The contrast of this SNP conference to a year ago is almost hard to believe. As John Swinney stood on stage to deliver his speech, there was a noticeable lack of anger compared to his political rival Anas Sarwar.
Inside the SNP’s campaign conference, party delegates were jubilant. There was confidence that John Swinney’s strategy of securing a majority – of at least 65 seats – is the right one.
But a lot rests on it, including the future of the SNP leadership.
A fortnight ago, Mr Sarwar, the Scottish Labour leader, asked voters to “hold your nose” and vote for his party. But for the SNP leader, the message was one of optimism.
John Swinney asked the country to back him as his party leads a “great wave of change”.
“The opportunity before us is enormous – but we have to reach out and grab it,” he said, as he stressed the SNP’s target of a majority.
But Mr Swinney’s party has been in government for around 19 years and the party’s popularity has taken a dip as voters become disgruntled with the speed of progress.
Under the leadership of Nicola Sturgeon, the SNP won around 48% of the constituency vote and 40% of the regional ballot in 2021.
But the SNP’s popularity has taken a dip in recent years, with polling putting the party’s support in the mid to high thirties for the constituency vote and low thirties for the regional.
Seat projections vary. Pollsters have estimated a return of between 57 and 64 seats. Just one poll has put the SNP on a majority – the target set by party leader Mr Swinney.
Read more:
- Sick pay arrangements tightened for police officers in Scotland amid budget concerns
- SNP announce Sally Donald replacement in Holyrood election following benefits probe
- Swinney: Scottish independence is 'within grasp' as he shrugs off 'failure' criticism
The SNP last secured a majority in 2011 under Alex Salmond’s leadership. But Mr Swinney has insisted his party can replicate this result. If he fails, like the polls consistently suggest he will, the consequences are massive.
The SNP’s current independence strategy has been gambled on securing a majority of MSPs. This, he says, is the only way to secure an independence referendum.
In that 2014 referendum, 55% of Scots voted against independence, with 45% backing it. That has led to critics to criticise a second plebiscite, quoting Mr Salmond who referred to the vote as “once in a generation”.
It looks increasingly unlikely that the SNP will secure that desired majority. So what happens if Mr Swinney failed in his defining mission?
Dr Fraser McMillan, of Edinburgh University, told The Herald: “From a strategic point of view, he has done the right thing when it comes to independence in terms of talking about it enough to keep SNP voters on board and folk within his own party happy.
“But he has deliberately set a high bar for pursuing a second independence referendum.”
He added: “He knows that even if he gets a majority, the UK Government will say no regardless. So, he is kind of in a strategic sweet spot.
“He probably won’t have to actually deal with the issue and he’s still able to talk about it enough to keep those pro-independence voters on board.”
Talks of a succession plan will always haunt every SNP leader after Ms Sturgeon’s shock resignation more than three years ago.
But even if the SNP do fail to secure a majority, don’t expect Mr Swinney to step aside immediately.
Mr Swinney’s position is particularly safe because he came in when “expectations” were so low, the elections expert said.
After all, just 18 months ago, the prospects of the SNP were bleak. The general election results were, to put it mildly, a disaster.
The party fell from 39 seats to just nine, with Mr Swinney in the job a matter of months by then after taking over from Humza Yousaf.
Mr Swinney seems unfazed by any suggestion his time as leader could be coming to an end. In his speech, he said: “We are ready. Ready to fight the election. Ready to fight for Scotland. And ready to win our independence.
“The progress we have made is because we’ve put Scotland, and the people’s priorities first.”
“Quite simply, Westminster is broken,” he said.
Read more:
- Union Cross fire: John Swinney announces £10m rebuild fund for Glasgow
- Argyll and Bute councillor defects to Reform UK from Scottish Tories
- 'Open secret': Senior Tories warn MSP could face allegations of sexual misconduct
“The Westminster parties want you to believe that this is as good as it gets. The SNP will never accept that because we know a much brighter future for Scotland is ours to build,” he said.
Following the general election, it looked likely Scottish Labour leader Mr Sarwar would become first minister, but his chances have been scuppered by Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer’s leadership in No 10.
That Mr Swinney has significantly turned his party fortunes around is no small feat. In the midst of it all, there has been Operation Branchform, the police probe into SNP finances and the saga around the scandal-hit Queen Elizabeth University Hospital (QEUH).
Mr McMillan said it was a “blessing in disguise” for the SNP when Humza Yousaf’s tenure in charge ended in disaster.
“It gave them a safe pair of hands to manage them through a difficult period,” he said.
“Approval of the Scottish Government at the start of this parliamentary term, amongst pro-independence voters, was up at 80% and now it’s down to around 50%.
“But that drop off has been arrested when Swinney came in and since then they’ve stayed at that point far enough ahead of other parties after Labour’s vote share massively dropped off.”
But talks will undoubtably be going on in the background on who will take over as SNP leader – and as first minister.
Mr Swinney has given a commitment to serve as leader until the end of the next parliament, in 2031.
“I suspect that’s not the case and they will have a leadership succession sometime in the middle of the parliament,” Mr McMillan said.
Inside the SNP conference, however, there are no signs of discontent. Even his closest leadership rival – Westminster party leader Stephen Flynn – suggested Mr Swinney was just getting started.
But if the SNP fail to secure that majority – which SNP members have been clear is the only justified way to another independence referendum – questions are undoubtedly going to plague the leadership.
While it was not the nail in Ms Sturgeon’s leadership coffin, her failure to make progress damaged her popularity within her own supporter base.
The independence movement has been incredibly fractured in recent years but the demise of Alba leaves many looking to the SNP to deliver another vote.
If Mr Swinney cannot deliver on that, the unity felt inside the main hall of the Edinburgh International Conference Centre (EICC) will shatter.
Share