A new poll suggests a majority of Scottish voters support Anas Sarwar’s decision to publicly call for UK Labour leader and Prime Minister Keir Starmer to step down.
The Norstat survey for The Sunday Times found around 52 per cent of respondents said Sarwar was right to urge Starmer’s resignation. Just over a quarter disagreed.
However, backing for Scottish Labour at the ballot box remains weak, with only a small share of voters indicating the intervention would make them more likely to support the party in the Holyrood election.
READ MORE:
- Sarwar: Starmer resignation call ‘not a coup attempt’
- Starmer–Sarwar row is overshadowing violence against women
Earlier today, the Scottish Labour leader insisted his call for Sir Keir to resign was “not a coup attempt”, declaring he acted alone and in Scotland’s interests ahead of the Holyrood elections in May.
“I didn’t tell anybody what I was thinking,” he said. “It was important that I made the decision that I wanted to make, that it was my own decision."
Rejecting suggestions of an organised move against the UK leader, Sarwar said: "I was not part of any organisation, not part of any coup attempt."
Instead, he framed his comments as a statement on 'prioritising Scotland' ahead of the Holyrood election on 7 May, where he is seeking to unseat First Minister John Swinney.
His intervention comes amid mounting frustration within sections of Scottish Labour over what they see as the UK leadership’s failure to address issues important to voters north of the border.
Despite Sarwar’s call, senior UK Labour figures including Deputy Prime Minister David Lammy and Chancellor Rachel Reeves have publicly backed Starmer, stressing party unity and urging focus on public services and economic challenges.
The survey of 1,001 Scottish residents, conducted between Tuesday and Friday — the day after Sarwar publicly called on the Prime Minister to resign — found that 52 per cent believed he had made the right decision, compared with 26 per cent who took the opposite view.
Although some in Westminster saw Sarwar’s intervention as having backfired, after figures including Health Secretary Wes Streeting and Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner reiterated their loyalty to Starmer, the poll suggests the move has landed well with the Scottish public.
There is, however, little evidence that it will alter Scottish Labour’s electoral trajectory or significantly boost Sarwar’s attempt to oust the Scottish National Party from office at Holyrood after almost two decades of nationalist rule.
After the 2024 general election, when Scottish Labour contributed to Labour’s landslide victory over the SNP in Scotland, it appeared Sarwar might be on course to secure the keys to Bute House. But the declining popularity of the UK Labour government has seen Scottish Labour’s ratings slump, leaving the party facing a steep challenge less than 12 weeks from polling day.
As matters stand, 17 per cent of Scottish voters intend to back Labour on both the constituency and regional ballots — placing the party behind the SNP and narrowly trailing Reform UK. Although Scots support Sarwar’s call for Starmer to resign by a margin of roughly two to one, nearly six in ten say it makes no difference to their likelihood of voting Labour. Only 15 per cent say it makes them more likely to back the party.
According to seat projections by polling expert John Curtice, the SNP is on course to win around 60 of Holyrood’s 129 seats - five short of an overall majority - with 35 per cent support in the constituency vote and 30 per cent on the regional list. Reform UK is projected to secure 22 seats on 19 per cent support in both ballots, while Labour could return just 16 MSPs, a record low, if the poll were replicated on election day.
The Scottish Conservatives are forecast to win 13 seats, with the Liberal Democrats on eight and the Scottish Greens on ten.
Starmer’s personal standing north of the border remains deeply negative. Just 15 per cent of Scots believe he is doing a good job as Prime Minister, while 62 per cent take the opposite view, leaving him with a net approval rating of minus 47, a record low.
Among those who voted Labour in 2024, his net rating stands at minus 24.
Sarwar’s own ratings have also deteriorated. His net approval among all Scots is now minus 25, down four points on last month. For the first time, slightly more 2024 Labour voters say he is doing a bad job (33 per cent) than a good one (30 per cent).
Professor Curtice suggested the intervention may even have worsened Sarwar’s position.
“At 17 per cent, Labour’s support on both ballots is unchanged,” he said. “Sarwar’s attempt to escape seemingly inevitable defeat in May has, it seems, left him, if anything, in an even weaker position.”
Allies of the Scottish Labour leader struck a more optimistic tone. Jackie Baillie, Sarwar’s deputy, said the poll demonstrated he had been “right to be honest with Scots”.
“The choice at the next election is who we want as the next First Minister: a tired John Swinney, who represents the past, or Anas Sarwar, who represents the future of Scotland,” she said.
Share