Inside the mood in Reform UK as Farage eyes Scotland

Nigel Farage and Malcolm Offord on stage at Reform UK's conference in Bishopton on Thursday, March 19. <i>(Image: Colin Mearns)</i>
Nigel Farage and Malcolm Offord on stage at Reform UK's conference in Bishopton on Thursday, March 19. (Image: Colin Mearns)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The most well-known anecdote about Nigel Farage and Scotland relates to how he had to be locked into pub in Edinburgh and escorted out for his own safety by the police after being "ambushed" by independence supporters.

The story about an incident experienced by the Reform UK leader (then UKIP leader) in 2013, captures the hostility of many Scots to the populist right wing English politician.

It is one that has been influential in how he has been perceived north of the Border for many years.

As recently as June 2024, his deputy Richard Tice told journalists Scotland was "too dangerous" for Mr Farage when asked whether his boss would be visiting Scotland ahead of the general election the following week after reporters pointed to his absence from the campaign trail.

Now it seems the MP for Clacton can hardly keep away.


Read More:


Mr Farage may once have been rather embarrassed by the Canon's Gait pub saga but as he closed his speech to a jubilant party faithful at its Scottish conference on Thursday he drew attention to the tale to illustrate how times have changed.

So how has a politician once chased out of Edinburgh reached a position where some 20% of the country's voters are prepared to support his party at the Holyrood election?

For people who have joined Reform UK Scotland, led by former Tory minister Malcolm Offord, the answer is fairly straightforward.

They like Mr Farage's hard-line stance on immigration, his attacks on net zero, his demand for low taxation, his sense that things are "broken" and that he and his party offer "change".

Retired nurse Evelyn Rollo, 63, said he first grabbed her attention when he appeared on the I'm A Celebrity... Get Me Out of Here!

The former Scottish Conservative voter joined Reform after seeing Mr Farage on the ITV reality show in 2023 and told The Herald that now all her friends and her friends' husbands are backing Reform having previously been SNP and Conservative voters.

"People need change," she said.

"I was a Conservative voter all my life until I went to Reform."

Retired nurse Evelyn Rollo joined Reform (Image: Colin Mearns)

Enjoying the sunshine, while standing in the long queue to get into the conference, held at the Ingliston County Club in Bishopton, Renfrewshire, fellow Reform members Neil Harding and Fraser McIntyre explained why they joined the party.

"The main reason I joined was because it was the only party speaking any sense about net zero," said Mr Harding, 44, a plumber and a gas engineer from Edinburgh.

"Net zero has been a disaster for Scotland and the UK as a whole."

He said energy bills were "sky-rocketing" while subsidies were being given to renewable energy devices such as solar panels which he said were of little use for much of the year.

Reform UK Scotland members Fraser McIntyre, left, and Neil Harding (Image: Colin Mearns)

Mr McIntyre, 48, from Grangemouth, said he joined because he agreed with Reform's stance on low taxation.

"For me it was taxation," he said but he also pointed out the state of the economy and a lack of good jobs for young people were other reasons why he joined the party.

"I live in Grangemouth. The refinery was the hub of the town for a long time and it was a shock when it closed," he said.

"There used to be good jobs around for people but now we have the young generation coming up and they have McDonald's or working in a call centre. We need plumbers. We need mechanics. And there seems to be no enthusiasm in the government to encourage that."

John Robertson, 60, from Dunfermline, a retired station commander for Scottish Fire and Rescue, was also among the party members queuing to go into the hall.

He joined because of the party's opposition to net zero noting global carbon emissions would hardly fall if the UK got to net zero while larger countries continued to "guzzle" fossil fuels.

"What difference is it going to make worldwide when we've got the superpowers guzzling oil and coal?" he asked.

Collecting his conference registration wrist band Gary Taggart, 57, from Greenock, said he believed "change" was needed and that he agreed with Reform's stance on immigration.

"I joined Reform because I want a change for the better for the British public and I want to stop all illegal immigrants coming into the country," he said.

Mr Taggart told The Herald he was currently not working and was receiving disability benefits. Reform want a major reduction in the welfare budget but he was not concerned that he would lose any benefits should Reform be elected to government.

Dressed in Union Jack trousers and holding up a T shirt saying "Put Farage in Charge" Mr Taggart was later delighted to be dragged onto the stage by Mr Farage ahead of his conference address.

Reform UK member Gary Taggart with Nigel Farage (Image: Colin Mearns)

On Thursday members got to their feet and cheered as Mr Farage slid onto the stage showman-like in slow motion making the anticipation among the audience crescendo.

Yet while Mr Farage is hugely adored by Reform members, he and his party are deeply unpopular among a vast chunk of other Scots.

According to the latest Scottish Election Study, which is carried out by Professor Ailsa Henderson and Dr Fraser McMillan at Edinburgh University, when voters are asked to name the party they dislike most, nearly half choose Reform.

On the “propensity to vote” scale — where zero means “I would never vote for this party” — more than 70% of the electorate give Reform a zero.

And the study, which is based on a poll of  around 1,200 voters, Mr Farage is "the least popular major political figure in Scotland".



Read More:


So how can a party with such a poor popularity score have reached a position where polling puts it currently on course to be Holyrood's second largest behind the SNP?

Dr McMillan said: "Reform support is drawn from a few places. About half of their current vote intention is direct transfers from the Conservatives, with the rest pieced together from various other parties, approximately one in five Reform supporters voted Labour in 2021, and previous non-voters.

"The traditional Westminster parties have both taken a big reputational hit in the last few years and it's not surprising that voters would peel off in different directions."

He added: "We asked those who indicated they would support Reform in May or in a Westminster election why they would vote for the party.

"Nearly half said they were the only party serious about tackling immigration. Another quarter said 'at least it's something new and they can't be as bad as the others'. So the 'core' supporter is motivated by the party's stance on the issues, and another chunk are basically "scunnered" with politics in general."

Delegates at the Reform UK conference in Bishopton (Image: Colin Mearns)

James Mitchell, professor of public policy at Edinburgh University, also thought that much of the position Reform finds itself in currently has a considerable amount to do with the weaknesses of its rivals - in particular of the Labour UK Government and the SNP Scottish Government.

"Reform’s support in the polls and hype it generates - though not matched in actual elections - is explained by a body of deeply disaffected voters, unhappy with the UK Labour Government and the SNP Scottish Government," he told The Herald.

Professor Mitchell believed that Reform's support was "soft" and would likely unravel as polling day drew nearer and its candidates and policies were more closely scrutinised.

"Reform’s support has been in decline since the end of last year and appears to have peaked across Britain and there is no reason to believe that is not true in Scotland.  It is also likely that Reform Scotland will come under greater scrutiny as we approach the election and the decline will continue," he said.

Professor Mitchell added that it's most likely impact will be as "a political spoiler" (by eating into the support for other others).

"Its chances of winning any constituencies are at best negligible," he said noting its manifesto aim to reduce the number of constitutency MSPs from 73 to 57.

"Its policy of reducing the number of constituencies suggests that it knows that.  The most likely outcomes of its intervention in constituency battles will be to help the SNP retain seats. Its best chances are on the lists."

Nigel Farage and Malcolm Offord launch Reform's Holyrood manifesto and parliamentary candidates (Image: Colin Mearns)

On Friday afternoon the think tank the Institute for Fiscal Studies published a highly critical analysis of the party's manifesto committee to align Scottish income tax to UK levels and then cut tax rates further so that by the end of the parliament the Scottish income tax rates would be three percentage points below the rest of the UK.

The IFS said the plans, first unveiled in January would cost around £4 billion a yea and were "not credible".

"The manifesto repeats plans to pay for these tax cuts by ending spending on ‘net zero’ initiatives and unspecified cuts to spending managed by ‘quangos’.

"As we highlighted when these plans were first announced in January, the Scottish fiscal framework means that cuts to capital investment – which includes much of the spending on ‘net zero’ initiatives – cannot be used to pay for tax cuts. Reform UK also claims that the income tax cuts would in fact pay for themselves via higher economic growth. This is not credible."

Under scrutiny in the heat of a election campaign for the next six weeks, can Reform remain on course to be main opposition party in Holyrood?

Already one Reform candidate Stuart Niven, just announced on Thursday, has been suspended and it's possible that others may well come a cropper as May 7 approaches.

Dr McMillan said he "wouldn't be surprised" if Labour gain some ground back and finishes in second so long as it is able to concentrate voters' minds on this being a Scottish election with the party challenging a 20 year incumbent government led by the SNP.

"Labour's focus on the 'time for a change' and 'boot out the SNP' message is the right strategy, it just might not be effective given the extreme unpopularity of the UK government, " he said.

"Scandals around candidates could hurt Reform, potentially pushing away the less-committed share of their voters, although it may also depend on which constituencies or regions it happens in. There's also a risk in 'going too far' on culture war and identity issues. They will get a decent clutch of seats either way, but at the margins there are people who could be put off."

Dr McMillan's close examination of the country's political mood suggests the next six weeks will be vital.

"As it stands, I'd say Reform are currently best-placed to finish as runners up, but given how close they and Labour are in the polls, the impact of the campaign could go either way," he said.

It's certainly going to be an election campaign to watch.

 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos