Scotland's information commissioner has launched a stinging attack on ministers' handling of freedom of information requests relating to an ethics inquiry into Nicola Sturgeon saying he can 'no longer trust the government' to deal with the matter.
David Hamilton released a strongly-worded statement on the latest development in a long-running freedom of information battle over files relating to the probe into Ms Sturgeon by James Hamilton, the independent advisor on the ministerial code.
Shortly after his statement was published he highlighted his possible course of action on social media.
He posted on X: "A second contempt of court proceedings looms for the Scottish Government. This has just got murkier."
Read More:
- Files reveal 'Hamilton probe into Sturgeon was a cover up'
- First batch of Salmond files released by Scottish Government
- Scot Gov told to release evidence into Nicola Sturgeon probe
- Salmond files: Commissioner seeks top civil servant meeting
On Thursday afternoon his office explained that the Commissioner wrote to the Permanent Secretary Joe Griffin in early February this year seeking assurances that ministers had complied with a decision he made relating to the case in September 2024.
That decision was that the government should release all legal advice given to it in relation to his earlier decision on whether it 'held' evidence relating to the probe into Ms Sturgeon by James Hamilton, the independent advisor on the ministerial code.
A statement published on the Scottish Information Commissioner's website today said the government had advised the watchdog that it had complied with his ruling but refused the Commissioner access to withheld information he needed to see in order to check this was indeed the case.
Former First Minister Alex Salmond (Image: Jeff J Mitchell)
"Therefore, at the time, the Commissioner had to take ministers at their word that compliance had been achieved," it said.
"During a related court case in January 2026, the Commissioner became alert to the prospect that some of that legal advice had not been released and sought reassurance.
"A response has finally been received which the Commissioner considers demonstrates that the Scottish Government has failed to comply with his 2024 Decision."
It added: "He is now consulting with lawyers on certifying this non-compliance to the Court of Session, allowing the court to inquire into a second case of contempt of court."
David Hamilton said: “Perhaps worse than the fact that Scottish Ministers have once again failed to comply with one of my decisions, is that they appear to have tried to conceal this breach of trust with unjustified delays and a wall of silence.
"The excuses I have now been given, both in writing and in person, are preposterous and unacceptable.
"I have now met with the Permanent Secretary and have expressed my dismay. I can no longer trust the government to handle this information unsupervised and will explore more intrusive options to ensure compliance."
Scottish Conservative MSP Murdo Fraser said the Commissioner's statement was "scathing" of the government.
He said: “This is a scathing verdict from the information commissioner on the sleekit behaviour of the SNP government.
“It is clear the nationalists were prepared to use every trick in the book to avoid complying with this ruling.
“That is typical of the culture of the secrecy that has been the hallmark of their two decades in power and it stinks."
He added: “The SNP cannot dismiss the commissioner’s latest rebuke and must now take urgent steps to rectify this situation.”
In January this year, the Commissioner warned the Scottish Government faced potential contempt of court proceedings if files relating to evidence given to the Hamilton investigation were not released by the end of the following week.
“I have now instructed the commencement of our non-compliance procedures following a late intimation to me that the Scottish government would fail to meet the deadline set,” Mr Hamilton said.
The former First Minister referred herself to the independent adviser on the ministerial code in response to allegations she had misled Holyrood in relation to the inquiry into a botched investigation of harassment complaints against her predecessor, Alex Salmond.
Senior Irish lawyer Mr Hamilton concluded in his report of March 2021 that Ms Sturgeon did not breach the ministerial code relating to her conduct in dealing with the allegations.
However, in a two-page note, he underlined his frustration with a considerable number of redactions that were made to the document ahead of its publication by the Scottish Government.
Last month the Scottish Government released thousands of pages of documents relating to Mr Hamilton's inquiry with many files substantially redacted.
The Commissioner's latest intervention relates to a freedom of information request seeking communications surrounding the legal advice given to ministers about a court action they took to oppose the publication of the files.
A member of the public Benjamin Harrop sought the release of the government's legal advice and communications after ministers lost its case against the Commissioner in the Court of Session.
In October 2024 the Scottish Government took the unusual step of publishing the legal advice received by ministers in relation to the case.
Writing on X on Thursday evening Mr Harrop underlined what he said was the significance of Mr Hamilton's intervention.
He said: "This from the Scottish Information Commissioner is quite extraordinary. To be clear since 2005, the SIC has never referred a public authority to the Court for non-compliance/contempt of court. He has now done so twice this year over FOIs submitted by me in relation to the Hamilton inquiry."
He added: "I think the FM [First Minister] or someone in Government needs to make a statement in Parliament. This is completely unprecedented, and the Government has serious questions to answer."
First Minister John Swinney previously told parliament that the freedom of information requests had been complicated by the need to make redactions to avoid identifying women who had made allegations against Salmond.
Mr Salmond successfully sued the government in 2019 over its mishandling of complaints against him.
The former first minister, who died in 2024, was cleared of sexually assaulting nine women in following a trial at the High Court in Edinburgh in 2020.
A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: “The Permanent Secretary met the Scottish Information Commissioner on 11 March and assured him that these cases were being handled properly, in line with statutory duties and with the highest standards of impartiality and integrity.”
Share