This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politicsnewsletter.
There is a belief among some in Holyrood that Reform UK’s support will crumble as soon as their policy pitch to voters comes under real scrutiny in the white heat of an election campaign.
That people flirting with putting Nigel Farage's pals into the Scottish Parliament will take fright as soon as Malcolm Offord faces his first TV debate with the other party chiefs.
It's a no doubt comforting belief for some of the spin doctors and strategists preparing for an election in just 48 days, but after attending a briefing with the boffins at the Scottish Election Study , I think it might also be borderline delusional.
Read more
-
Why has Police Scotland chief Jo Farrell been given an eyewatering pay rise?
-
'It took a smart English police chief to do what Scotsmen fear: call out Old Firm'
-
Why is health rising up the agenda for voters once more ahead of Holyrood 2026?
-
Inside John Curtice's latest election briefing - insights and forecasts
Three times a year, for their SCOOP monitor , Professor Ailsa Henderson and Dr Fraser McMillan poll around 1,200 voters to track how opinion is shifting between elections.
What we know is that Reform surged to between 15% and 20% of the vote almost immediately after the UK general election in July 2024.
What is striking is that since then that support has barely shifted.
Reform is doing particularly well among older men — particularly those aged 45 to 54 without a university degree, where backing for the party reaches into the mid-30s.
Much of Reform’s support comes from former Conservative voters. But it is not simply a Tory story.
The data shows Reform drawing from across the political spectrum, including a fair chunk of disillusioned Labour voters.
Labour’s 2021 coalition, in particular, appears to be fragmenting, with Reform one of the beneficiaries.
The researchers asked Reform voters directly why they were backing the party. The single biggest reason, cited by 45%, is that Reform is “the only party serious about tackling immigration”.
While that is the core of the party’s appeal, the second and third answers are arguably more revealing.
A quarter of Reform voters say the party “cannot be any worse than anyone else”. A further 8% say that actually there is “no real difference” between the other main parties.
Taken together, that means roughly a third of Reform’s support is not driven by policy at all, but by frustration with the status quo — what Professor Henderson called “anti-politics grounds”.
“What Reform have done is they have filled a gap in the electoral market,” said Dr McMillan. “Between one in seven and one in five Scottish voters wants a party that is anti-establishment, anti-immigration, anti-net zero, anti-woke — the kind of classic populist combination.
“And they were not really getting that with the Scottish Conservatives before.”
But — and maybe this will be of interest to the other parties — there is a ceiling.
Reform is now the most disliked party in Scotland.
When voters are asked to name the party they dislike most, nearly half choose Reform. On the “propensity to vote” scale — where zero means “I would never vote for this party” — more than 70% of the electorate give Reform a zero.
Then there is the leadership problem. Nigel Farage remains, in the researchers’ words, the least popular major political figure in Scotland.
The only leader who is less popular than Farage is Donald Trump.
Reform may already have “maxed out their natural pool of voters”, says Dr McMillan.
Get Scotland's top politics newsletter straight to your inbox.
The academics said the other way that the party could well reshape Scottish politics is through its impact on tactical voting.
In 2021, tactical voting in Scotland was overwhelmingly about stopping the SNP. Around 83% of those who said they were voting tactically were doing so for that reason. By 2026, that figure has fallen to 53%.
Why the drop? Because for the first time, a substantial share of voters say they are choosing candidates to keep Reform out.
The researchers describe this as “anti-Reform negative polarisation” and suggest it could become a defining feature of British politics over the next decade.
The effect is particularly visible among Labour voters, whose tactical vote is now split: roughly half aimed at stopping the SNP, half at stopping Reform.
That's not great news for Labour and creates a more complex electoral landscape for everyone else.
Reform, then, is both a disruptor and a constraint.
It has created a new, durable bloc of voters — disproportionately male, older, and disillusioned — who are not easily shifted and not interested in playing the usual tactical games.
But it has also triggered an equal and opposite reaction: a large, equally firm bloc of voters who will do almost anything to stop it.
Share