This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter.
Freedom of information (FOI) laws were introduced to increase public service transparency, but it has become an increasingly frustrating process.
On Tuesday, MSPs will vote on proposals at stage one to overhaul the FOI process. As a journalist who has been locked in numerous FOI battles, it is long overdue.
Labour MSP Katy Clark’s proposals – the Freedom of Information Reform (Scotland) Bill – seek to update the existing Act, introduced in 2002.
The proposals include extending FOI obligations to private and third-sector bodies delivering public services.
It would also strengthen the enforcement powers of the Scottish Information Commissioner and would limit the First Minister’s ability to override decisions ordering the release of information.
If passed, it would be a criminal offence for politicians and officials to deliberately and recklessly erase WhatsApp messages and other communications relating to government business.
The most high profile case of contention lies with the so-called Salmond files.
Read more from Unspun:
- Why did Scottish Labour only suspend Pam Duncan-Glancy now?
- Starmer–Sarwar row is overshadowing violence against women
- Scandal that will last years: What Mandelson saga means for Scotland
- Glasgow's CCA: From a slow-motion car crash to mission impossible
- Can Starmer survive? Plausible deniability only works if it's plausible
- What’s going on with Scotland's maternity inspection reports so far?
First Minister John Swinney denied there was a culture of secrecy after the Scottish Information Commissioner took the unprecedented step of instructing solicitors to begin legal proceedings against the government.
It centres around the Scottish Government’s failure to release documents relating to the probe by James Hamilton KC into potential breaches of the ministerial code by former first minister Nicola Sturgeon during the investigation into Alex Salmond.
It is the first time this action has ever been taken and has come as scrutiny around freedom of information legislation grows.
In the last six to eight months alone, I have had to challenge public bodies – namely the Scottish Government and NHS Fife – to obtain information.
Some of the appeal processes are still ongoing.
With the Sandie Peggie employment tribunal, it took The Herald more than six months to uncover the full costs in one of the most high-profile legal cases of 2025.
FOI requests are supposed to be responded to within 20 days, but increasingly, deadlines are missed or information is refused or significantly redacted.
In trying to uncover the legal fees paid to NHS Fife’s barrister – London-based Jane Russell KC – NHS Fife and the NHS’ National Services Scotland (NSS) repeatedly said the information was exempt because its “commercial interests” could be jeopardised.
Get Scotland's top politics newsletter straight to your inbox.
It was only in December, after David Hamilton, the Scottish Information Commissioner, intervened, that a full breakdown of costs could be revealed.
Last month, following an FOI request, the Scottish Government provided me with correspondence between NHS Fife and Health Secretary Neil Gray, following the employment tribunal judgment.
In the emails, Mr Gray had asked for its response to the findings that NHS Fife had harassed Ms Peggie. But crucially, the improvement plan provided by the health board was almost entirely redacted by government officials because its publication could lead to “misinterpretation”.
It is an increasingly frustrating process that inevitably results in more public money being spent with the drawn out appeals process and interventions from the Commissioner.
Appealing directly to the public body is the first step but rarely ever results in the information being released, meaning a lengthy review request to the Information Commissioner is necessary, where a decision can take months.
Mr Hamilton issued a level four intervention into NHS Fife’s handling of FOI requests following what he described as “serious and systemic” breaches.
The Scottish Information Commissioner takes these steps as a last resort. His actions tell us that current FOI laws are not working as they should.
Reform is in the interest of the public and the freedom of reporting by journalists. Is it in the interest of the Scottish Parliament? Whether this Bill passes its first stage will answer that.
Share