Unspun 🗳️

What does Mandelson scandal mean for Scottish politics?

What will be the impact of Mandelson scandal on Scottish politics and Scottish Labour? <i>(Image: Graphic: Derek McArthur)</i>
What will be the impact of Mandelson scandal on Scottish politics and Scottish Labour? (Image: Graphic: Derek McArthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter.


With Keir Starmer on the brink as Prime Minister what impact will the crisis at Number Ten have on Scottish politics and on Scottish Labour?

For a start it now seems inevitable that Starmer's fight for survival amid the Peter Mandelson scandal has completely ruined the chances of Anas Sarwar becoming the next First Minister.

Sarwar's prospect of taking that role were already diminished since Labour won the general election in July 2024.

The new UK government made a series of decisions unpopular with voters - the first scrapping winter fuel payments to pensioners (a decision later partially reversed following a public outcry) - which weakened Scottish Labour's chances of success at the Holyrood elections this Spring.


Read More from Unspun:


But despite such moves by the Starmer government, Scottish Labour still had a chance of triumph this May.

Just last month pollster Mark Diffley told Unspun that Sarwar's attacks on the Scottish Government over "secret Scotland", referencing controversies over the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital deaths and the 'Salmond files' were effective and were cutting through with voters.

A few weeks on, it now seems clear that last week's revelations over Mandelson's connections to the late billionaire US paedophile and financier Jeffrey Epstein have sealed a miserable election fate for Scottish Labour.

Interviewed on Friday, top pollster Professor Sir John Curtice, of Strathclyde University in Glasgow, gave a dire assessment of the likelihood of Mr Sarwar ousting the SNP leader John Swinney from Bute House.

He told The National that the possibility of the Scottish Labour leader becoming the head of a new Scottish Government in three months was "virtually zero".

Polls suggest the parties benefitting from the Labour crisis are the SNP, which successive polls suggest will win the election, and Reform UK, which is gaining momentum, putting it in a strong position to become the second party in Holyrood with its leader Malcolm Offord quite likely now to become opposition leader.

With the resignation on Sunday of Starmer's chief of staff Morgan McSweeney, a Mandelson ally who had advised the PM to appoint Mandelson as UK ambassador to the United States, it is now expected that Starmer may well step down before too long as Prime Minister.

It now just seems a matter of when.

However, it would be wrong to think a change of Prime Minister before May will lead to an uptick in Scottish Labour's chances as Anas Sarwar seems to hope for following his call on Monday afternoon for the PM to go.

Firstly, neither of the possible candidates currently being discussed to succeed Starmer are scandal free.

Angela Rayner had to resign as deputy prime minister just last September following a breach of the ministerial code regarding her tax affairs, specifically underpaid stamp duty on a £800,000 Hove flat, while health secretary Wes Streeting has close connections with Mandelson - a relationship he is now furiously trying to distance himself from.

And secondly, the Mandelson scandal itself.

The emails released by the US government last week which appeared to show Mandelson, while a member of Gordon Brown's government, passing on sensitive government financial information to Epstein within minutes of receiving it were devastating.


Get Scotland's top politics newsletter straight to your inbox.


A day after they came to light the Metropolitan Police announced a criminal investigation into alleged misconduct in public office with officers searching Mandelson's properties in London and Wiltshire.

Mandelson, a leading architect of New Labour, who was sacked last September as US ambassador over his friendship with Epstein, has not commented publicly on the allegations, but it is understood his position is that he has not acted in any way criminally and that he was not motivated by financial gain.

Meanwhile, UK government figures are preparing to hand over electronic communications with Mandelson ahead of the release of government documents detailing his vetting process for his appointment as US ambassador.

It seems likely that more damaging messages will come out as the Mandelson documents are released - potentially prompting further resignations of senior Labour figures.

Both the police investigation and political scandal are really just starting.

It has all the hallmarks of a saga that will drag on for many months and indeed possibly years.

The way events are currently developing, never mind May 2026, Scottish Labour could be struggling to get on the front foot even by 2030.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos