Swinney vows Salmond Files will be released before May vote

John Swinney promises release of 'Salmond Files' before Holyrood election <i>(Image: PA)</i>
John Swinney promises release of 'Salmond Files' before Holyrood election (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

First Minister John Swinney has promised his government will release the so-called Salmond Files ahead of May’s Holyrood election.

His commitment comes after the Scottish Information Commissioner, David Hamilton, instructed solicitors to begin proceedings in the Court of Session after ministers missed two deadlines to hand over documents relating to the James Hamilton investigation into whether Nicola Sturgeon breached the ministerial code.

Benjamin Harrop, a member of the public, lodged the original FOI request seeking access to some of the evidence considered by James Hamilton.

Ministers refused, arguing that disclosure could lead to “jigsaw identification” of those who accused Alex Salmond of sexual harassment.

Mr Harrop appealed to the Scottish Information Commissioner, who issued a decision notice instructing ministers to hand over some documents.

However, they failed to comply, and a second deadline of January 22 was set, with a warning that the Commissioner would bring legal action if this was not met.

Again, the Scottish Government did not hand over the papers, prompting the watchdog to begin court action.

It is the first time in the history of his office that such a step has been taken.

On Friday, the Scottish Government lodged an appeal with the Court of Session over both Mr Harrop's request and a similar FOI request covering the same material submitted by The Herald.

In a letter to us, the government said it "considers the Scottish Information Commissioner erred in law" around the issues relating to contempt of court.

Speaking on BBC Scotland’s Sunday Show, Mr Swinney said the government faced a “real risk” of acting unlawfully if it got the process wrong.

“There’s a Freedom of Information request that relates to the inquiry conducted by James Hamilton into whether Nicola Sturgeon breached the ministerial code,” he said. “And the Information Commissioner has said that we’ve got information we’ve got to disclose.

“I’m concerned that if the government gets that wrong, we will breach court orders which have been put in place by a court to protect the identity of women who’ve complained.”

When it was put to him that the commissioner had said he was not asking ministers to break the law but simply to comply with it, Mr Swinney said the situation was complex.

“There’s a live FOI request that we are going to answer, but we have to take just a little bit more time to make sure we get that right and we don’t cross the line and disclose information that breaches court orders,” he said.

Pressed on why the process had taken weeks after the government had previously suggested it could respond within 44 hours, Mr Swinney said: “We’ve got to look at the interaction between that case and the two cases that we are appealing to the Court of Session, because we are concerned that we would be at risk of acting in a manner that breached the court orders that were put in place to protect the identities.”

He added: “I cannot do anything that runs the risk of disclosing the identities of women who have come forward in good faith, protected by the courts to make complaints in cases of alleged sexual assault.”

Nicola Sturgeon giving evidence to Holyrood's Salmond Inquiry (Image: JEFF J MITCHELL)

The Commissioner’s office is dealing with six different freedom of information appeals relating to the Sturgeon and Salmond inquiries, and Mr Swinney has said almost 90 requests have been received in total.

He insisted the documents would not be withheld until after the election. “No, definitely not after the election, definitely not,” he said.

Mr Swinney also rejected claims that his administration was failing to be transparent.

Mr Swinney said: “We’re answering an increasing number of freedom of information requests, and we’re answering an increasing number of those on time. So 96% of freedom of information requests, a rising number, are answered on time.

“And in relation to the issues you put to me about the James Hamilton inquiry, the government has already answered and addressed 90 freedom of information requests and reviews. So the government is publishing and making available more information than any government has ever, at any stage in the past, ever made public.”

He added: “We are trying to observe a really important principle that we should not disclose the information and identities of women who have come forward to complain about alleged sexual assault.

“If we go back to other issues that have been talked about for many years in Scotland, we have bemoaned the fact that women have not been confident to come forward when they have been the victims of sexual assault.

"Now we have women doing it, and I am being invited to jeopardise the protection in place. That is the issue, and I want to make sure that I act properly to those who make complaints.”

James Hamilton himself has previously complained that his published report was heavily redacted and “presents an incomplete and even at times misleading version of what happened”, but said he was bound by court orders.

Last week, Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar promised that if he became First Minister he would release what he called the “Salmond Files that the SNP desperately don’t want you to see".

Mr Salmond, who died in 2024, was ultimately cleared of 13 counts of sexual assault following a trial at the High Court.

He and his supporters have long claimed there was a conspiracy against him inside the Scottish Government.

A parliamentary inquiry into the handling of the allegations found that Sturgeon had misled Holyrood, but the inquiry headed by James Hamilton cleared her of any breach of the ministerial code.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos