Holyrood poll: SNP lead, Labour fourth on list as Reform surges

Fractured Scottish poll bodes ill for Labour and Conservatives this May <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Fractured Scottish poll bodes ill for Labour and Conservatives this May (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Scottish Labour’s difficulties have intensified ahead of May’s Holyrood election, with the party now trailing in fourth on the regional list behind a resurgent Scottish Greens, according to the final Scottish Opinion Monitor (Scoop) poll of the cycle.

The SNP remain firmly ahead on 34% of the constituency vote once “don’t knows” and other non-responses are excluded and weights applied.

The YouGov poll for the Scottish Election Study shows Reform UK are established in second place on 18%, with Labour on 14% .

Pollster Mark Diffley of the Diffley Partnership told The Herald this would result in seat projections of 15 seats for Labour, putting them behind the Greens who would take 16 if this was replicated at the Holyrood election in May.

Seat projections show the SNP would take 57 seats and Reform would gain 22, while the Liberal Democrats would be on 10 and the Conservatives would be trailing behind with 9.

The poll comes after the Greens won one of Labour’s safest seats in the Gorton and Denton by-election in England. Labour placed third after Reform UK.

The Conservatives have also taken a hit, reduced to 10% and now level with the Liberal Democrats - a significant weakening of their position compared with 2021 and a further sign of the fragmentation of the pro-union vote.


READ MORE:


On the regional list ballot, Reform record 19%, while the Scottish Greens climb to a new Scoop high of 16%.

The figures underline a fragmented opposition landscape and a tightening contest for second place behind the SNP.

The survey, conducted online by YouGov between 11 and 18 February among 1,517 Scotland-resident adults aged 16 and over, also highlights significant electoral volatility, with less than half of voters likely to back the same party they supported in 2021

Labour’s position appears particularly precarious. Fewer than one third of those who voted Labour in the 2024 UK General Election say they intend to support the party in May’s constituency ballot. Of that group, 32% plan to remain with Labour, 23% are undecided, 14% have switched to Reform UK and 13% to the SNP.

Dissatisfaction with Sir Keir Starmer’s UK government appears to be weighing heavily. Just 8% of Scots believe the UK Labour government has done a good job. Even among Labour’s 2024 voters, only 15% say it has performed well since the last UK election. .

The Conservatives are retaining just 39% of their 2021 constituency voters, compared with 70% for the Liberal Democrats.

With Reform also competing strongly for pro-union voters — drawing 46% of 2021 Conservative constituency voters and 19% of Labour’s 2021 constituency voters - the unionist vote is now spread across four parties, complicating tactical calculations.

Reform’s support has stabilised in the high teens after its surge in late 2024. If repeated in May, the party would come second to the SNP and become the official opposition at Holyrood

However, its newly appointed Scottish leader, Lord Malcolm Offord, remains relatively unknown. Some 71% of respondents say they do not know who he is when asked to rate political leaders, compared with just 4% unfamiliar with UK-wide leader Nigel Farage.

The data suggest Reform’s brand recognition in Scotland continues to be driven primarily by its UK leadership.

SES Co-Investigator Fraser McMillan, lecturer in Scottish Electoral Politics at the University of Edinburgh, said: “Reform vote intention across both ballots shot up to the high teens at the beginning of 2025 and has remained remarkably stable ever since.

"There has been virtually no difference in the party’s numbers between the constituency and list vote at any point, suggesting their supporters are scunnered with all the other options and therefore not interested in tactical voting considerations.

"This has seriously damaged Conservative prospects for May and hurt Labour at the margins, with Reform now clearly in pole position to become the official opposition after polling day.”

Despite declining satisfaction with the SNP’s performance in government - just 23% say the party is doing a “good job”, down from 40% in December 2021 - the electoral system may once again work in its favour.

The SNP’s continued strength among pro-independence voters on the constituency ballot positions them competitively across Scotland’s 73 first-past-the-post seats. Combined with the Greens’ increasing focus on the list and retreat from most constituency contests, the pro-independence parties could again secure a parliamentary majority.

This comes even though independence itself remains behind in headline terms. In a hypothetical second referendum, 54% would vote No and 46% Yes once undecided voters and other non-responses are removed.

SES Principal Investigator Ailsa Henderson (Professor of Political Science at the University of Edinburgh) said:

“The May 2026 election is taking place in a wider context of anti-incumbent attitudes, and while this continues to hurt the recent and current UK governing parties, the SNP is faring well for three reasons: they are buoyed by support from pro-indy voters, the pro-indy Scottish Greens have opted not to stand candidates in seats where they might have challenged the SNP, and increased competition on the pro-union side of the party spectrum raises demands on pro-union voters hoping to vote strategically. In such an environment, whether the SNP forms a government on its own could well depend on turnout and the level of tactical voting.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos