Updated

Mega-poll predicts SNP Holyrood majority in May

SNP MSP John Swinney <i>(Image: Jeff Mitchell)</i>
SNP MSP John Swinney (Image: Jeff Mitchell)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The SNP is on course for a Holyrood majority, according to a new “mega-poll”.

The MRP survey predicts that John Swinney’s party is poised to win 67 seats in May’s election.

Under a strategy agreed by SNP members last year, this would then be taken by the Scottish Government as a mandate to start negotiations for a second vote on independence.

The SNP last had an outright majority in 2011, which led to the 2014 independence referendum So far, polls have suggested the party was set to fall short of a Holyrood majority.

The seat-by-seat analysis, conducted by Stonehaven, a global strategy and research firm, and published in the Times, predicts that tactical voting could help get the party over the 65-seat threshold.

Its model suggests voters, including a sizeable number of those sympathetic to Labour, will rally round the SNP to block Reform UK.

Stonehaven’s model predicts Mr Swinney’s party will win 67 of Holyrood’s 73 constituency seats. 

However, Reform would return 25 list seats, while Scottish Labour would elect only 15 MSPs, its worst result in the history of devolution.

The Scottish Lib Dems would take eight seats, while the Scottish Tories and Greens would be tied on seven each.

“Tactical voting is likely to play a significant role this May, with a handful of closely fought constituency contests set to decide whether or not the SNP secures an overall majority for the first time since 2011,” Luke Betham, head of data science at Stonehaven, said.

“At the same time, our modelling points to Reform becoming the main opposition force in Holyrood, ahead of the Conservatives and Labour. That kind of generational realignment would cause an almighty headache for both Sir Keir Starmer and Kemi Badenoch.

“John Swinney has already said winning an outright majority would be a mandate for a second independence referendum, based on the precedent set in 2011. Labour has indicated it would reject calls for a rerun of 2014, which would likely lead to a souring of relations between Edinburgh and Westminster.”

The poll suggests, however, that the SNP’s referendum mandate could be at risk if Reform continues to gain momentum. The model puts Nigel Farage’s party within five points of the SNP in three races — Banffshire & Buchan Coast, Dumfriesshire, and Galloway & West Dumfries.

Labour also still has hope of retaining Edinburgh Southern, where the model suggests it is just behind the SNP.

Reform would pick up four list MSPs in the Highlands & Islands and South Scotland, and at least three everywhere else, with the exception of Edinburgh & Lothians East, where it would win two.

Anand Menon, a director at Stonehaven and of UK in a Changing Europe, said the overall surge in support for Reform in Scotland, which would propel it to runner-up in 54 of 73 constituency seats, would “send a shiver up the spine of even the most phlegmatic Labour MP”.

He added: “It is hard to see how this can have any other impact than to further erode support for Sir Keir Starmer. Not least because Anas Sarwar is doubtless going to be ruthless in blaming the national leadership for the Scottish Labour Party’s poor showing.”

Scottish Lib Dem Election campaign chair Wendy Chamberlain said the poll did not reflect what the party were finding on the ground.

She said: "To be honest, this doesn't bear much resemblance to our canvass data, which shows that in constituencies like Skye, Lochaber & Badenoch, Inverness & Nairn and Argyll & Bute, it is neck and neck between us and the SNP.

"If voters back Scottish Liberal Democrats in key constituencies, we can deprive the SNP of a majority, while every vote for us on the second peach regional ballot will deliver more MSPs focused on delivering change with fairness at its heart."

Malcolm Offord, Leader of Reform UK Scotland, said a majority of the SNP would be "disastrous for Scotland".

"I have been clear, this is a straightforward race to win a majority for Scotland.

“I have pledged to make this country prosperous and reignite ambition. The race has only just begun.

“I believe in the Scottish people, and this poll shows that they believe in us.

“This poll demonstrates that if people want to vote for change, then they must vote for Reform. A vote for Labour or the Conservatives will be a wasted vote in May.”

The SNP's depute leader Keith Brown said momentum was "firmly with the SNP".

“John Swinney’s strong leadership is on Scotland’s side, focussed on Scotland’s priorities - that’s a world away from the chaos and scandal of Westminster.

“While Westminster parties squabble amongst themselves, John Swinney is laser focussed on improving our NHS and offering the best cost of living support package available on these islands.

“The Westminster establishment is in chaos and broken, Brexit Britain is in terminal decline - in May, a fresh start with independence is now there to be won.”


Last year, Rachel Reeves told BBC Radio Scotland: “There will not be another referendum.”

She added: “When there was a referendum just a few years ago, they said this was a once-in-a-generation referendum. People gave their verdict then; we do not need another one.”

Asked how long she believed a generation was, Ms Reeves said it was “certainly not 12 years”.

In 2022, Nicola Sturgeon asked the Supreme Court to rule on whether the Scottish Parliament could legislate for a consultative referendum without Westminster’s permission. The court unanimously concluded that it could not, because the Union is a reserved matter.

Any lawful referendum requires Westminster’s consent, whatever the result of next May’s election.

In her memoir, Frankly, Ms Sturgeon admitted that the Scottish Government’s legal reference was “in all likelihood impossible”.



Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos