Exclusive

FM urged to address MSPs after 'unprecedented' criticism

Nicola Sturgeon and John Swinney pictured in the Holyrood chamber when Ms Sturgeon was First Minister and Mr Swinney was Deputy First Minister. <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Nicola Sturgeon and John Swinney pictured in the Holyrood chamber when Ms Sturgeon was First Minister and Mr Swinney was Deputy First Minister. (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Fergus Ewing has called for John Swinney to give a statement to Holyrood after the Scottish Information Commissioner said he could "no longer trust the government" in handling freedom of information (FOI) requests relating to an ethics inquiry into Nicola Sturgeon.

The former SNP cabinet minister, who now sits as an independent, described David Hamilton's criticism as "unprecedented" by a public servant and wants the First Minister to come to parliament in person before it dissolves this month to address the remarks.

Mr Ewing was close friend of the late First Minister Alex Salmond and has been a prominent critic of the government's handling of FOI requests relating to the probe into Ms Sturgeon.


Read More:


Ms Sturgeon was cleared of breaching the ministerial code in the inquiry by the government's independent advisor who examined her conduct in relation to meetings and discussions with Mr Salmond in 2018 after two civil servant had made allegations of sexual misconduct against him.

However, senior Irish lawyer James Hamilton who carried out the investigation, expressed his frustration with a considerable number of redactions that were made to the document ahead of its publication by the government.

The government said the redactions were made because of court orders in place to protect the identities of people who had made complaints against Mr Salmond.

Former First Minister Alex Salmond died in October 2024 (Image: NQ)

Following the publication of the report into Ms Sturgeon in March 2021, a series of FOIs were submitted to the government seeking evidence relating to the probe.

Some of these requests have been at the centre of a long-running dispute between the Commissioner and the government.

The latest row erupted on Thursday when David Hamilton accused the government of using "preposterous and unacceptable" excuses to prevent legal advice linked to the case from being released.

Fergus Ewing was a close ally of Alex Salmond (Image: Colin Mearns/PA)

He said ministers had "once again failed" to comply with one of his decisions regarding the disclosure of information.

In his letter on Friday to Mr Swinney, which has been shared with The Herald, Mr Ewing said the latest criticism made by Mr Hamilton went to "the very heart of the government's reputation".

He said: "The Commissioner... states that he no longer has trust in the Scottish Government. This criticism in itself is surely not only unprecedented but one which goes to the very heart of the reputation of your government."

Mr Ewing went onto note that Mr Hamilton alluded to criticisms made over the way in which the government released around 4500 pages of documents - dubbed the "Salmond files" - from the inquiry into Ms Sturgeon.

Scottish Information Commissioner David Hamilton (Image: Graphic: Derek McArthur)

And he asked whether the way the "dump" of documents last month was done in "haphazard" way to deliberately to stifle scrutiny.

He pointed out Mr Swinney had been responsible for handling the release of documents to a Holyrood inquiry into the Scottish Government's flawed handling of complaints into Mr Salmond and with the administration faced criticism then of the way information had been published.

"You were then in charge of that process too." Mr Ewing said in his letter to Mr Swinney.

"I would be grateful if you can in particular address whether this practice was adopted deliberately by the Scottish Government, and if that is denied, why there was not a proper  and orderly presentation  of such a large number of documents."

He added: "It is difficult for me to fathom any other reason for this approach than an attempt by the Scottish Government in “damage limitation” by making the process of piecing together what happened very difficult or impossible  - a bit like attempting a jigsaw with no picture."

He continued: "I am sure you will agree that there has never been since 1999, in the history of the Scottish Parliament, any previous instance where the most senior public servant, rightly independent of government, charged with being the guardian of freedom of information in Scotland, has delivered such an utterly damning verdict on your government, nor one delivered in such coruscating terms and language."

He urged the First Minister to "make a ministerial statement" to explain what he is doing to respond to the criticisms.

Mr Hamilton is already taking a contempt court action against the Scottish Government as part of the dispute relating to the inquiry into Ms Sturgeon.


Read More:


On Thursday he raised the possibility of  new legal case saying he would have to "explore more intrusive options to ensure compliance".

It came after a letter from the Scottish Government's most senior civil servant, Permanent Secretary Joe Griffin, said while all legal advice within the scope of the freedom of information request had been released, some information had been "withheld" which "included legal advice, as well as other information subject to litigation privilege".

Mr Griffin stressed, however, the case had involved the "disclosure of a substantial amount of material".

The Information Commissioner, however, is now consulting with lawyers on whether to raise this "non-compliance" with the Court of Session - a move which could allow the court to inquire into a second possible case of contempt of court.

In his statement Mr Hamilton said: "Perhaps worse than the fact that Scottish ministers have once again failed to comply with one of my decisions is that they appear to have tried to conceal this breach of trust with unjustified delays and a wall of silence.

"The excuses I have now been given, both in writing and in person, are preposterous and unacceptable."

Mr Salmond won a judicial review against the government in 2019 with the Court of Session ruling that the way the government had investigated complaints against him by two civil servants was "unlawful" and "tainted by apparent bias". In 2020 he was acquitted of charges of sexual offences following a criminal trial at the High Court in Edinburgh.

After his acquittal, a Holyrood committee examined how the government had mishandled the its investigation into Mr Salmond.

The former First Minister died in October 2024 after suffering a heart attack while attending a conference in North Macedonia.

The Scottish Government said on Thursday in response to Mr Hamilton's statement: “The Permanent Secretary met the Scottish Information Commissioner on 11 March and assured him that these cases were being handled properly, in line with statutory duties and with the highest standards of impartiality and integrity.”

A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: "The Scottish Government has answered more than 13,000 FOI requests since the start of 2024, with over 95% responded to on time.  The Commissioner has raised compliance concerns in relation to two of those cases.  

“One of those relates to a delay in compliance of just over four weeks, due to the scale and complexity of material involved, with more than 700 documents, comprising more than 4,500 pages published.

 “The other relates to concerns over interpretation of the scope of a request which resulted in the unusual step of legal advice received by ministers in relation to a Court case being published in October 2024.  That material remains published with the advice freely available to view.”

 It is understood the Scottish Government will respond to Mr Ewing’s letter in due course

 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos