Swinney calls commissioner criticism in Salmond files row ‘strange’

John Swinney <i>(Image: Agency)</i>
John Swinney (Image: Agency)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

First Minister John Swinney has described criticism from Scotland’s information watchdog as “a bit of a strange comment” as a growing dispute over the release of documents linked to the Salmond inquiry intensifies.

Speaking on the BBC Scotland Sunday Show on Sunday morning, Mr Swinney defended the Scottish Government’s record on freedom of information (FOI) compliance after Scotland’s independent information commissioner said he could no longer trust ministers to handle certain information without supervision.

The remarks follow a warning from David Hamilton that he may seek a second contempt of court action against the Scottish Government over its handling of legal advice relating to files connected to the investigation into former first minister Nicola Sturgeon.


READ MORE:


Asked about the commissioner’s comments, Mr Swinney said: “I found this a bit of a strange comment from the commissioner because just the other week there the commissioner was saying that generally the Scottish Government is very good at handling freedom of information requests.

“In the last month, we have had 97% performance of meeting freedom of information requests on time. The government is really good at dealing with freedom of information. The stuff in the Hamilton report is very tricky because the government has got to be mindful of court orders that are in place.”

The commissioner’s intervention came after he accused ministers of failing to release legal advice required under a decision he issued in 2024 concerning the disclosure of material linked to an inquiry by independent adviser James Hamilton into whether Ms Sturgeon breached the ministerial code.

In a strongly worded statement, Mr Hamilton said the government had provided explanations for withholding information that were “preposterous and unacceptable”.

He added he had now lost confidence in the government’s handling of the matter, warning: “I can no longer trust the government to handle this information unsupervised and will explore more intrusive options to ensure compliance.”

Responding to the criticism, Mr Swinney said: “These are the commissioner’s words and I can’t script what the commissioner says but what I can say is the government is acting and conforming to its legal duties to make sure that we comply with court orders and I just will do nothing, absolutely nothing, that risks disclosing the identities or leading to the disclosure of identities of individuals who have been victims.”

The dispute centres on a long-running freedom of information battle over documents connected to the handling of complaints against former first minister Alex Salmond and the subsequent political fallout.

The commissioner said ministers had previously assured his office that they had complied with a ruling to release all relevant legal advice relating to his earlier decision about whether the government held evidence linked to the probe into Ms Sturgeon. However, during a related court case earlier this year he became aware that some of that advice might not have been disclosed.

His office said a later response from the government appeared to show that ministers had failed to comply fully with the 2024 decision, prompting him to consult lawyers about referring the matter to the Court of Session over a potential second case of contempt.

The row is the latest development in the fallout from the Scottish Government’s handling of harassment complaints against Mr Salmond, which led to a successful legal challenge by the former first minister in 2019. Mr Salmond, who died in 2024, was later acquitted of sexual assault charges at a trial in 2020.

The government has previously argued that redactions and delays in releasing documents have been necessary to comply with court orders and to protect the identities of women who made allegations against Mr Salmond.

However, the commissioner’s latest warning raises the prospect of further legal scrutiny of ministers’ compliance with freedom of information rulings.

During his interview on the Sunday Show, the First Minister also insisted he is being "honest" with the public about a £5 billion blackhole in the Scottish Government's finances as he added that the number of people working in the public sector would have to be reduced.

The Auditor General and Fraser of Allander Institute have both warned the Government faces a £5 billion blackhole in its budget and has called for "honesty" from political parties about how to fill it.

Responding to those comments, Scottish Labour's Jackie Baillie said: "John Swinney has once again refused to give a straight answer on the black hole he has created in Scotland’s finances. 

"Despite record levels of funding from a Labour government, and ordinary Scots seeing the SNP raise taxes to record highs, public services are getting worse. 

"People are entitled to ask: where has the money gone?

"Dishonest John and the SNP’s failure can end with a Scottish Labour government who will fix the mess, get the basics right and deliver the economic growth Scotland needs.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos