Exclusive

Salmond files: Commissioner seeks top civil servant meeting

Scottish Information Commissioner David Hamilton has been critical over how the Scottish Government handled freedom of information requests relating to an inquiry into Nicola Sturgeon <i>(Image: Graphic: Derek McArthur)</i>
Scottish Information Commissioner David Hamilton has been critical over how the Scottish Government handled freedom of information requests relating to an inquiry into Nicola Sturgeon (Image: Graphic: Derek McArthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Scotland’s information watchdog is seeking a meeting with the country's top civil servant as he described the Scottish Government's handling of the release of files relating to an inquiry into Nicola Sturgeon as "shambolic".

David Hamilton, the Scottish Information Commissioner, made the criticism after the documents had to be re-released after the government disclosed the name of a civil servant who had been seconded to work on the ethics probe into former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon.

Ministers said last year the official could not be identified publicly because of data protection. Mr Hamilton had previously ruled the civil servant's "personal data could be withheld".


Read More:


He has written to the Permanent Secretary Joe Griffin to discuss his concerns over how the so-called Salmond files have been handled.

"The shambolic handling of these cases by Scottish Government continues. I had previously ruled that the civil servant in question's personal data could be withheld, the fact that their name was released just typifies the disjointed and chaotic approach taken," he said.

“Data protection breaches are the responsibility of the UK Information Commissioner's Office, but I will be seeking an early meeting with the Permanent Secretary to discuss the approach in 'The Hamilton Inquiry' cases so that I can assess the practice of the Scottish Government and consider whether a third intervention is required."

A spokesman for the Commissioner added: "The Commissioner will be considering whether a third intervention is appropriate - with the unprecedented step of requiring the Scottish Government to cover the cost of this - to address and resolve the serious issues which have come to light through our James Hamilton Inquiry cases."

Mr Hamilton confirmed last week his officials are scrutinising thousands of pages of documents released by the Scottish Government to determine whether ministers have complied with a ruling on the ministerial code inquiry conducted by senior Irish lawyer James Hamilton, the government's independent advisor on the ministerial code, which reported in March 2021.

He told BBC Radio Scotland last week his investigators were assessing the material which he described as "a large, confusing tranche of records" linked to the investigation into Ms Sturgeon.

His interventions come after a long-running battle over access to internal communications about the probe.

Former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon was investigated by James Hamilton (Image: Jeff J Mitchell)

More than 4,700 pages were published by the Scottish Government on Tuesday but then released on Friday following redactions to the civil servant's name.

There was further confusion when one batch of documents, amounting to more than 200 pages, did not appear on the government's website from Friday until Monday.

The government said on Monday afternoon the temporary absence of batch 18 was due to an "administrative error" and the documents had not been withdrawn from publication.

Speaking last week Mr Hamilton said there was “a long way to go yet” before it was clear whether the government has fully met its legal obligations.


Read More:


He told BBC Radio Scotland his office was actively checking compliance because of concerns about how the documents were supplied.

“What my investigators are now doing is assessing that to see whether, in fact, there has been compliance because we’ve had 4,700 pages, frankly, dumped in an unstructured way, which is causing everyone lots of confusion, trying to work out what on earth has been released,” he said.

The original freedom of information request dates back around five years and sought material relating to the investigation by James Hamilton into Ms Sturgeon’s conduct during the fallout from complaints against her predecessor, Alex Salmond.

The Scottish Government initially argued it did not hold the information requested, a position that was later challenged in the Court of Session. The Commissioner said the court “took 21 seconds” to tell the Scottish Government it did.

There then followed a battle over some of the exemptions in the paperwork. There are currently four cases still to be heard at the Court of Session.

The Commissioner was asked if he would still be pushing ahead with the legal action after Tuesday’s data dump.

He told the BBC: “There’s a second request that came in looking at communications surrounding the inquiry, which the government did not contest. And I said that they must give a response to the applicant by January 15, which of course was over five weeks ago.

“They missed that deadline, missed the second extension I gave them to get things through. And on that basis, reported them for contempt of court because they’re breaking the law. And to be honest, there’s been a bizarre kind of toing and froing in terms of how this plays out in public. But at the moment, it is still a live case at the Court of Session."

The material — comprising emails, legal notes, draft correspondence and administrative records — released by the government on Tuesday last week contains extensive redactions.

Asked whether Scotland has a systemic secrecy problem, Mr Hamilton was broadly positive about public sector transparency but said difficulties tend to arise when requests concern sensitive or politically contentious matters.

He also suggested the handling of requests connected to the Hamilton investigation had been particularly problematic.

"There are cases where it all goes wrong and that’s exactly what’s happened,” he said.

The documents released last Tuesday show the independent adviser feared his report would be “dishonest” if he was forced to omit key material because of legal restrictions.

Draft correspondence from James Hamilton revealed he at one stage halted progress on his findings amid disputes over anonymity and identification.

The redactions stemmed from legal constraints linked to Mr Salmond’s criminal trial and his successful judicial review, as well as wider concerns around privacy, data protection and defamation.

Mr Hamilton cleared Ms Sturgeon of breaching the code, though he said she had given MSPs an “incomplete narrative” about a key meeting, which he judged to be a genuine lapse of memory rather than deliberate.

A Scottish Government spokesman said: “The Permanent Secretary has received the Information Commissioner’s letter and will respond in due course.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos