A Scottish Labour MP has called on Sir Keir Starmer to resign as Prime Minister after Labour slumped to third place in one of its safest seats in a shock by-election defeat to the Greens.
Brian Leishman said the result in Gorton and Denton showed voters had rejected the "bad judgement calls” of the Prime Minister and his advisers.
The Green Party’s Hannah Spencer secured 14,980 votes — 40.7% of those cast — and a majority of 4,402. Reform UK finished second on 10,578 votes, 28.8%, while Labour’s Angeliki Stogia came third with 9,364 votes, down sharply from the 18,555 secured in the 2024 general election.
Mr Leishman, the MP for Alloa and Grangemouth, has long been said voters had rejected Labour "because of the direction Keir Starmer and the people around him have taken our Labour Party".
"The societal issues communities up and down the country face need real Labour Party values in government to benefit the millions of people that have become worse off after Tory austerity and the cost of living crisis.
"Making things fairer, more equal and improving people’s lives should always be the mission of the Labour Party."
"Instead, Keir Starmer made a selfish mistake in blocking Andy Burnham from standing and it's yet another example of him and his advisers making bad judgement calls.
"I’ve said it for a long time now, the Prime Minister has taken our Labour Party in the wrong direction by trying to out-Reform, Reform.
"We need to be a proper Labour government and live by real Labour Party values. He has proved that he is not the leader that can and will do that. He has to go for the good of Scotland, the UK and the party."
Sir Keir’s leadership has already been under pressure in Scotland, with Anas Sarwar calling for the Prime Minister to quit earlier this month.
Labour party activists are gathering in Paisley for the Scottish Labour conference today. The Prime Minister is not attending.
Mr Sarwar told BBC Radio Scotland: “Look I’ve stated my view but my focus in the next 10 weeks is going to be what happens in Scotland".
He argued that voters north of the border would not automatically link Labour’s performance in England with the Scottish political landscape, claiming the dynamics were fundamentally different after nearly two decades of SNP rule.
“It demonstrates that people everywhere feel angry, feel frustrated and that the electorate is volatile,” he said.
“But I think we do need to be careful not to have an automatic read across to what’s happening in Scotland because of course in Scotland the establishment for the last 20 years has been the SNP and I think that will be a very different framing for an election in 10 weeks time here in Scotland.”
Mr Sarwar said his role was "not to commentate on UK politics" but to "try and persuade people in Scotland".
He pointed to recent by-elections across Britain as evidence that political behaviour varied sharply by nation. While Labour had lost one to Reform and another to Greens, they had won in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse.
"We had a by-election in Scotland, Scottish Labour beat the SNP and gained a seat and it demonstrates to you that politics is different in different parts of the country and that people in Scotland know that the choice they face in 10 weeks is whether we have a new government and a new first minister and only I can deliver that.”
"Reform can't win here, the SNP don't deserve to win. In constituency after constituency across this great country only Scottish Labour can beat the SNP," he added.
Asked about Sir Keir’s absence from the party’s upcoming conference, Mr Sarwar stressed that voters would be judging him rather than the Prime Minister.
“I am the candidate for first minister. Of course it’s a one-day conference rather than the traditional three-day conference."
"Keir Starmer is not on the ballot paper. He was never coming to this conference. I am standing to be first minister. People deserve to know what my view is and what I’m going to do differently in this country.”
Labour MP Karl Turner told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme the result was "catastrophic" for his party. He criticised Sir Keir for block Andy Burnham's bid to contest the by-election.
"I mean, that’s the truth. It couldn’t be any worse.
“Having the Greens in Manchester is the worst result we could have expected or we wanted, frankly.
“But you know, the reality is, Burnham was blocked. He shouldn’t have been, in my view.”
Mr Turner said unpopular policy is the reason Labour came third and lost their majority in the Greater Manchester constituency.
“This is the stuff on Gaza and Palestine and a build-up of policy which is unpopular,” Mr Turner, the MP for Kingston upon Hull East, said.
“And frankly the fact that Andy Burnham was blocked, who was the candidate who gave us our best chance, that’s why we are where we.”
Read more
-
My son is disabled because doctors at 'dirty hospital' gave him anti-infection drugs
-
Families of children left disabled by anti-infection treatment at QEUH hit out at FM
-
Sturgeon: 'I could not have done what I did during Covid without Jeane by my side'
Sir John Curtice cautioned that the result should not be viewed solely as a verdict on Sir Keir’s personal leadership, arguing instead that “two of the key foundations of Labour’s traditional electoral coalition have crumbled away”.
He said Labour’s relative strength among working-class voters had largely disappeared in recent years, with Reform increasingly appealing to that demographic, while the party had also lost ground among minority voters and younger voters — groups that proved decisive in Gorton and Denton.
“The future of British politics is now even more uncertain than it was already,” Prof Curtice added.
Share