inquiry into Ms Sturgeon.

Benjamin Harrop made his FOI request to the government in April 2021 seeking written evidence given to Irish lawyer James Hamilton's probe into whether Ms Sturgeon broke the ministerial code in how she acted in relation to allegations made against her late predecessor Alex Salmond.


Read More:


"Mr Harrop has doggedly pursued his case and his arguments have largely been accepted by the Commissioner and the courts in preference to those of the Scottish Government and its expensive lawyers," Mr Ewing, an ally of the late Mr Salmond, told The Herald.

"The First Minister must release the documents, tell the truth and apologise to both Mr Harrop and to the people of Scotland. If he fails to do so the question is ''What has he got to hide?'"

Mr Ewing said FOI requests are supposed to be answered in 20 working days under the law, but he argued the one relating to the probe into Ms Sturgeon "will take over five years spanning three parliamentary terms".


Read More:


Mr Hamilton concluded in his report of March 2021 that Ms Sturgeon did not breach the ministerial code relating to her conduct in dealing with the allegations.

However, in a two-page note, he underlined his frustration with a considerable number of redactions that were made to the document ahead of its publication by the Scottish Government.

The Scottish Information Commissioner David Hamilton ruled in November that the government should release some of the files Mr Harrop requested.

But it refused, lodging an appeal against the decision in the Court of Session saying it would breach court orders protecting the identity of the women who made complaints about Mr Salmond and be in contempt of court to disclose the evidence.

Mr Salmond, who was cleared in court of all charges, died in October 2024, aged 69.

On Friday, Commissioner David Hamilton said the government faces potential contempt of court proceedings if the files are not released by January 22.

Former SNP minister Fergus Ewing, who is now an independent MSP (Image: PA)

Mr Ewing told The Herald Mr Harrop's five year wait "surely constitutes clear evidence that the SNP Government shows contempt for the law of the rights of citizens of freedom of information".

He argued that the Commissioner made serial criticism of the Scottish Government in handling FOI requests relating to the James Hamilton case including condemning it continuing to withhold documents, for factual discrepancies in its responses and for changing its position on reasons for withholding information and for spending "huge" amounts of taxpayers money to prevent release of information both on legal fees in fighting the case and using up the resource of the Commissioner.

Mr Ewing added: "On Friday the Commissioner said 'the government’s last minute response reflects poorly on ministers and disrespects the applicant and the wider Scottish Public on a matter of significant public interest'.

"Given the Commissioner has himself ordered the release of documents, it now appears that the Scottish Government’s argument that they cannot do so because of the risk of “jigsaw ID” is simply a pretext which is being used to as an excuse to withhold all of the documents from the public.

"It is now clear that one of the applications Mr Harrop has made, that in April 2021, which is being challenged in the courts by the Scottish Government, will not be concluded until after the Holyrood elections in May, raising questions about what exactly they have to hide from the public.

"It also means that it will have taken over five years and a full Session of Parliament to block an FOI request.

"Whilst the First Minister repeatedly asserts his unshakeable commitment to obeying the law and to the rule of law, he appears ready to flout the law in failing to comply with the Commissioner’s direction, and block and obstruct the application of the law by using every trick in the book, and huge sums of taxpayers money, to delay, deny and obfuscate."

A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “The Scottish Government has lodged an appeal with the Court of Session challenging the Scottish Information Commissioner's decision on a freedom of information request for evidence submitted to the Hamilton investigation.

"We consider that the Commissioner erred in relation to the law on whether the information can be withheld because it risks breaching contempt of court orders. The Scottish Government cannot release information which would amount to a contempt of court.

 “It would otherwise not be appropriate to comment on what is now live litigation.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos