Analysis

Why Scottish Labour’s 2024 voters are drifting away

Anas Sarwar addressing delegates at party conference in Paisley <i>(Image: Jeff J Mitchell/Getty)</i>
Anas Sarwar addressing delegates at party conference in Paisley (Image: Jeff J Mitchell/Getty)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Through some real bad luck, Scottish Labour’s conference in Paisley, opened just five hours after the declaration in the Gorton and Denton by-election in Manchester.

Delegates woke up to find the Greens had taken what was one of their safest seats, and that Reform had come second.

It wasn't even close. Hannah Spencer, the country’s newest MP, has a majority of 4,402.

At Scottish Labour’s party conference in 2024, Anas Sarwar walked on stage to Unstoppable by Sia.

In 2026, his walk on music was Home by local sea shanty specialist Nathan Evans.

Two years ago, Scottish Labour was unstoppable. Now, Sarwar’s song is the Wellerman crooner’s attempt at a Caledonia for the 21st century — a song about homesickness, where the third verse is about it being “so long since I seen you smile”.

In that momentum-filled speech of 2024, we heard the word “change”, or some form of it, about 61 times in the hour-long address. On Friday, we heard it just nine times in 35 minutes.

At that pre-general election gathering of the party faithful, there was an event by the boffins at the Scottish Election Study. Dr Fraser McMillan told us then that Labour was the “least disliked” party in Scotland, and Anas Sarwar the least unpopular leader.

He sounded a warning though. The switchers who were giving their vote to Labour were soft.

“They are liable to switch again if they see something else that they like more or something from Labour that they dislike,” he told the fringe event.

There was no fringe event on Friday, but just two hours before Sarwar walked on stage, the study dropped a bombshell poll.

The survey, carried out by YouGov for the study, found that the party had fallen to fourth.

Mark Diffley, of the Diffley Partnership, told The Herald that the numbers in the study’s poll would give the SNP 57 MSPs, Reform 22, Greens 16, the Lib Dems 10, and the Tories just nine.

Scottish Labour, however, would take 15 — a fall of seven from the 2021 vote.

Two years ago Labour believed they were unstoppable, now they're going backwards

Scottish Labour has lost more than two-thirds of its 2024 vote. That, it seems, has little to do with Sarwar and almost everything to do with disillusionment with Sir Keir Starmer’s government.

“It is the challenge for the UK-wide parties in Scotland — was ever thus,” Dr McMillan told The Herald.

“The SNP came to power in the first place because faith in Blair and Brown had waned.

“Scottish Labour and the Scottish Conservatives are both victims of this dynamic, with trust in the traditional parties evaporating all over Britain in recent years.

“And as we can see from the by-election in England, Labour are also indirectly threatened by negative polarisation against Reform, with left-liberal voters reaching for whichever option they regard as best placed to keep Farage’s party out in constituency contests.

“In Scotland, the SNP are the most viable non-Reform option in the vast majority of constituencies.”

He shared a table from the study which showed that of those who have left the party, 14% have switched to Reform UK and 13% to the SNP.

“Scattered to the winds does not begin to cover it,” Dr McMillan said. “They have lost roughly equal numbers to Reform and the SNP and the other three parties combined. The 2024 coalition has completely collapsed.”

Could there be some glimmer of hope in the fact that 22% of their former voters are ticking the don’t know box?

Maybe, says Dr McMillan, but with just 10 weeks until the election, it is an uphill battle.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos