Exclusive

Midwives warn Scotland at ‘tipping point’ for safe maternity care

Midwives say safe maternity care in Scotland is now at a ‘tipping point’
Midwives say safe maternity care in Scotland is now at a ‘tipping point’
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The Royal College of Midwives has told The Herald that providing safe maternity care is at a ‘tipping point’ as they demand the Scottish Government take urgent action.

Jaki Lambert, the RCM director of Scotland, also said staffing shortages mean women and babies cannot always receive all the care midwives would like to give.

Her comments come as RCM in Scotland launched its manifesto ‘Safe Staffing = Safe Care’, calling for seven key priorities to secure safe maternity care.

The manifesto falls at a time when various inspectorate reports have highlighted safety concerns across maternity units in Scotland and the Scottish Government has promised a national review into maternity care.


READ MORE:


During the launch in Edinburgh today, Ms Lambert told The Herald: “We are not just launching our manifesto, we are launching our campaign which is about safe staffing equals safe care.

“We have been calling over and over again that we do not have the right numbers of staff, we don’t have the right skill mix and resources around maternity and basically enough is enough.

“We need to have the right number of midwives in Scotland so that families get all the care they want and midwives thrive and continue to work in the service.”

Asked if midwives are currently able to provide safe maternity care, Ms Lambert said: “I think we are at a tipping point.

“I think that our amazing care in Scotland is based on the dedication of amazing midwives and the wider workforce in Scotland but if we look over the past ten years; more and more policy coming out saying this is what maternity services will provide, more and more complexity or aspirations in what families want and we haven’t got more staff to provide it.

"There’s no accommodation or flex left in the system.”

The launch comes as data reveals that in the past decade, the midwifery workforce in Scotland has increased by just 7.9% – nearly half the rate of nursing (13.4%) and less than a quarter the rate of doctors (28.4%).

Current workforce shortages are forcing health boards to stand down vital services including home birth and midwifery-led care – limiting women’s choices.

Meanwhile, newly qualified midwives struggle to find posts while experienced staff are being pulled from community services to cover acute settings.

Discussing the workforce figures, Ms Lambert said: “What that amounts to, in the reduced working week, is about a hundred midwives.

“In that time you’ve seen a 25% increase in caesarian sections, you’ve seen all the policy aspirations.

“By comparison, nursing has gone up by 5,000 nurses, doctors have gone up by 23%. We are not asking for way over and above. We are asking for a fair share.”

The RCM Scotland manifesto calls for a national midwifery workforce plan in place by the end of 2026 and full implementation by 2031. It also calls for there to be minimum safe staffing ratios established for all care settings, a graduate guarantee of a post for every newly qualified midwife in Scotland as well as an 'earn-as-you-learn' route for maternity care assistants to become midwives.

Other calls in the manifesto include for there to be a Director of Midwifery in every health and special board and a consultant midwife in every maternity unit by the end of Parliament in May 2026.

Ms Lambert added: "Midwives hold the future of a healthy Scotland in their hands. They play a key role in boosting women and communities' health and giving each baby the best start in life. But without safe staffing, our midwives are being stretched beyond breaking point and we’re denying women and babies the comprehensive care they desperately need and deserve.

"We already know what the issues are: not enough staff, not enough resources and not enough of a skill mix. The time for talking is over. This manifesto calls for a funded workforce plan, safe staffing ratios and genuine investment in maternity services.

“Women deserve choice, babies deserve safety and midwives deserve the resources to provide the care they're trained to give."

The RCM says it stands ready to work constructively with the Scottish Government and health boards.

Their calls come as earlier today Crosshouse maternity unit, previously linked to baby deaths, was ordered to improve patient safety.

A number of findings from a Healthcare Improvement Scotland report on the unit published today included that staff were reluctant to report patient safety events and that reviews into incidents took too long to the detriment of families.

The inspection of the maternity unit marks the fifth of its kind, with thirteen more to follow. All 18 are expected to be completed by March next year.

The findings come amid a broader national review of maternity care after concerns were raised across several Scottish units.

Neil Gray said the latest findings showed the inspection regime was working, however, he also confirmed that the national review of maternity care, promised by the government in November last year, had yet to begin.

Responding to the RCM manifesto on staffing pressures, Mr Gray said: “Our NHS staff do incredible work in very challenging circumstances, and their wellbeing is a priority. We invest over £2.5 million each year in staff wellbeing, including mental health support, psychological therapies and a compassionate listening service through NHS 24.

“We have increased midwifery staff numbers by 11% over the past decade and are driving improvement through inspections of every maternity unit and delivery of the Nursing and Midwifery Taskforce actions, which the Royal College of Midwives (RCM) helped to shape and continue to support as an active member of the Taskforce.

“A new Scottish Maternity and Neonatal Taskforce will strengthen national oversight, ensuring staff and women’s voices directly shape improvements. Jaki Lambert, RCM Director for Scotland, is also a member of this Taskforce.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos