With work on a full review of university funding already underway, a Scottish Government minister has said that colleges might have a similar project commence before the new Parliament comes into session later this year.
Speaking at an election hustings at Edinburgh College on Monday, SNP Higher and Further Education Minister Ben Macpherson was pressed on his party’s support for colleges and whether it would commit to a holistic review of the sector’s funding model, such as was recently launched for universities.
In a surprise response, Mr Macpherson indicated that he was “very determined” to work with Colleges Scotland to set a college review “in motion formally before the new parliament rises”, so that any new government can work with its findings.
This comes after years of reduced funding or flat-cash settlements that have resulted in a 20% real-terms cut over five years. The most recent Scottish budget, however, included a 10% uplift for colleges.
Sector leaders have shown appreciation for the uplift and expressed the hope that it will signal the start of a sea change in how the government approaches college funding and how the public perceives the importance of colleges.
During Monday’s hustings, each party’s education spokesperson was given an opportunity to respond to questions about how they view the college system, how they will prioritise it, and what the most important next steps are to capitalise on what some college insiders have called an “encouraging rise” in public support for colleges.
Over the course of the discussion, each of the six party representatives – Mr Macpherson, Scottish Conservative MSP Miles Briggs, Scottish Labour MSP Paul O’Kane, Scottish Green MSP Ross Greer, Scottish Liberal Democrat MSP Willie Rennie, and Reform UK MSP Graham Simpson – agreed that the current course of action will not sustain Scotland’s colleges, although each focused on different tangible steps to take towards reform.
Calls for changes to college credit and cash schemes
There was a brief discussion of the need for a sustained multi-year funding settlement, something that college advocates have argued for years would help institutions plan for their futures.
The day's moderator, political podcaster and columnist Andy Maciver, pointed to the most recent funding uplift for colleges but suggested that many in the sector see it as a “sticking plaster” given the downward trajectory in recent years.
Mr Simpson pointed out that many colleges are still considering cuts despite the new settlement, and that he would feel more positive about a commitment to higher levels of funding “over a number of years”.
He also mentioned concerns raised in evidence to the Public Audit Committee that parts of the college estate are “crumbling”.
Mr O’Kane echoed a similar concern, warning there is a “massive issue” regarding capital in the college sector.
“In talking to college principals, I recognise the real concern that if there were to be a catastrophic failure in terms of the actual buildings that our colleges are in, that could have a huge impact on resources.”
Other speakers zeroed in on the need to reform some of the metaphorical nuts and bolts of the college sector, particularly the credit system, which Mr Briggs and Mr Rennie both singled out for urgent attention.
Mr Briggs suggested that while he sees employers “crying out” for skilled workers in construction, care, renewables, and other key industries, colleges are not always able to adapt quickly enough to meet these needs under the current model.
“Until we do something about the credit system to actually allow the sector to bring more people in, train them up and get them out to businesses, we’re not going to grow our economy.”
This followed a statement from Ayrshire College Principal and CEO Angela Cox, who helped introduce the panel and pointed out that the sector as a whole is forced to turn away “thousands” of students each year.
Mr Rennie suggested that the credit system has become too “siloed”, saying that it “chains” colleges to certain approaches when they should be able to be more flexible in offering credits and places across apprenticeships, qualifications and shorter courses in response to local and national economic demands.
Read more:
- Can Scotland revive its stalled economy? Muscatelli says colleges can lead recovery
- Colleges are crying wolf, and the wolf is very real
- Colleges risk insolvency as universities are forced to restructure
- Scottish college targeting alternative types of income
- Highland college bucks national decline with record growth - but warns of strain
There were also calls for changes to colleges’ borrowing powers and their inability to maintain a surplus, both of which are severely restricted by colleges’ public sector classification. After a question from City of Glasgow College Principal and CEO Dr Paul Little, most panel members said colleges should be allowed to borrow, as many of their counterparts across the UK do.
Mr Briggs said that he did not see any other realistic route to the capital funding that the college sector needs to shore up its campuses.
Calls for a clearer national strategy to work towards
Mr Greer was repeatedly critical of the Scottish Government for what he saw as a failure to provide a clear set of targets and direction of travel for the economy.
“We won’t see the kind of success we want for the sector unless we are absolutely clear about what kind of economy and what kind of society we’re trying to build. We cannot do everything, and every college cannot be expected to do everything.”
Colleges, he argued, still lack a clear statement of what ministers expect them to deliver by region and sector.
Using examples from Ayrshire, he said institutions have already shown how they can support the net‑zero transition by working with employers on heat‑pump installation, cable manufacturing and health workforce pipelines, but that this has often happened despite limited national direction.
Speakers discussed their priorities for Scotland's colleges and what needs to change to secure a more sustainable future. (Image: Stewart Attwood Photography 2026)
In a manifesto launched to coincide with the hustings, Colleges Scotland highlighted two key roles colleges play in society: skills engines and community anchors.
Multiple speakers highlighted the potential value of a more regional approach and closer collaboration between schools, colleges, and local authorities, which could support colleges in both roles.
Mr Greer suggested that college boards should feature a local councillor to strengthen ties to the local community, while Mr Briggs said that school-college partnerships are “the best thing going on in Scotland at the minute” and called for them to be “turbocharged”.
Mr Rennie positioned colleges as key resources for fighting poverty and unemployment, while Mr Simpson called colleges “absolutely vital to the future of Scotland and the future economy”.
Consensus, but what next?
The hour-long panel discussion was remarkably free of barbs or political point-scoring. This was something Mr MacIver remarked upon as host, and it was also picked up by Edinburgh College Principal and CEO Audrey Cumberford MBE, who offered closing remarks.
In setting the conversation in the context of the sector’s next steps, however, Ms Cumberford warned against seeing consensus as a point of hope.
Edinburgh College Principal and CEO Audrey Cumberford MBE FRSE said that consneus on the debate stage is not enough to secure the future of Scotland's colleges. (Image: Contributed)
Speakers agreed that the “status quo is not an option” and that there is a real opportunity in the next parliament to do things differently.
“I’ve been around a long time now in the college sector, and I can honestly say hand-on-heart I have not met a politician in all of that time that has said anything other than, ‘I value colleges.’
“But that is part of the problem, which is that there is a big difference between rhetoric and narrative, and actually what a government can do in creating the right environment, policy, and funding, to lead and to drive the transformation reform that's needed within the sector.
“One of the risks is that we see the next year as a sticking plaster, everybody breathes a sigh of relief, and then, from a principal’s point of view, in twelve months’ time we are back to where we started and dealing with the same challenges.”
One concrete step that could begin to break the cycle Ms Cumberford warned about would be for the government and sector leaders to take serious steps towards reviewing the funding model.
In response to Mr Macpherson’s comments about a review being imminent, a Scottish Government spokesperson did not directly confirm that there would be a review of college funding.
The spokesperson said:
“The Scottish Government deeply values the important contribution colleges make across the country. That is why the proposed 2026-2027 budget delivers an increase of £70 million – a 10% uplift on last year’s budget – taking our total investment in core college funding to £764 million.
“This uplift is designed to support sustainability and reform, and we are working closely with the sector to scope, develop and then deliver changes needed to meet the needs of both students and the economy, and to respond to challenges and opportunities in the years ahead.”
Share