Unspun 🗳️

Can Sarwar’s war over 'Salmond files' win over SNP voters?

Scottish Labour's Anas Sarwar is taking aim at First Minister John Swinney to 'stop the cover ups' <i>(Image: Graphic: Derek McArthur)</i>
Scottish Labour's Anas Sarwar is taking aim at First Minister John Swinney to 'stop the cover ups' (Image: Graphic: Derek McArthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

This article appears as part of the  Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter.


Scottish Labour chiefs Anas Sarwar and Jackie Baillie on Monday invited the press to the stunning Trades Hall in Glasgow to announce a war on 'secret Scotland' as part of their bid to remove John Swinney's SNP from power.

Their immediate focus was the 'Salmond files' which Mr Sarwar said he would open up should he replace Mr Swinney as First Minister this May.

So what's behind Labour's sudden interest in how Nicola Sturgeon handled complaints against Alex Salmond and the investigation of her actions by senior Irish lawyer James Hamilton five years ago?

The 'Salmond files' or you could say 'the Sturgeon files' - as they relate to evidence given to Mr Hamilton's probe - is not an issue Labour has devoted much attention to in recent months and it is probably not a pressing matter for a large section of the population.


Read More:


I suspect if I walked down Sauchiehall Street and asked shoppers 'do you think John Swinney should release the Salmond files?' I would be met with lots of blank faces.

However, regardless of whether the particular battle between the Scottish Information Commissioner David Hamilton and Mr Swinney's government over the documents has cut through into the minds of the general public, it is clearly a move by Labour designed to appeal to disaffected SNP voters.

Some SNP voters may have stopped supporting the SNP because of the Sturgeon/Salmond psychodrama.

And, as the 2024 general election results showed, some SNP voters can quite happily switch to Labour if they believe it may be in their interests to do so, for instance toppling the Conservatives from power in Westminster.

Unfortunately for Labour, polls suggest that many of those SNP voters who backed Labour in 2024 have now stopped supporting them and have either moved back to the SNP or maybe decided to back Nigel Farage's Reform UK.

But what is also behind Mr Sarwar's intervention on the 'Salmond files' is a bid to seize the news agenda and get voters focused on  what he would say would be shortcomings and 'cover ups' of the Scottish Government rather than dwelling on any shortcomings of the UK Labour government.

It was also significant at Monday's press conference that the Scottish Labour leader called for a criminal probe into the contaminated water scandal at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital, again raising questions over how open government figures have been over the matter.

Polling expert Mark Diffley told Unspun there was a rationale behind the Labour strategy as the issue of 'the Salmond files' and any cover ups regarding the QEUH may resonant with voters' wider concerns about trust in politics.

Get Scotland's top politics newsletter straight to your inbox.


"I don't trust John Swinney" Mr Sarwar repeated several times at his press conference on Monday whether pressed about his failure to release the 'Salmond files' or over the contaminated water scandal at the QEUH.

The big question is whether with the SNP which is leading the polls with around 35% of voters backing them in the constituency ballot while 17% back Labour the strategy will work.

"If Labour can successful pin some of these issues onto the SNP and attempt to change the narrative and seize the initiative it gives them an opportunity," said Mr Diffley.

"They want voters to focus on the performance of the Scottish Government rather the constant focus on the UK Government but polling suggests voters are currently more focused on punishing the UK Labour government than they are on the Scottish Government."

He added: "You can absolutely see Labour's rationale. If they manage to successful change the narrative they may have a better chance of closing the gap with the SNP - but it is a big if."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos