Could Meindl boots solve the mystery of Iona tragedy?

Iona mystery has not been solved five months on <i>(Image: Getty Images)</i>
Iona mystery has not been solved five months on (Image: Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Late summer was sliding into autumn, and the Hebridean days were shortening when out on water off Iona, a shape emerged on the surface of the sea.

For the people on board a passing vessel who spotted the pale form, jostled by the shifting swell, there may have been a rush of excitement.

Was this a dolphin or a seal? Maybe even the smooth hump of a whale emerging and disappearing with the ebb and flow?

Drawing closer, curiosity must at some point have given way to shock…

It was late September when the lifeboat crew in Oban responded to the distressing call that sent them out to retrieve the woman’s lifeless body. floating in the water around five miles west of the beautiful and deeply religious island of Iona.

Once on land, it would emerge that she had been in the water for four, perhaps even six weeks.  

Surely someone, somewhere would be missing her.

Yet almost precisely five months to the day since she was found, just who she was, what happened to her and why came to be floating in the cold open water five miles beyond Iona’s western beaches, remains as big a mystery as on the day she was found.

And still investigators have little to share of who she might be beyond a vague description:  she was tall, around 6ft in height, aged somewhere between 45-60, medium build.

No tattoos, no obvious scarring.   

It’s pitifully little to create an image from: the water and passing of time mean the colour of her eyes and the shade of her hair have long since gone.

What’s left is precious DNA, her black hiking style trousers – no labels for clues – and her distinctive size 8.5 German-made Meindl brand walking boots.


Read more:


Shown now for the first time, it’s hoped the unusual dark brown suede boots with a dark red flash, black and mesh trims, might hold the key.

The distinctive size 8.5 Meindl brand walking boots worn by the woman found in water off Iona (Image: Police Scotland)

Not commonly available in UK shops and with a typical price tag of around £200, will they be distinctive enough to jog someone’s memories and help fill the gaps?

For Inspector Roddy MacNeill of Police Scotland, Iona’s lost lady of the sea has so far posed a perplexing challenge that has taken the search across the UK and into Europe, covering Iceland, Greenland, the Faroe Islands and Norway, and crossed the Atlantic to Canada.

“It’s not that common for us not to be able to identify someone,” he concedes.

“We are obviously very keen to identify her and return her to whatever family she has.”

But he, adds: “We are no closer to identifying her.”

In a modern digital age of connectivity and traceability, the lack of a breakthrough is striking and, for those involved in the search for clues, frustrating.

However, it’s not for the want of trying.

A search of current missing person cases in Scotland and then across the wider UK failed to find any match.

The investigation widened the net, bringing in colleagues from the National Crime Agency to assist with broader enquiries. Still nothing.

Her DNA profile was taken and run through the UK database with no match. Likewise, when it was checked against European databases.

From the west coast of Iona, officers looked across the Atlantic.

“We have sent her DNA profile to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, because there’s nothing between Canada and where she was recovered,” Insp MacNeill says.

“It is feasible she could have moved a distance.”

With that in mind, an oceanographer was consulted and tidal patterns and possible points of entry into the water studied.

“We have exhausted that line of enquiry,” he adds.

Police hoping to identify a woman's body found off Iona have widened their search to Canada and Norway

One possibility is that having entered the water, her lifeless remains were caught by a vessel and dragged for miles.

“We can’t rule anything out,” he adds.

“From the west coast of Iona, there’s Canada, we’re looking at Greenland, the Faroe Islands, Iceland, Norway. They are all open to the sea.

“It’s a busy sea route. There’s a possibility she has been moved by a vessel at some point.

“We’re open to the fact that maybe she has travelled a distance, be that by tidal or something has caused her to move.”

A post mortem showed no reason to treat her death as suspicious, with no obvious trauma or unexplained injuries.

On Iona, an island steeped in Christianity and faith, where the abbey and religious retreats are a magnet for tourists and pilgrims seeking peace and contemplation, police guest details and found no missing visitor reports.

For islanders, the mystery has been a talking point.

“It has affected folk,” says one woman at the island’s Aosdana Gallery, which sells silver jewellery inspired by Iona’s land, the sea and the sky.

“From what we know, it was found in the water by a fishing boat, a fair bit off Iona.

“But it wasn’t someone who fell in the water here, or something that happened to someone on the island.”

At Staffa Tours, thoughts were with the mystery woman. “There’s many different reasons for someone ending up in the water,” said one worker.

“It is strange in this day and age when you think how much is digital and how DNA should make it easy to identify people, yet they don’t know who she was.

“She could be a mother, she’s someone’s daughter. It’s sad.”

Digital ferry tickets mean passengers are scanned on and off again, ruling out the idea she may have been lost overboard.

“If someone fell from a ferry, we would expect that to be reported at the time,” says MacNeill. “If someone doesn’t reach their destination or fails to return home, generally they would be reported missing.

“We’ve had nothing.”


Read more:


A renewed appeal for help last month drew a blank too.

What’s left is the most haunting detail of all. That no one - not in Scotland, not elsewhere in the UK and so far, further afield - has stepped forward to say a woman matching her description has failed to come home.

“There are people who maybe don’t have a lot of contact with a lot of people,” adds Insp MacNeill.

“But I would like to think that generally, if someone failed to return home, they would be reported missing.”

What remains is the DNA trail, and her boots.

Sold across Europe, officers traced two UK retailers in the hope records would reveal some clues as to who may have purchased that particular size and style.

Again, it was a dead end: one had gone out of business, the other only recently began keeping digitised records and couldn’t help.

Now investigators are considering a more complex route: familial DNA searching. Not a commercial ancestry test, Insp. MacNeill is clear, but a trawl of existing law enforcement databases to look for close biological matches in the hope it might lead to a parent, sibling or even a child whose DNA is already held.

The process is unlikely to throw up immediate answers, he adds.

Meanwhile, the woman’s DNA profile will remain on their files.

“It will take some time to be confident that no one is ever going to come forward for this lady,” he adds.

“We would keep her for a length of time to give it a real opportunity to identify her and get her home for a proper burial.”

Meantime, she remains in limbo.

“Somebody must know or have known her,” says MacNeill. “We would like to find out where the lady came from and get her returned home. There’s no doubt about that.

“It’s five months now and that’s quite unusual, but we will keep going.”

If you have any information which could assist, contact Police Scotland on 101 quoting incident number 1564 of 23 September, 2025.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos