John Swinney was today accused of failing to publish evidence into a probe into Nicola Sturgeon in order to prevent "extreme embarrassment" to members and former members of Scottish Government.
The accusation was made by former SNP minister Fergus Ewing who earlier this week called for the First Minister to apologise for not disclosing some of the evidence given to Irish lawyer James Hamilton's probe as ordered by the information watchdog.
Ms Sturgeon referred herself to Mr Hamilton – the independent adviser on the ministerial code – in response to allegations she had misled Holyrood in relation to the inquiry into a botched investigation of harassment complaints against her predecesor the late Alex Salmond.
Read More:
- Swinney legal action to stop secret Sturgeon files release
- Scot pushing for secret Sturgeon files not 'hopeful'
- Scot Gov told to release evidence into Nicola Sturgeon probe
- Scot pushing for secret Sturgeon files not 'hopeful'
Mr Hamilton concluded in his report in March 2021 that Ms Sturgeon did not breach the ministerial code relating to her conduct in dealing with allegations against Alex Salmond.
But in a two-page note to his report, he underlined his frustration with a considerable number of redactions that were made to the document ahead of its publication by the Scottish Government.
David Hamilton, the Scottish Information Commissioner, said in November, the government should publish some of the files which followed an freedom of information request in April 2021.
But earlier this month the Scottish Government lodged an appeal challenging the Commissioner's ruling arguing he had "erred in law" and that the government would be in contempt of court to make the documents public as it would breach court orders protecting the identity of women who made complaints against Mr Salmond.
Mr Ewing today told the Holyrood chamber at First Minister's Question that he did not believe the Commissioner would make a ruling that would lead to the government being in contempt of court.
"What the First Minister hasn't said...is that James Hamilton, when he produced his report, himself in public, in an unprecedented move, expressed its severe reservations with the redactions that he was required to meet, and moreover, the orders made regarding the release of other information have been made by David Hamilton," he said.
"James and David Hamilton are individuals of the highest repute and integrity, and they would not invite him to do anything that was illegal.
"So my question is, isn't the First Minister using the excuse of jigsaw identification as a human shield, as a pretext for declining to release information, because the real reason is it will cause extreme embarrassment to several people who are in the Scottish Government now and previously were in that trusted position."
Mr Swinney disagreed: "I cannot find it in myself to associate myself with the words that Mr Ewing has made of the quote excuse of jigsaw identification, because that question lies at the very heart of the provision of statute in this country, and my duty as First Minister at all times is to obey the law. And Mr Ewing is inviting me to be cavalier with the orders that have been passed by a court in this country."
Ms Sturgeon referred herself to James Hamilton – the independent adviser on the ministerial code – in response to allegations she had misled Holyrood in relation to the inquiry into a botched investigation of harassment complaints against Mr Salmond.
On Monday Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar said he would release what he called the 'Salmond files' should he be elected First Minister in May.
The move was welcomed by Mr Ewing but criticised by Mr Salmond's niece Christina Hendry who described it as 'political opportunism'.
Share