Scotland’s information watchdog has confirmed his officials are now scrutinising thousands of pages of documents released by the Scottish Government to determine whether ministers have complied with a ruling on the so-called Salmond Files.
David Hamilton, the Scottish Information Commissioner, said his investigators were assessing the material after the Government produced what he described as a large, confusing tranche of records linked to the ministerial code investigation into former first minister Nicola Sturgeon.
It comes after a long-running battle over access to internal communications about the probe conducted by James Hamilton, the Government’s independent adviser on the ministerial code.
Read more
-
James Hamilton was worried his report into Nicola Sturgeon risked being ‘dishonest’
-
Sturgeon said Salmond warned of 'floodgates' opening over misconduct claims
-
What are the Salmond files and what is in the documents released on Tuesday?
-
Scottish Government finally publishes ‘Salmond Files’ after FOI ruling
More than 4,700 pages were published by the Scottish Government on Tuesday.
However, Mr Hamilton warned there is “a long way to go yet” before it is clear whether the Government has fully met its legal obligations.
He told BBC Radio Scotland his office is actively checking compliance. because of concerns about how the documents were supplied.
“What my investigators are now doing is assessing that to see whether, in fact, there has been compliance because we’ve had 4,700 pages, frankly, dumped in an unstructured way, which is causing everyone lots of confusion, trying to work out what on earth has been released,” he said.
The original freedom of information request dates back around five years and sought material relating to the investigation by James Hamilton into Ms Sturgeon’s conduct during the fallout from complaints against her predecessor, Alex Salmond.
The Scottish Government initially argued it did not hold the information requested, a position that was later challenged in the Court of Session.
The Commissioner said the court “took 21 seconds” to tell the Scottish Government it did.
There then followed a battle over some of the exemptions in the paperwork.
There are currently four cases still to be heard at the Court of Session.
The Commissioner was asked if he would still be pushing ahead with the legal action after Tuesday’s data dump.
He told the BBC: “There’s a second request that came in looking at communications surrounding the inquiry, which the government did not contest. And I said that they must give a response to the applicant by January 15, which of course was over five weeks ago.
“They missed that deadline, missed the second extension I gave them to get things through.
“And on that basis, reported them for contempt of court because they’re breaking the law. And to be honest, there’s been a bizarre kind of toing and froing in terms of how this plays out in public. But at the moment, it is still a live case at the Court of Session.
“We’ll take that through.”
The newly released material — comprising emails, legal notes, draft correspondence and administrative records — contains extensive redactions. Applicants are entitled to challenge any of those redactions, triggering further review by the commissioner.
Asked whether Scotland has a systemic secrecy problem, Mr Hamilton was broadly positive about public sector transparency overall but said difficulties tend to arise when requests concern sensitive or politically contentious matters.
“Across Scotland, we’ve got good performing system, a lot of people dedicated to actually releasing information,” he said.
“The problem is when it becomes difficult, awkward, embarrassing, contentious. That’s where we start seeing these things coming to the top.”
He also suggested the handling of requests connected to the Hamilton investigation had been particularly problematic.
“However, there are cases where it all goes wrong and that’s exactly what’s happened,” he said.
He added that disputes over this specific case risk overshadowing the work of civil servants who usually handle information requests professionally.
“Anything to do with Hamilton Inquiry has been an exemption and it’s a shame because it drags down the good efforts and the good work of the rest of the civil servants who are doing their job really well and professionally.”
The newly released documents show the independent adviser feared his report would be “dishonest” if he was forced to omit key material because of legal restrictions.
Draft correspondence from James Hamilton, appointed to examine whether the former first minister breached the ministerial code over her handling of complaints about Alex Salmond, reveals he at one stage halted progress on his findings amid disputes over anonymity and identification.
In a March 17 letter to then deputy first minister John Swinney, written as the inquiry neared completion, Mr Hamilton said the report had “been largely drafted for the past several weeks” but could not be finalised because attempts to anonymise a central section had failed. He wrote that removing the passages would prevent the report telling “the full truth”, adding: “It would be a dishonest report and I am not prepared to put my name to such a document.”
He later warned a version excluding the material could be “misleading” and said his preferred option was to submit a full report to ministers even if parts could not be made public. When the final report was published on March 22, he noted it was “impossible to give an accurate description of some of the relevant events… while at the same time complying with the court orders”.
The redactions stemmed from legal constraints linked to Mr Salmond’s criminal trial and his successful judicial review, as well as wider concerns around privacy, data protection and defamation.
Read more
-
Can Alba survive electoral failure, financial turmoil and the loss of Alex Salmond?
-
Cherry seeks answers on Murrell memo as she calls for Lord Advocate role reform
-
SNP presiding over ‘secret Scotland’ in freedom of information laws, says Katy Clark
The papers also show senior official James Hynd helped co-ordinate evidence gathering and draft letters for the inquiry, including correspondence intended for Ms Sturgeon. Mr Salmond objected to his involvement because Mr Hynd had authored the complaints procedure later ruled unlawful. A draft reply from Mr Hamilton indicated Mr Hynd subsequently stepped away from any day-to-day role.
Separate documents record Ms Sturgeon telling Mr Hamilton that Mr Salmond warned of the “floodgates” opening over misconduct allegations and that his contact with officials had stirred a “hornets nest”. She said she was “deeply, profoundly shocked” by an account he gave her and later wished she had never discussed the matter with him.
Mr Hamilton ultimately cleared Ms Sturgeon of breaching the code, though he said she had given MSPs an “incomplete narrative” about a key meeting, which he judged to be a genuine lapse of memory rather than deliberate.
Share